Vegetative growth parameters
Response of plant height to variety in both cropping periods of 2019 was significant (
P<0.05) with Omankwa being taller than Pannar 12 (Table 3). However, levels of N application did not significantly (P>0.05) influence plant height. The combined effects of maize variety and fertilizer on plant height in the main and minor cropping periods of 2019 were significant (P<0.05) (Table 4). In the main cropping period of 2019, the tallest maize plants (63.83 cm) were associated with application of N at 120 kg ha
-1 to Omankwa plants, while the Pannar 12 plants, which were not treated with fertilizer were the shortest (44.67 cm) (Table 3). Omankwa was generally taller than Pannar 12 under both nutrient-applied conditions and non-nutrient-applied conditions (Table 4). In the minor cropping period of 2019, Omankwa crops grown with 120 kg N ha
-1 were the tallest (62.9 cm), whereas Pannar 12 crops grown with no fertilizer were the shortest (44.40 cm).
Plant height increased in Omankwa relative to Pannar 12 in both seasons of the trial (Tables 3 and 4) probably because the former may be more efficient in dry matter distribution in support of plant height than the latter. Overall, application of nutrients did better than the no fertilizer treatment in terms of plant height probably because sufficient N application increases division and elongation of cells, nucleus formation and green leaves. This helps to increase the chlorophyll composition of leaves to speed up the photosynthetic rate and extension of stem, culminating in tallness in plants.
Gul et al., (2021) and
Anjum et al., (2018) reported that plant height increased due to application of huge quantities of nitrogen. Similarly, findings of
Namvar and Sharifi (2016) indicated that, increasing the rate of N fertilizer increased internodal extension, plant height and good vegetative development. In a similar study,
Adhikari et al., (2016) found that N increased the number and length of internodes, which increased height of the maize plant.
Both variety and different rates of N application significantly (P<0.05) affected mean number of leaves in the main cropping period of 2019 (Table 3). Omankwa had more leaves than Pannar 12. Mean number of leaves was highest (8) as a result of application of N at 90 kg ha
-1. The lowest treatment effect of 6.75 was observed in the control treatment. All the fertilizer-applied treatments were similar in effect, but differed significantly from the control. In the minor cropping period of 2019, mean number of leaves was not significantly (P
>0.05) affected by variety, but different N rates application significantly (P<0.05) affected it (Table 3). Mean number of leaves was highest (13.64) due to application of N at 90 kg ha
-1, with the control treatment producing the least value of 10.40. All the fertilizer-applied treatments were similar in effect, but differed significantly from the control treatment (Table 3). The combined effects of maize variety and fertilizer on mean number of leaves in the main and minor cropping periods of 2019 were significant (P<0.05) (Table 4). In the main cropping period of 2019, mean number of leaves was highest in Omankwa (8.42) following application of 90 kg N ha-1, while crops of Pannar 12 which were not fertilized recorded the least mean number of leaves (6.50). In the minor cropping period of 2019, mean number of leaves was highest in Omankwa grown with 90 kg N ha
-1, while Pannar 12 crops which were not fertilized recorded the least mean number of leaves (Table 4).
The increase in number of leaves due to fertilizer application could be due to the involvement of N in leaf formation, growth and development as ever reported by
Gharge et al., (2020). Plants of Pannar 12 may be more efficient in dry matter partitioning than those of Omankwa following nitrogen application and this may have led to an increased stem diameter in the former (Tables 3 and 4).
Both variety and rates of N application significantly (P<0.05) influenced stem diameter (Table 3). Stems of Panner 12 were significantly larger in diameter than those of Omankwa. Application of N fertilizer increased stem diameter in both varieties of maize throughout the study. In the main cropping period of 2019, stem diameter was highest due to application of N at 150 kg ha
-1 and was lowest under the control. The combined effects of maize variety and fertilizer on stem diameter in the main and minor cropping periods of 2019 were significant (P<0.05) (Table 4). Generally, application of fertilizer increased stem diameter in Omankwa over Pannar 12 in the main cropping period of 2019. Plants of Pannar 12, which received no fertilizer had the lowest stem diameter of 0.59 cm (Table 4). In the minor cropping period of 2019, stem diameter was biggest (0.79 cm) when 120 kg N ha
-1 was applied to Pannar 12 and was smallest (0.60 cm) when Omankwa was grown with no fertilizer (Table 4). The availability of sufficient N could have increased photosynthesis and dry matter partitioning in support of vegetative growth leading to an increase in stem diameter
(Shah et al., 2021b; Karki et al., 2020).
Nitrogen use efficiency
Results of NUE in the major season of 2019 depicted no significant (P>0.05) differences between the two varieties, but fertilizer N applied significantly influenced it (Table 5). The application rate of 150 kg ha
-1 gave NUE of 11.37 kg/kg, but did not differ significantly from the rest of the fertilizer N rates. Again, the application rate of 120 kg ha
-1 gave NUE of 7.17 kg/kg, which varied significantly from that of 90 kg ha
-1, which had the highest NUE of 12.73 kg/kg. In the minor season of 2019, results of nitrogen use efficiency depicted significant (P<0.05) differences between the two varieties of maize, but the fertilizer N applied had no significant (P>0.05) effects on it (Table 5). Pannar 12 was more efficient in nitrogen use than Omankwa. The combined effects of maize variety and fertilizer on nitrogen use efficiency in the main and minor cropping periods of 2019 were significant (P<0.05) (Table 6). In the main cropping period of 2019, the greatest treatment interaction effects (15.91 kg/kg) were observed in Omankwa grown with 90 kg N ha
-1, while the lowest (6.52 kg/kg) was noticed in Pannar 12 grown with 120 kg N ha-1. In the minor season of 2019, Pannar 12 plants treated with 150 kg N/ha had the highest NUE (13.54 kg/kg), while Omankwa plants treated with 150 kg N/ha had the lowest NUE (4.69 kg/kg) (Table 6).
The greatest NUE recorded following application of 90 kg N ha
-1 to Omankwa could probably be due to the fact that, the rate of N application was sufficient enough to optimize NUE in Omankwa. However, these results were not translated into grain yield as Omankwa grown with 90 kg N ha
-1 gave a seed yield of 4036 kg ha
-1, which was significantly lower than the seed yield of 6146 kg ha
-1 recorded by Pannar 12 grown with 150 kg N ha
-1 (Fig 2). Generally, it was noticed in the present study that increasing levels of N application in both seasons of 2019 decreased NUE in Omankwa, but increased NUE in Pannar 12, especially in the minor cropping period, where Pannar 12 grown with 150 kg N ha
-1 had the maximum NUE of 13.54 kg/kg (Table 6). The results could be due to the genetic differences between the two genotypes of maize grown. The application of 150 kg N ha-1 increased NUE in Pannar 12 in the minor cropping period of 2019 (Table 6) probably because the amount of N was sufficient to improve uptake and utilization of N in Pannar 12, meaning that augmenting rates of N application in the minor cropping period could increase NUE of hybrid maize varieties. These results were reflected in the maximum seed yield of 6095 kg ha
-1 gained in the minor cropping period of 2019 (Fig 2) as reported by
Ansu et al., (2023). The increased levels of NPK application could have reduced losses of N through leaching and that roots of crop plants could have grown copiously to absorb sufficient mineral elements from a large area of soil.
Zada et al., (2000) stated that NUE of crops maximized with high levels of nutrient application up to a certain point and then began to decrease and this is corroborated by the findings of this study.
For the NUE indices,
Fixen et al., (2015) gave a standard value of 15-30 kg kg
-1 for AE. Values obtained in this study were below this range, except the value (15.91 kg/kg) obtained when Omankwa was grown with 90 kg N ha-1 (Tables 5 and 6).
Seed yield
The combined effects of maize variety and fertilizer on seed yield of maize in the main and minor cropping periods of 2019 were significant (P<0.05) (Fig 2 and 3). In the main cropping period of 2019, Pannar 12 raised with 150 kg N ha
-1 gave the highest seed yield of 6146 kg ha
-1, while Pannar 12 raised with no fertilizer gave the least seed yield of 3958 kg ha
-1 (Fig 2). In the minor cropping period of 2019, Pannar 12 grown with 150 kg N ha
-1 recorded the greatest seed yield of 6095 kg ha
-1, while Omankwa grown with no nutrient gave the least grain yield of 3684 kg ha
-1 (Fig 3).