Growth performance
The 61-day body weight of the 600 g/t essential oil group was significantly higher than that of the control group (
P<0.05). The 37-day body weight (
P=0.069) and the daily gain of 0-61 days (
P=0.094) in the essential oil 600 g/t group were higher than those in the control group. Dry matter intake and feed conversion rate were not significantly different among the groups (
P>0.05, Table 2).
Great attention should be paid to the added amount of plant essential oil in the ruminant diet. Too low dose has no obvious effect while too high dose may have negative effects on growth performance
(Torres et al., 2020). Sun et al. (2022) reported that 300 mg/kg and 450 mg/kg of oregano oil (5.65% purity) in the fattening Sewa sheep diet, could significantly increase ADFI and ADG, the growth perfor-mance of sheep was improved by changing intestinal morphology and intestinal flora structure.
Torres et al., (2020) found that essential oil has a negative impact on animal performance, it would reduce ADG (100 mg/kg of DM), slaughter and carcass weight (200 mg/kg of DM). Meanwhile,
Munoz-Cuautle et al. (2022) reported that 200 and 400 mg/kg of oregano essential oil had no effects on the growth performance of lamb. In our experiment, adding 600 mg/kg essential oil to the diet of Hu sheep significantly increased the final weight of sheep at 61
st day of age. For the growth performance of Hu sheep, 600 mg/kg dietary supplementation is better than 300 mg/kg. This experiment was carried out in summer, heat stress was very serious (highest temperature were 35~38°C). The essential oils may moderate heat stress. In addition, the Hu sheep in this trial were just weaned recently, the function and development of their tissues, organs, gastrointestinal tract, were easily affected by nutritional factors.
Belanche et al., (2020) reported that short-term studies showed minor and inconsistent effects while long-term studies (>4 weeks duration of feeding) revealed that essential oil (Agolin Ruminant®) supplementation increases milk yield and feed efficiency. Our trial lasted 61 days and had an obvious effect on improving the growth performance, which was consistent with the above study. Inconsistent studies on the dose and effect of plant essential oils in ruminant diets require further research.
Rumen fermentation index
Compared with the control group, the 600 g/t group of essential oil significantly reduced the ammonia nitrogen in rumen fluid (
P<0.05). There were no significant differences among the sheep in terms of the ruminal pH and individual VFA proportions (Table 3). Ruminal liquid ammonia nitrogen content is an apparent indicator reflecting ruminal nitrogen degradation in ruminants. It is not only the final product of the degradation of nitrogencontaining substances in diet, but also the raw material for microbial synthesis of bacterial body proteins. The content of ammonia and nitrogen in the rumen fluid are related to the degradation rate of nitrogen in the diet and the ability of microorganisms to synthesize ammonia. Study showed that essential oil can inhibit protein hydrolysis in the rumen and selectively inhibit high yield bacteria such as
Prevotella ruminicola,
Clostridium sticklandii and
Peptostreptococcus anaerobius in the rumen, which leads to a significant decline in rumen ammonia production
(McIntosh et al., 2003). In this experiment, adding 600 mg/kg essential oil (blend of cinnamaldehyde, thymol and carvacrol) to the diet significantly reduced the contents of ammonia and nitrogen in the rumen fluid, the results were consistent with
Naseri et al. (2022). This is beneficial for protecting the environment by reducing nitrogen and ammonia excretion. Some reports suggest, the effect of essential oils on rumen nitrogen metabolism is more effective in short-term
in vitro trials
(Zhou et al., 2022), while the results are less pronounced in longer-term trials, such as
in vitro continuous culture, rumen nylon bag test and
in vivo tests (
Soltan et al., 2018;
Khorrami et al., 2015). The reason may be that the long-term tolerance has changed the ruminal microbial flora, or some essential oil compounds are degraded by the ruminal bacteria. This may be related to the type of essential oil, the amount of addition.
Rumen pH is an important indicator to evaluate environmental stability of ruminal fluid. The pH for normal fermentation of sheep rumen fluid was 5.5~7.5. In this experiment, the rumen fluid pH was in the normal range, there were no significant differences, which may be related to the ability of essential oil to promote the production of volatile fatty acids in the rumen. Many studies showed that plant essential oils (such as mixture oil from clove, oregano, cinnamon and lemon; eucalyptus) have no significant effect on ruminal pH in ruminants
(Lin et al., 2013; Akbarian-Tefaghi et al., 2018). However,
Biricik et al., (2016) reported that the rumen fluid pH was raised by carvacrol and thymol in sheep while
Yadeghari et al., (2015) reported lavender essential oil decreased ruminal pH
in vitro experiments. The inconsistency in the literature may be related to the sampling error of rumen fluid, the type of essential oil and the amount of addition.
El-Essawy et al., (2021) confirmed that anise, clove and thyme essential can promote the production of volatile fatty acids, increase the yield of propionate and reduce the ratio of acetate to propionate. The content of total VFA decreased with the addition of high level of essential oil (1 g/day) and the propionate increased significantly with 0.5 g/day essential oil. The ratio of acetate to propionate decreased significantly with the addition of mixture essential oil (eugenol, carvacrol, citral and cinnamal-dehyde)
(Lin et al., 2013). Cobellis et al., (2016) reported that low doses of essential oils do not seem to alter volatile fatty acids production in the rumen and ruminal microorganisms can also adapt to the presence of essential oils over time, thus suggest that essential oils can only affect VFA production in the short term. Our study also found that plant essential oils increased rumen volatile fatty acids but did not show a significant difference. It may be related to the fact that the amount of essential oil added is not very high.
Nutrient digestibility
Essential oil has no significant influence on the digestibility of various nutrients, including DM, OM, CP, CF, NDF and ADF (Table 4). The effects of plant essential oils on ruminant digestibility are inconsistent.
Malekkhahi et al., (2015) reported that 400 mg/day mix essential oil (thymol, carvacrol, eugenol, limonene and cinnamaldehyde) could significantly increase the protein digestibility of Baluchi sheep.
Lin et al., (2013) reported that addition of 0.5 g/day and 1 g/day essential oil did not influence digestibility of the nutrients in total or at different parts of the digestive tract but decreased ruminal protein digestibility. Our results showed that the essential oil has no obvious effect on the digestibility of various nutrients, the diet addition of 600 mg/kg essential oil reduced the crude protein digestibility and improved the NDF and ADF digestibility (P<0.05). Essential oils increase the relative abundance of fiber-degrading bacteria (such as
Fibrobacter succinogenes,
Ruminococcus albus and R.
flavefaciens) in sheep rumen fluid, so it is beneficial for fiber digestion (
Patra and Yu, 2015). But
Soltan et al., (2018) reported that the addition of 200 and 400 mg/kg essential oil to sheep diet had no effect on nutrient digestibility.
Rajkumar et al., (2023) also reported that there were no significant differences in daily feed intake, total digestible nutrients and digestible crud protein intake could be noted with supplementation of essential oils in indigenous dairy cattle. The inconsistent conclusions between the various studies may be related to essential oil composition, additive amount, coating process, the different animals’ growth stage, duration of feeding and feeding environment.