Caspase-9 immunostaining findings
Caspase-9 activity was observed to be positive only in epithelial cells in all groups in the present study.
In the control group, no immuno-reaction was observed in crypts in duodenal sections, but there was moderate immuno-reaction in villi epithelial cells (Fig 1A). At the same time, a weak immuno-reaction was noted in the crypt and villi in the jejunum (Fig 1B) and ileum (Fig 1C) (Table 1). In the heat stress group, strong immunoreaction was observed in the crypt and villi in the duodenum (Fig 2A). In the jejunum, a strong reaction was observed in the villi, while there was a weak immuno-reaction in the crypts (Fig 2B). In the ileum, a moderate positive reaction was noted in the villi, crypts (Fig 2C) and lymph follicles (Fig 2D) (Table 1). For heat stress + vitamin E group, in the duodenum, moderate positivity was found in the villi (Fig 3A), but not observed in the crypts (Fig 3B). In the jejunum, the positive reaction was found to be moderate in the villi and weak in the crypts (Fig 3C). In the ileum, there was a weak reaction at the crypts and lymph follicles, while villi epithelium was found to be moderately (Fig 3D) (Table 1).
Caspase-8 immunostaining findings
Regarding caspase 8 in all groups, a positive reaction was found in both epithelium and connective tissue in this study. Weak cytoplasmic staining was observed in the duodenum in the control group. There was a weak immuno-reaction in the crypts, villi and connective tissue (Fig 4A). In the jejunum, weak or negative immuno-reaction was observed in the crypts, while there was a weak reaction in the villi (Fig 4B). In the ileum, weak or negative immuno-reactions were observed in the crypts, while moderate immuno-reaction was observed in the connective tissue, villi and lymph follicles (Fig 4C). Moderate positivity was observed in the villi and weak reaction in the crypt of the duodenum (Fig 5A). Weak immuno-reaction was observed in the villi and crypts in the jejunum in the heat stress group (Fig 5B). Strong immuno-reaction was observed in the villi and lymph follicles, while negative immuno-reaction was observed in the crypts. (Fig 5C). Negative or weak immuno-reaction was observed in the crypts of the duodenum (Fig 6A), jejunum (Fig 6B) and ileum (Fig 6C) in the Heat stress + vitamin E group. There was a moderate immuno-reaction in the lymph follicles (Fig 6C) (Table 2).
TNF-α immunostaining findings
As for TNF-α, a weak immuno-reaction was observed in the villi, crypt epithelium and lymph follicles in the duodenum (Fig 7A), jejunum (Fig 7B) and ileum (Fig 7C) in the control group. A moderate immuno-reaction was found in all parts of the duodenum (Fig 8A) while weak immuno-reaction was observed in the villi, crypt and lymph follicles in the jejunum (Fig 8B) and ileum (Fig 8C) in the heat stress group. The reaction was less than heat stress in all regions of the duodenum in the Heat stress + vitamin E group (Fig 9A). The immuno-reaction in the jejunum was found to be not much different compared to heat stress (Fig 9B). A weak immuno-reaction was observed in both villi and crypt of the ileum in de Heat stress + vitamin E group (Fig 9C) (Table 3).
IL-6 immunostaining findings
Regarding IL-6, weak positivity was observed in the cytoplasm in all areas in the duodenum (Fig 10A) and jejunum (Fig 10B) in the control group. In the ileum, weak immuno-reaction was observed in the lymph follicles, but there was a moderate immuno-reaction in the villi (Fig 10C). A weak reaction was observed in all areas in all three regions in the Heat stress group (Fig 11A, 11B, 11C). All regions in the Heat stress + vitamin E group exhibited immuno-reaction similar to the control (Fig 12A, 12B, 12C) (Table 4).
Caspases are a conserved family of cysteine-aspartic proteases that mediate programmed cell death and inflammation (
Avrutsky and Troy, 2021). Caspase-9, as the most extensively studied initiator caspase, is an important factor in the intrinsic or mitochondrial pathway involved in various stimuli, including chemotherapies, stress agents and radiation
(Li et al., 2017). Miao et al., (2020) found no significant variation in the protein levels of caspase 3 and caspase 9 in the livers of broilers that were exposed to a maximum temperature of 35°C for 6 hours.
Aengwanich and Wandee (2022) examined the blood cells of broilers at different temperature ranges. They found that caspase-9 and caspase-3 activities decreased at 42-43°C, but caspase 9 and caspase 3 activities increased at 44-45°C and higher temperatures. This was attributed to the increase in heat shock proteins (HSP70) against heat stress at temperatures between 42 and 43°C and the suppression of apoptosis by that increase. Caspase-9 activity was observed to be positive only in epithelial cells in all groups in the present study. The heat stress group in this study was exposed to heat stress at 35°C (5 hours/day). Caspase-9 activity was found to increase significantly in all small intestinal sections of the animals in the heat stress group. Unlike,
Miao et al., (2020), it was considered that the increase in caspase-9 activity in the intestines at 35°C may be caused by two reasons. The first one is due to the small intestinal epithelium being the most rapidly affected part of the intestinal epithelium by environmental factors and the second one may be the exposure of the experimental group to heat stress for a long period of time as three weeks. However, caspase-9 activity in the vitamin E-supplemented group reacted closely to the control group.
Caspase-8 is the first cysteine protease identified as an apical caspase that triggers exogenous apoptosis
(Muzio et al., 1996). Caspase-8 activates other caspases such as caspase-3-7-9 to initiate apoptosis and thus induce apoptosis
(Aral et al., 2019). Imao et al., (2006) discovered that recurrent heat stress increased caspase-8 activity while studying apoptosis that heat stress induced in mouse liver. The present study revealed that caspase-8 activity increased in both epithelial and connective tissue in chicken intestines that were exposed to heat stress at 35°C (5 hours/day). However, vitamin E was observed to increase the caspase activity closer to the control group. This indicates that vitamin E showed antioxidant activity by decreasing the rate of increase of caspase-8 in the broiler intestinal epithelium because the control group was not exposed to heat stress.
Under stress conditions such as heat stress, different immune cells secrete pro-inflammatory cytokines
(Siddiqui et al., 2020). TNF-α is reported to increase in egg-laying hens under heat stress, resulting in a decrease in the number of follicles and egg production in the ovary
(Li et al., 2020). However,
Lendez et al., (2021) found that the expression of TNF-α and its receptors decreased in dairy cattle under heat stress conditions. They argued in their study that the immune system of animals was affected by heat stress and that animals that are physiologically unable to resist high temperatures may have a less effective immune response and therefore may be more susceptible to opportunistic infections. It is reported that exposure of broilers to both acute and chronic heat stress can elevate serum corticosteroid levels and induce intestinal inflammation (
Quinteiro-Filho et al., 2012).
Tang et al., (2021) reported that the levels of TNF-α and caspase-1 protein in the duodenum and ileum of poultry were significantly increased by heat stress. Duodenum in particular was reported to be more susceptible to heat stress-induced inflammation than other parts of the small intestine. It was observed in the present study that heat stress increased TNF-α activity in all three parts of the small intestine in broilers, especially in the duodenum. However, TNF-α activity in the group with vitamin E was found to be closer to the control group like caspase 8.
IL-6 is reported to be produced by immune-mediated cells, mesenchymal cells, vascular endothelial (VE) cells, fibroblasts and many other cells under physiological and pathological conditions
(Tanaka et al., 2014). In 42-day-old chickens, heat stress was observed to raise the serum concentration of IL-6. This was reported to be a systemic inflammatory response
(Li et al., 2020). The increase in IL-6 induced by stress was observed to decrease in the jejunum but not the ileum when Galacto-oligosaccharide was introduced to the diets of chickens kept under heat stress conditions. It was stated that a difference in the micro-biota composition between the ileum and jejunum may be the cause of the more severe heat-induced damage observed in the ileum
(Varasteh et al., 2015). In the present study, it was observed that heat stress at 35°C (5 h/day), which started in the 4
th week and ended in the 6
th week after incubation, caused no difference between the groups in the level of IL-6 in all sections of the small intestine. However, IL-6 activity was higher in the ileum in all groups but not in all regions. This supports that the difference in micro-biota composition causes IL-6 activity to be higher in the ileum, as stated by
Varasteh et al., (2015).
The intestinal mucosa has a unique position in mucosal immunity and exhibits complex defense mechanisms
(Wu et al., 2016). This study put forth the effects of heat stress and vitamin E given for protection on TNF- α, IL-6, caspase-9 and caspase-8 in the duodenum, jejunum and ileum mucosa of broilers. It is of primary significance to expel damaged cells from the healthy medium to inhibit proliferative diseases in the life cycle
(Li et al., 2017).