Concentrations of circulating IgM
Table (3) show data on the IgM levels in the plasma of Cobb chickens that were vaccinated with a long vaccination program against ND. The IgM levels are measured from Week 1 (W1) to Week 60 (W60), with a comparison between vaccinated and non-vaccinated chickens. The data demonstrated significant differences in the IgM response between the two groups in the earlier weeks post-vaccination, which gradually decrease over time. At W 1, vaccinated chickens display a significantly higher IgM concentrations (9.896 ng/ml) compared to non-vaccinated chickens (3.106 ng/ml). This significant difference (p<0.01) indicates that the Newcastle vaccine triggers a strong early immune response, as expected from the role of IgM in primary immunity. At week 3, the IgM levels in vaccinated chickens remained high (9.916 ng/ml), while non-vaccinated chickens show negligible change from week 1(3.070 ng/ml). At week 5, the vaccinated group maintained significantly higher IgM levels (6.803 ng/ml) compared to the non-vaccinated group (3.120 ng/ml). At week 8, IgM levels in the vaccinated group remained elevated (6.830 ng/ml), while the non-vaccinated chickens exhibited very low IgM levels (4.426 ng/ml). The significant difference (p< 0.01) shows that the vaccine continues to stimulate immune activity, likely due to either sustained immune memory or continuous pathogen exposure. At week 10, the vaccinated group retained a strong IgM response reaching to 6.655 ng/ml, while the non-vaccinated group remained near the baseline 4.194 ng/ml. The significant difference (p<0.01) suggests that vaccination provides longer-lasting protection than natural exposure alone. By week 15, IgM levels in the non-vaccinated group increase to 3.650 ng/ml, possibly due to natural exposure to pathogens. The vaccinated group shows higher IgM levels (3.784 ng/ml), but the difference is not statistically significant. At week 18, both groups show an increase in IgM levels, with vaccinated chickens maintaining higher levels (7.360 ng/ml). However, the absence of statistical significance suggests that natural exposure has allowed non-vaccinated chickens to develop comparable immunity. By week 20, both groups exhibit similar IgM levels, with no significant difference between them. At Week 40, there is still no significant difference in IgM levels between the two groups (T-value=0.67), suggesting that the vaccine-induced immune response has waned to the point where it is no longer detectable in comparison to the non-vaccinated group. By the end of the study at week 60, the vaccinated group shows slightly higher IgM levels (3.778 ng/ml) than the non-vaccinated group (2.660 ng/ml). However, the difference is not statistically significant.
Concentrations of circulating IgG
Table (4) provide data on the levels of Immunoglobulin G (IgG) in the plasma of Cobb chickens, vaccinated with a long vaccination program against the Newcastle disease (ND). Notably, the table shows that in the early stages of the vaccination program, there are significant increases in IgG levels in vaccinated chickens compared to their non-vaccinated counterparts. However, the significance of this difference decreases over time, especially after Week 15. At week 1, the vaccinated chickens exhibit a much higher IgG concentration (114.000 µg/ml) compared to the non-vaccinated group (29.79 µg/ml). By week 3, the IgG levels in both groups increase, with the vaccinated group reaching 142.800 µg/ml and the non-vaccinated group rising to 63.80 µg/ml. At week 5, the vaccinated group’s IgG levels remained high (142.650 µg/ml) with minimal change from week 3. Meanwhile, the non-vaccinated group’s IgG levels declined to 51.68 µg/ml. The highly significant difference (p<0.001) suggests that the vaccine continues to provide strong immune protection. By week 8, the IgG levels in both groups are nearly identical (49.43 µg/ml in non-vaccinated chickens vs. 48.680 µg/ml in vaccinated chickens). At week 10, the vaccinated group exhibits slightly higher IgG levels (55.860 µg/ml) than the non-vaccinated group (36.73 µg/ml). However, the difference was not statistically significant. At week 15, the vaccinated group maintained higher IgG levels (50.532 µg/ml), while the non-vaccinated group showed a continued decline to 24.82 µg/ml. Although the vaccinated group retained some immune advantage, the difference was no longer statistically significant. By week 18, the vaccinated chickens exhibit higher IgG levels (52.197 µg/ml) than the non-vaccinated group (27.31 µg/ml). At week 20, the non-vaccinated group shows a slight increase in IgG levels (40.84 µg/ml), surpassing the vaccinated group (35.000 µg/ml). By week 40, both groups display reduced IgG levels, with the non-vaccinated group at 17.24 µg/ml and the vaccinated group at 15.40 µg/ml. At the end of the study (week 60), the non-vaccinated group showed higher IgG levels (35.60 µg/ml) than the vaccinated group (12.048 µg/ml).
Concentrations of circulating IgA
Table (5) illustrate the impact of vaccination on the levels of circulating IgA (ng/ml) in the plasma of Cobb chickens, vaccinated with a long vaccination program against NDV with data spanning week 1 (W1) to week 60 (W60). At Week 1, IgA levels in the vaccinated chickens were significantly higher than in the non-vaccinated group (3.178ng/ml and 2.656ng/ml respectively). By Week 3, the difference in IgA levels between the vaccinated and non-vaccinated chickens remained highly significant (3.165 ng/ml). At Week 5, the IgA levels in vaccinated chickens remained significantly elevated (3.006 ng/ml), though the T-value has decreased slightly. Week 8 shows a very large difference, with vaccinated chickens having much higher IgA levels (2.932 ng/ml) compared to non-vaccinated chickens (1.676 ng/ml). At Week 10, the IgA levels in the vaccinated group 2.921 ng/ml remained significantly higher than those of the non-vaccinated group (2.694 ng/ml), although the T-value is lower compared to Week 8. By Week 15, there is still a significant difference in IgA levels between the vaccinated and non-vaccinated groups (2.772 ng/ml and 2.957 ng/ml respectively), but this difference becomes smaller as the chickens age. In Week 18, there is no longer a significant difference between the groups. By Weeks 20 to 60, the IgA levels in vaccinated and non-vaccinated chickens converge. The differences are no longer statistically significant
and the T-values indicate a diminishing effect of the vaccine on IgA production over time.
Histology of Bursa Fabricius (BF) of vaccinated and non-vaccinated chicks
The tissues of BF were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (Fig 1). The BF of a 1-week-old chicks showed areas of lymphocyte depletion and necrosis within the medulla of some bursal follicles. The tissue sections of the 3-week-old chicken showed numerous well-defined bursal follicles, which are the primary functional units of the BF. The follicles appear to have a uniform size and distribution, suggesting a healthy and developing BF. The BF of a chicken at 5, 8,10,15 and 18 weeks old, exhibited a well-preserved and organized structure. The lymphocytes within the follicles appear to be intact and without any signs of necrosis, inflammation, or other cellular damages. The BF of 20-and 40-weeks-old chicken contained some follicles showing signs of lymphocytic necrosis and the follicles appeared dark and necrotic. The bursal follicles of a 60-week-old chicken showed a reduction in the number of lymphocytes (depletion) and evidence of lymphocyte necrosis. The histology highlights the presence of increased connective tissue (fibrosis) between the follicles. The histology of the BF of a non-vaccinated chicken (2 weeks old), showed areas of lymphocytic necrosis and depletion. Heterophils infiltration and the presence of inflammatory cells were noticed. The histology the BF of a 13-week-old non-vaccinated chicken showed a reduction in the number of lymphocytes (lymphocyte depletion) and evidence of lymphocyte death (necrosis). Within the affected areas, the formation of caseated material can be observed.
Histology of spleen of vaccinated and non-vaccinated chicks
The histology depicts the spleen of a 1, 5, 10 ,15, 18, 20, 40 and 60 -weeks -old chickens (Fig 2). The images show a well-organized lymphoid architecture with distinct white pulp and red pulp areas. There were no visible signs of inflammation, necrosis, or other pathological changes within the spleen tissue. This indicates a healthy and normal appearance of the organ. On the contrary, the histological examination of the spleen of the 3 and 8-weeks-old chicken showed areas of mild lymphocytic necrosis and depletion. The lymphoid follicles in the affected areas appeared less well-defined and organized compared to normal follicles. The histology of the spleen of a 2-week-old non-vaccinated chickens showed areas of lymphocytic necrosis and depletion and a significant reduction in the number of lymphocytes. The lymphoid follicles in the affected areas appear disorganized and less well-defined compared to normal follicles. On the other hand, the spleen of a 13-week-old non-vaccinated chicken indicated the presence of reticular cell hyperplasia. The lymphoid follicles within the white pulp appear enlarged and less well-defined compared to a normal spleen.
In this study we monitored the levels of circulating IgM in the Cobb chickens vaccinated against ND from week 1 to week 60. The data showed that the IgM levels of the vaccinated chickens were significantly higher than the IgM levels of the non-vaccinated chickens at weeks 1, 3, 5, 8
and 10. The IgM levels of the vaccinated chickens peaked at week 10 and then declined slightly over the next few weeks. The IgM levels then remained relatively stable from weeks 20 to 60. The circulating levels of both IgM and IgG in poultry are a sign of humoral immunity being modulated and their adaptive immune responses being stimulated
(Du et al., 2017). After the initial interaction with an antigen, specific IgM responses rise; responses decline with a subsequent exposure
(Martinez et al., 2018). The IgM levels of the non-vaccinated chickens also increased over time, but not as significantly as the IgM levels of the vaccinated chickens. This suggests that the non-vaccinated chickens may have been exposed to other microorganisms in the environment, which would have boosted their immune response. The results of the study suggest that the Newcastle vaccine is effective in induce IgM production in Cobb chickens.
IgG is another type of antibody that is found in primarily in the blood. It is essential for the body protection against infections. Our results showed the circulating levels of IgG in the chickens vaccinated against ND from week 1 to week 60. The data showed that the IgG levels of the vaccinated chickens were significantly higher than the IgG levels of the non-vaccinated chickens at weeks 1, 3, 5, 15 and 18. The IgG levels of the vaccinated chickens peaked at week 3 and then declined slightly over the next few weeks. The IgG levels then remained relatively stable from weeks 10 to 60. The vaccine appears to be sufficient in inducing IgG production in the first few weeks after vaccination. The overall results of the study suggest that the Newcastle vaccine is effective in maintaining a protective immune response against ND.
IgA is a type of antibody that is essential for mucous immunity, such as the nose, mouth
and intestines. IgA plays a role in protecting the body from infection. It plays a major role in mucosal immunity, providing the first line of defense against infections
(Abbas et al., 2021). During the early weeks (Weeks 1-10), the vaccine provides a significant advantage in boosting IgA levels. The results indicated a strong IgA response within the first 10 weeks, with vaccinated chickens showing consistently higher IgA levels than their non-vaccinated counterparts. This demonstrated that the Newcastle vaccine effectively stimulates mucosal immunity during the critical early phase. As time progressed (Weeks 15-20), the difference between the two groups started to diminish. By weeks 18, 40 and 60, there was no significant difference between the two groups, indicating that both vaccinated and non-vaccinated chickens now rely on natural immune mechanisms. These findings highlight the temporary nature of vaccine-induced immunity and emphasizes the importance of booster vaccinations to maintain long-term protection. The study also highlights the adaptive capability of non-vaccinated chickens, can develop over time, although they remain vulnerable during the early stages without vaccination. IgA is also an important Ig involved in humoral immunity. Their content can reflect the level of humoral immunity in chickens. The data of the current study offers valuable insights for poultry management practices, helping farmers and veterinarians make informed decisions about vaccination schedules to ensure optimal protection against ND.
Several studies
(Sedeik et al., 2022) have indicated that vaccination programs using a progressive strategy that uses booster shots may provide protection against clinical illness and mortality after virulent NDV infection if vaccinated birds continue to have high antibody levels. All the vaccinated chickens in this investigation developed adequate antibody responses. Evaluation of vaccine efficiency is important in poultry farms and companies
Geletu and Robi (2024). Despite the advances in immunization programs, ND remains a significant threat to poultry industries worldwide; however, the infection can be managed through the effective implementation of vaccination programs
(Martinez
et al., 2018).
Suitable immunization techniques should be looked for
(Mebrahtu et al., 2018). Measurement of serum IgM and IgG by ELISA was recently done with parallel results
(Attia et al., 2020). Different NDV vaccines programs are carried out in poultry farms for different reasons. These comprise the avoidance of encouraging stress in chicks through excessive treatment
and to reduce vaccination costs
(Ball et al., 2019). The detection of antibodies before elevation due to vaccination might be due to maternal antibodies following a natural decline in the unvaccinated group as previously mentioned
(Martinez et al., 2018). The results of the current investigation were in agreement with
Landman et al., (2017) who observed high antibody titers with a nearly similar program
(Landman et al., 2017).
In the present study, the BF of a 1-week-old chicken showed areas within the medulla of some bursal follicles where there is a lymphocyte depletion and lymphocyte necrosis. After that, the image of BF of chicken at 3, 5, 8,10,15 and 18 weeks old show numerous well-defined bursal follicles, which are the primary functional units of the BF. This indicates a lack of any significant immune system abnormalities or diseases in these weeks-old chicken. The BF of a chicken of a 20, 40 and 60 -weeks-old chicken present some of the follicles are showing signs of lymphocytic necrosis and the follicles that appear dark and necrotic. These changes are indicative of immune system dysfunction. The histology of the BF of a non-vaccinated chicken (2 and 13 weeks old), showed areas of lymphocytic necrosis and depletion. heterophils infiltration and the presence of inflammatory cells were noticed. This histological image reflects immune suppression or damage in the bursa, which is critical for the development of the immune system in young chickens and highlights the detrimental effects of the absence of vaccination or potential exposure to pathogens. To regulate humoral immunity, chicken BF grows rapidly after hatching and achieves a massive size at the age of one to four months (
Abdul-Aziz 2016). A large number of lymphoid or bursal follicles that give the B lymphocytes that produce antibodies (
Cooper, 2015 and
Abdul-Aziz, 2016).
Cooper (2015) reviewed the development of the concept that the lymphoid follicles are a key organ in immunology. This histology of BF demonstrated how the immune system of birds is complicated and influenced by various factors including age and immunization program
(Attia et al., 2020). At the early age of live in the vaccinated groups, some follicles appeared with mildly reduced lymphocytes and it might be triggering the immune response as previously reported by
Cooper (2015).
Histological examination of the spleen of a 1, 3, 5, 10,15, 18, 20, 40 and 60 -weeks -old chicken show a well-organized lymphoid architecture with distinct white pulp and red pulp areas. There are no visible signs of inflammation, necrosis, or other pathological changes within the spleen tissue. This indicates a healthy and normal appearance of the organ. On the contrary, the histological examination of the spleen of 8-week-old chicken revealed areas of mild lymphocytic necrosis and depletion. The histology of the spleen of a 2 and 13 weeks-old non-vaccinated chicken showed areas of lymphocytic necrosis and depletion and a significant reduction in the number of lymphocytes. These organs (BF and spleen) are widely recognized as being crucial a
vian lymphoid organs and serving as primary immunological sites for induction of immunological responses against antigens
(Attia et al., 2020).