Genomic comparisons and variations
Understanding the genomic distinctions between the
Av. paragallinarum isolate ZJ-C and the Modesto reference strain was a key goal of our study, aiming to determine their evolutionary trajectories and functional differences. High-throughput sequencing technology was used to sequence and assemble the genome of ZJ-C, which was found to be 2.67 Mb in size with a GC content of 40.93%. The genomic structure of the serogroup C Modesto strain served as the reference for comparative analyses (Table 1, Fig 1). Using Mauve software, we identified notable collinearity between the genomes of ZJ-C and Modesto, with largely similar structural arrangements. Circular genome diagrams generated using BLAST Ring Image Generator (Fig 2A) showed genome coverage of 82% and 96.41% sequence similarity in the covered regions. Genomic collinearity between the strains is shown in Fig 2B.
Further analysis of ortholog gene clusters revealed that ZJ-C had 92 fewer genes than Modesto. Notably, a more pronounced difference was observed in protein-coding genes, with ZJ-C harboring 503 fewer genes than Modesto (Table 1). This disparity highlights the conservative nature of Modesto’s protein-coding genes, while suggesting greater evolutionary dynamism in ZJ-C, potentially involving mutations (
Rodriguez-Larrea et al., 2010). The genomic variation observed here highlights the evolutionary dynamics of
Av. paragallinarum, providing insights into its pathogenicity and potential control measures
(Baltrus et al., 2011). Orthologous gene cluster analysis indicated that ZJ-C contained significantly fewer protein-coding genes compared to Modesto, with a difference of 503 genes (Table 1). The considerable genomic divergence between these two strains of
Av. paragallinarum may reflect distinct evolutionary pressures and adaptation strategies. Such genomic differences underscore the evolutionary plasticity within strain ZJ-C and emphasize the need for future functional studies to experimentally verify the precise impact of these gene variations on virulence and pathogenicity. Clarifying the role of these differential genes will enhance our understanding of bacterial adaptation mechanisms and inform strategies for disease control and prevention (
Gupta, 2016).
Virulence gene analysis
Comparative analysis of virulence genes between
Av. paragallinarum strains ZJ-C and Modesto helps elucidate their pathogenic potential and resistance profiles. According to the VFDB, ZJ-C harbored 210 virulence genes, while Modesto had 212. Some virulence genes had multiple copies in both strains. Specifically, we found that a pilus guide protein gene, which is often implicated in urinary tract infections caused by
A. baumannii (Mahapatra et al., 2022), was replicated four times in ZJ-C. This gene replication may suggest enhanced host colonization or infection by
Av. paragallinarum, warranting further investigation.
Further analysis revealed that the two strains shared 168 identical virulence genes, but ZJ-C and Modesto had 42 and 44 unique virulence genes, respectively (Fig 3). Refined KEGG pathway analyses, focused exclusively on bacterial metabolism, pathogenicity and antibiotic resistance pathways, revealed distinct differences. Unique virulence genes in ZJ-C predominantly belonged to membrane transport systems and carbohydrate metabolism (Fig 4A), potentially indicating adaptive advantages in nutrient acquisition and host interaction. Conversely, Modesto-specific genes primarily mapped to metabolic pathways including glycan biosynthesis, lipid metabolism and nucleotide metabolism (Fig 4B), suggesting different adaptive strategies in this strain.
ResFinder analysis, sourced from the drug resistance database
(Zankari et al., 2012), revealed that ZJ-C contained the tetracycline resistance gene
tet(B), which was absent in Modesto. This suggests that ZJ-C may have an increased ability to invade and establish infections in chickens at a potentially more aggressive rate than Modesto
(Guillard et al., 2016) Additionally, ZJ-C’s increased drug resistance profile further strengthens its adaptability in challenging environments. The differences in virulence genes and resistance profiles hint at a complex interplay between the pathogen’s ability to evade treatment and its capacity to cause disease. This potential association between resistance and virulence may reflect evolutionary pressures on ZJ-C (
Andersson and Hughes, 2014). Currently, specific mechanisms employed by
Av. paragallinarum to evade host defenses remain poorly characterized. However, considering the strategies utilized by closely related pathogens, such as H
aemophilus influenzae and
Shigella, it is plausible that similar mechanisms, including biofilm formation and Type III secretion systems (T3SS), might play roles in
Av. paragallinarum pathogenesis. Biofilms could potentially facilitate persistent colonization and resistance to antimicrobial agents, whereas T3SS could assist in translocating virulence factors into host cells to modulate cellular processes essential for colonization and survival
(Chatziparasidis et al., 2023, Deng et al., 2017, Flacht et al., 2023, Sowmiya et al., 2025). These potential pathogenic mechanisms in
Av. paragallinarum warrant further experimental verification, which could contribute significantly to understanding its virulence and developing targeted therapeutic strategies.
Experimental validation of zj-c and Modesto virulence differences
In Modesto-infected groups (5×10
4–5×10
5CFU), clinical symptoms were initially mild, with incomplete infection on day 1. Even at the highest inoculation dose (5×10
5 CFU), all chickens only displayed symptoms by day 3, followed by a rapid recovery. In contrast, ZJ-C infection at doses ranging from 5×10
3 to 5×10
5 CFU resulted in the onset of clinical symptoms in all chickens on the first day, with persistent severe symptoms lasting until day 5 before showing mild recovery. Notably, even a low-dose ZJ-C infection (5×10
2 CFU) led to 100% of chickens exhibiting symptoms by day 3. These findings indicate that ZJ-C exhibits significantly higher virulence than Modesto (Fig 5B). Using an established infection scoring model, we further assessed the clinical severity of symptoms. At equivalent doses, the Modesto-infected groups consistently displayed milder symptoms. Even at 5×10
2 CFU, ZJ-C infection resulted in more severe clinical signs compared to Modesto at 5×10
4 CFU (Fig 5C). Collectively, both the duration and severity of disease symptoms indicate that ZJ-C possesses substantially higher virulence than Modesto.
The testing of virulence
in vivo supports our genomic findings, reinforcing the idea that ZJ-C possesses genetic characteristics that enhance its pathogenic abilities. The swift manifestation of disease symptoms and the extended duration of infection seen in chickens infected with ZJ-C indicate that the virulence factors of this strain facilitate effective colonization of the host and evasion of the immune response. Importantly, ZJ-C was capable of establishing infection and inducing severe illness at significantly lower doses compared to Modesto, emphasizing its increased pathogenic potential. Moreover, earlier research has shown that hemagglutinins, fimbrial proteins and cytolethal distending toxins are essential to the virulence of
Av. paragallinarum (
Wang et al., 2014,
Liu et al., 2016, Chen et al., 2014). The genome of ZJ-C includes numerous copies of genes related to these factors, which may enhance adhesion, invasion and modulation of the immune response. The extended persistence of disease in chickens infected with ZJ-C is also consistent with its anticipated metabolic adaptability, which aids in bacterial survival within the host environment. In summary, these findings offer solid experimental evidence that backs our genomic assessment and underline the necessity for focused strategies to address infections caused by hypervirulent strains of
Av. paragallinarum. Future studies should aim to clarify the specific molecular mechanisms driving the heightened virulence of ZJ-C utilizing transcriptomic and proteomic methodologies.
Antibiotic resistance gene identification
Identifying antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in
Av. paragallinarum isolate ZJ-C is essential for understanding potential treatment challenges in IC management. Using the Resistance Gene Identifier (RGI) mode of CARD, six resistance genes were predicted in ZJ-C, including
qacJ and
tet(B), as well as genes associated with resistance in
Klebsiella pneumoniae (
e.g.,
KpnH),
Haemophilus influenzae (
e.g.,
PBP3, conferring beta-lactam resistance) and
Escherichia coli (
e.g.,
EF-Tu, conferring resistance to pulvomycin and
tetR). These genes mediate resistance through mechanisms such as antibiotic efflux (
qacJ, tet(B), KpnH, PBP3)
(Tristram et al., 2007) and target site alterations (
EF-Tu and
tetR)
(Hummel et al., 2007).
The presence of these resistance genes highlights ZJ-C’s potential resilience to common therapeutic antibiotics, posing significant clinical challenges (
Andersson and Hughes, 2014,
Adwitiya et al., 2025). Although ZJ-C’s additional ARGs such as tet(B) suggest higher resistance potential compared to Modesto, further studies are required to determine if these resistance mechanisms directly contribute to increased virulence. The potential relationship between resistance and virulence suggests an interplay between the pathogen’s ability to evade treatment and cause disease (
Martínez and Baquero, 2002,
Romero et al., 2011). KEGG pathway analysis, refined to specifically highlight resistance-associated bacterial pathways, demonstrated significant enrichment differences: ZJ-C harbored 54 resistance-related proteins compared to Modesto’s 45, underscoring ZJ-C’s heightened potential for resisting therapeutic interventions (Fig 6) (
Davies and Davies, 2010). Understanding the genetic basis of antibiotic resistance will inform targeted therapeutic strategies and facilitate the development of effective interventions against
Av. paragallinarum infections
(Alkatheri et al., 2023, Salyers, 2002).
Protein ortholog gene cluster analysis
Orthologous gene analysis is essential for understanding evolutionary relationships and functional similarities between genomes
(Pan et al., 2009, Sivashankari and Shanmughavel, 2007). To accurately assess genomic differences, we included
Av. paragallinarum strain ESV-135 (Ref_Strain) as an outgroup in the orthologous gene cluster analysis.
The refined analysis identified orthologous protein gene clusters across strains ZJ-C, Modesto and the outgroup (Fig 7). A total of 1839 conserved clusters were shared by all three strains, suggesting a substantial genomic core characteristic of the genus Avibacterium. Importantly, ZJ-C had 50 unique protein clusters and Modesto possessed 115 unique clusters, highlighting distinct strain-specific evolutionary adaptations potentially linked to their differential phenotypes and pathogenic potential.
The identification of these unique gene clusters provides critical insights into the adaptive mechanisms and evolutionary pressures experienced by these strains. Although the limited number of publicly available
Av. paragallinarum genomes restricts broader comparative analyses, these unique gene sets offer meaningful targets for future functional studies aimed at clarifying their roles in bacterial lifecycle management, virulence factors and host interaction dynamics. Thus, this comparative ortholog analysis not only enhances our understanding of genomic diversity within
Av. paragallinarum but also establishes a solid foundation for targeted investigations into the genetic basis of pathogenicity and strain-specific adaptations.
Pathway enrichment analysis and functional implications
To explore the molecular mechanisms underlying differences in virulence and antibiotic resistance between
Av. paragallinarum strains ZJ-C and Modesto, we conducted KEGG pathway enrichment analysis using the annotated genomic data.
(Kanehisa et al., 2017, Romero et al., 2011). Genes from both ZJ-C (2220 annotated genes) and Modesto (2255 annotated genes) were systematically classified into functional categories: Cellular Processes, Environmental Information Processing, Genetic Information Processing, Metabolism and Organismal Systems. Metabolic pathways represented the majority of annotated functions, accounting for 66.4% and 66.9% of genes in ZJ-C and Modesto, respectively. Notably, carbohydrate metabolism, amino acid metabolism and metabolism of cofactors and vitamins were among the most prominently enriched pathways, suggesting essential roles in bacterial adaptation and survival.
Detailed comparative analysis revealed significant functional divergence between the two strains, particularly in pathways associated with bacterial pathogenicity and antibiotic resistance. In ZJ-C, unique gene enrichment was notably prominent in membrane transport mechanisms and carbohydrate metabolism. These functional categories are crucial for bacterial nutrient acquisition, colonization efficiency and persistence in host environments. This enrichment supports experimental observations that ZJ-C exhibits enhanced colonization capability and persistent infection phenotypes. Furthermore, ZJ-C showed higher numbers of genes linked to antibiotic resistance pathways compared to Modesto, potentially reflecting an adaptive advantage that allows survival in antibiotic-exposed environments typical of poultry farms.
Among ZJ-C’s unique virulence genes, approximately 62% (26 out of 42) were directly associated with metabolic processes, especially membrane transport and carbohydrate utilization. In contrast, Modesto’s unique virulence genes were primarily enriched in glycan biosynthesis, diverse metabolic processes and antibiotic resistance mechanisms. These genomic distinctions highlight differential evolutionary pressures acting on these strains and provide molecular insights into the distinct virulence phenotypes experi-mentally observed. Collectively, our pathway enrichment analysis underscores how genomic variations contribute to significant differences in virulence and antibiotic resistance traits between
Av. paragallinarum strains
(Fraser et al., 2010). The identification of specific metabolic and resistance-related gene clusters unique to ZJ-C offers critical insights and potential targets for developing more effective vaccines and therapeutic interventions against highly virulent
Av. paragallinarum strains.
Implications for vaccine development and disease control
The comprehensive genomic comparison between
Av. paragallinarum serovar C strains ZJ-C and Modesto provides critical insights with direct implications for vaccine development and the management of IC. Significant genomic differences identified between these two strains, particularly in virulence-associated genes, antibiotic resistance determinants and host-interaction pathways, underline the necessity for developing strain-specific or broadly protective intervention strategies (
Plotkin, 2010). Distinct genomic profiles observed in ZJ-C and Modesto strains, especially unique gene clusters and differential enrichment in metabolic, pathogenicity and antibiotic resistance pathways, suggest differing pathogenic potentials and therapeutic challenges. Specifically, unique gene clusters in the highly virulent ZJ-C strain related to membrane transport, carbohydrate metabolism and antibiotic resistance mechanisms may confer enhanced capabilities for host colonization, persistent infection and resistance to conventional antibiotics used in poultry farming
(Petersen et al., 2007), which can affect the efficacy of existing vaccines and treatments. Consequently, these genomic distinctions highlight a potential limitation in the protective efficacy of existing serovar C vaccines, which may not adequately address such highly pathogenic and drug-resistant strains like ZJ-C
(Hendriksen et al., 2019).
The presence of strain-specific ARGs, such as those identified in ZJ-C, underscores the critical need for tailored antibiotic stewardship practices and novel therapeutic strategies specifically designed to target these resistance determinants. Conversely, the absence or reduced expression of certain genes in less virulent strains, like Modesto, presents opportunities to leverage these genetic vulnerabilities in new vaccine formulations or targeted treatments, potentially reducing pathogenicity and improving vaccine-induced protection. Our findings further advocate for incorporating comparative genomic analyses routinely into IC vaccine development protocols. Considering the substantial genomic variability even within the same serovar, incorporating locally prevalent or genetically representative strains into vaccine formulations might significantly enhance protection efficacy. Additionally, exploring genomic data across multiple
Av. paragallinarum serovars would help identify conserved or universally critical antigens, facilitating the development of broadly protective vaccines with potential cross-serovar effectiveness.
Finally, the increasing availability of genomic sequences of
Av. paragallinarum strains in public databases, such as those reported by (
Byukusenge et al., 2020), provides valuable resources for expanding comparative genomic studies. Integrating these genomic resources into a broader analytical framework will enable more comprehensive understanding of virulence mechanisms, adaptive evolution and resistance emergence in
Av. paragallinarum. Such integrated genomic approaches are pivotal for designing robust disease control measures and developing next-generation vaccines and therapeutics, ultimately improving poultry health and productivity.