The experiment site was dominated by broad leaved weeds (
Abelmoschus ficulneus, Cleome viscosa, Corchorus trilocularis, Croton sparsiflorus, Euphorbia hirta and Trianthema portulacastrum), followed by grasses (
Brachiaria reptans, Chloris barbata, Dactyloctenium aegyptium and
Echinochloa colonum) and sedges (
Cyperus rotundus and
Cyperus iria) respectively
.
Weed parameters on 20 and 40 DAS
At 20 DAS, hand weeding twice (T
7) emerged as the most effective treatment, recording the lowest total weed density (3.80 no./m
2), weed dry weight (1.54 g/m
2) and highest weed control efficiency (96.2%). Among herbicide-based treatments, triafamone + ethoxysulfuron followed by hand weeding (T
4) exhibited excellent weed suppression, with a total weed density of 10.20 no./m
2, weed dry weight of 4.08 g/m² and weed control efficiency of 89.9% (Table 1). This reduction in weed population was attributed to the herbicide efficiency in controlling a broad spectrum of weeds by inhibiting acetolactate synthase (ALS), a key enzyme for branched-chain amino acid synthesis in weeds
(Ali et al., 2019 and
Dangol et al., 2020). Pre-emergence herbicides (T
1-T
3) showed moderate control, with T
2 (bensulfuron methyl + pretilachlor
fb hand weeding) being the most effective in this group (20.90 no./m
2). In contrast, Bispyribac sodium alone (T
6) and the weedy check (T
8) had the highest weed infestations (96.80 and 100.80 no./m
2, respectively), demonstrating poor weed suppression owing to absence of any weed control measure
(Parihar et al., 2020).
At 40 DAS, hand weeding twice (T
7) maintained its superior performance with the lowest weed density (2.40 no./m
2), weed dry weight (1.44 g/m
2) and highest weed control efficiency (98.6%). The triafamone + ethoxysulfuron followed by hand weeding (T
4) treatment continued to show strong efficacy of 4.30 no./m
2 weed density, 2.59 g/m
2 weed dry weight and 87.5 % weed control efficiency, while T
1 and T
2 (pre-emergence herbicides followed by hand weeding) also performed well (3.20 and 3.00 no./m
2, respectively) (Table 2). The integrated approaches combining timely mechanical control with effective herbicides provide the most consistent weed suppression
(Dhanapal et al., 2018 and
Bhattacharya et al., 2022). The weedy check (T
8) exhibited the highest weed pressure (172.80 no./m
2), followed by T
6 (bispyribac sodium alone) at 44.00 no./m
2, reinforcing the limitations of single herbicide applications. Similar results were documented by
Rahman et al., (2017) and
Munnoli and Rajakumar (2021).
The weed index showed marked variation among the different weed management treatments, reflecting the extent of yield loss caused by weed competition (Fig 1). Hand weeing twice (T
7) indicating its superior performance in maintaining crop productivity and its use as the weed free benchmark. Among the herbicidal treatments, triafamone + ethoxysulfuron followed by hand weeding (T
4) recorded a very low weed index of 2.68, followed by T
5 (9.34). The lower weed index under these treatments indicates that effective suppression of weeds during the critical stages of crop growth helped minimize yield losses. The results are in accordance with the findings of
Teja et al. (2015) and
Parihar et al., (2020). Bispyribac sodium alone (T
6) resulted in a higher weed index of 30.68, suggesting comparatively greater yield reduction due to inadequate weed control. The maximum weed index of 79.69 was recorded in the weedy check (T
8), demonstrating the severe adverse effect of unchecked weed competition on crop yield.
Crop parameters
The growth parameters of aerobic rice at 60 DAS showed that the treatment with hand weeding twice (T
7) produced the tallest plants (58.4 cm), highest number of tillers (456/m
2) and maximum dry matter accumulation (7936 kg/ha) (Table 3). This was closely followed by the triafamone + ethoxysulfuron followed by hand weeding treatment (T
4), which recorded plant height of 55.6 cm, 427 tillers/m
2 and dry matter production of 7584 kg/ha (Table 4). Compared with herbicides having a relatively narrow spectrum of activity, the triafamone + ethoxysulfuron mixture offers broader weed-spectrum management through ALS inhibition, enabling effective suppression of major grassy, sedge and broad-leaved weeds in rice ecosystems (
Choudhary and Dixit, 2018 and
Saravanane, 2020). Weedy check (T
8) had the poorest growth (46.6 cm, 148 tillers/m
2, 1356 kg/ha).
Physiological parameters
The physiological parameters (Table 3) of aerobic rice at 60 DAS demonstrated that hand weeding twice (T
7) achieved the highest leaf area index (4.62) and SPAD value (45.1), suggesting better light interception and photosynthetic activity, which are critical for biomass accumulation
(Riaz et al., 2018 and
Selvaraj and Hussainy, 2020).The treatment, T
4 that recorded LAI of 4.50 and SPAD value of 44.9. In contrast, the weedy check (T
8) exhibited the poorest physiological performance with significantly lower LAI (1.52) and SPAD value (37.3).
Yield parameters
The yield analysis revealed significant differences among treatments, with hand weeding twice (T
7) reflecting in significantly higher grain (5388 kg/ha) and straw yield (8201 kg/ha) (Fig 2). This was closely followed by the triafamone + ethoxysulfuron followed by hand weeding treatment (T
4), with a grain and straw yield of 5244 and 7920 kg/ha due to the maintenance of weed-free conditions throughout the crop growth period, allowing for optimal resource utilization. In contrast, the weedy check (T
8) showed 79.7% reduction of 1094 kg/ha of grain and 2270 kg/ha of straw. The superior performance observed with herbicide mixtures may be attributed to the effective suppression of a broad spectrum of weeds through ALS inhibition by triafamone and ethoxysulfuron
(Verma et al., 2023; Donayre et al., 2021). Inhibition of ALS disrupts the biosynthesis of essential branched-chain amino acids, thereby restricting weed growth and reducing competition for nutrients, water and other resources required for rice development. The resulting reduction in weed interference contributed to improved crop growth and productivity under aerobic rice cultivation. The results are in accordance with the findings of
Mishra (2019) and
Yogananda et al., (2022).
Economics
Weed management practices significantly influenced the economics of aerobic rice cultivation (Table 4). The weedy check (T
8) recorded the lowest cost of cultivation (₹41,076/ha), as no weed control measure was imposed, while the highest cost (₹56,076/ha) was recorded under hand weeding twice (T
7), owing to the labour requirement of manual weeding. Among the herbicide-based treatments, the lowest cost (₹42,226/ha) was recorded with bispyribac sodium alone. The highest gross return (₹1,43,139/ha) was obtained with hand weeding twice, closely followed by triafamone + ethoxysulfuron followed by hand weeding (T
4) (₹1,39,128/ha), while the weedy check recorded the lowest gross return (₹30,878/ha). However, the highest net return (₹87,852/ha) was recorded with triafamone + ethoxysulfuron followed by hand weeding, exceeding the net return of hand weeding twice (₹87,063/ha) despite the latter’s higher gross return, on account of its considerably lower cost of cultivation. The highest benefit-cost ratio (2.90) was recorded with triafamone + ethoxysulfuron followed by bispyribac sodium (T
5), indicating that sequential herbicide application without manual weeding was the most cost-efficient option, although with a comparatively lower yield. The weedy check recorded a negative net return (-₹10,198/ha) and the lowest benefit-cost ratio (0.75). The results were proved with the findings of
Satapathy et al., (2020) and
Poojitha et al., (2022).