Growth performance
Growth performance and feed efficiency of climbing fed with varying levels of dietary crude protein are shown in Table 2. In this present study, varying levels of dietary crude protein had a significant effect on growth rate, specific growth rate (SGR), daily growth coefficient (DGC), feed conversion ratio (FCR), feed efficiency ratio (FER) and protein efficiency ratio (PER). Our findings indicated that, diets with crude protein levels 35% and 38% demonstrated better growth performance and nutrient utilization compared to other treatments. The highest weight gain (8.49±0.08 g) was observed in fish fed with 38% (CP 38) crude protein fed diet. In terms of SGR (4.68±0.12% day
-1) and DGC (2.10±0.04 %day
-1), the highest values were recorded in the 35% (CP 35) crude protein fed diet. The growth rate of climbing perch increased progressively with increasing dietary protein levels from 25% to 38% crude protein containing diet. Although, the maximum growth parameters were obtained when fish were fed with 38% crude protein containing diet, there were no significant differences was observed in growth parameters between the 38% (CP 38) and 35% (CP 35) diet fed groups. Therefore, the 35 % crude protein diet is considered as optimal due to its cost effectiveness, efficient nutrient utilization and reduced environmental impact.
Charoentesprasit and Jiwyam (1996) reported that a diet with 30% protein resulted in maximum growth of
Anabas testudineus, while
Hossain et al. (2012) found that 40% dietary protein is the optimal level for maximum growth in the climbing perch. The present study also found 35-38% crude protein as optimal level. No significant difference (P>0.05) was observed in the survival of fish fed with different crude protein diets, which is similar to the finding of Arshad
Hossain et al. (2012) in
Pampus argenteus. Feed intake in climbing perch showed no significant difference (P>0.05) among the dietary groups fed with different dietary protein levels, indicating that variations in protein content did not affect the feeding behavior of the climbing perch. However, some studies reported that fish regulate feed intake based on protein intake rather than energy
(Li et al., 2017).
In the present study, feed conversion ratio (FCR) and protein efficiency ratio (PER) were recorded as suboptimal when the fish were fed with diets containing lower protein levels (25%, 30%). However, improvement in FCR and PER was observed with elevated levels (35% and 38%) of dietary protein in their diet. In addition, better FCR (1.37±0.06) and PER (0.09±0.003) were observed in fish fed with CP 35 diet. Similar trends of FCR and PER values were also reported by
Kim and Lee (2009) in
Takifugu rubripes and
Ahmed and Maqbool (2017) in
Cyprinus carpio var specularis. The enhancement of PER with each elevated protein level suggests that the appropriate protein level resulted in the highest PER, indicating the optimal protein availability for supporting the fish growth and maintenance (
Ahmed and Ahmad, 2020). In the present study, CP 35 group exhibited a higher protein utilization value (PUV) (30.33±1.19%), suggesting that this level of crude protein is optimal for climbing perch
.
Apparent digestibility coefficient (ADC)
The apparent digestibility coefficient of climbing perch fed with varying levels of dietary crude protein is presented in Fig 1. Significant difference (P<0.05) was observed in the ADC of dry matter, crude protein and crude lipid of climbing perch fed with different diets. The highest values of ADC dry matter (72.24±0.27%), crude protein (82.44±0.52%) and crude lipid (84.59±0.62%) were observed in CP 38 dietary group. However, ADC did not differ significantly among the fish fed with CP 35 and CP 38 dietary groups.
Apparent digestibility coefficients (ADCs) are becoming more widely used by aquaculture nutritionists and feed developers to assess the quality of diet ingredients and dietary formulations (
Hardy, 2010). In the present study, the highest ADC of dry matter, crude protein and crude lipid observed in the groups fed with higher protein diets (35% and 38%), indicating that increased protein levels enhanced nutrient absorption and utilization. The lower ADC values in the lower protein fed groups (25% and 30%), indicating that inadequate dietary protein negatively impacts the fish’s ability to digest and absorb nutrients effectively. These findings highlight the importance of formulating diets with optimal protein levels to maximize growth performance and overall health in climbing perch. Similar to the present study,
Gul et al. (2007) reported the better ADC values in diets of
Labeo rohita containing optimal dietary protein level.
Digestive enzymes
The digestive enzyme activity levels of climbing perch fed with varying levels of dietary crude protein are shown in Fig 2, 3 and 4. The protease and amylase activities exhibited significant difference (P<0.05) across the treatments, while lipase activity did not show any significant difference among the treatments. The significantly higher protease activity was observed in the intestine (4.10±0.07 U mg protein
-1 min
-1) and liver (2.52±0.04 U mg protein
-1 min
-1) of the CP 38 dietary group. However, these results are not significantly varied with the 35% crude protein diet fed group. The highest amylase activity, in both the intestine (1.45±0.05 U mg protein
-1 min
-1) and liver (0.81±0.03 U mg protein
-1 min
-1), was observed in the CP 25 dietary group.
The digestive enzyme activities influence the nutrient utilization and fish growth performance which indicates the optimal availability of dietary nutrients in intestine
(Sagada et al., 2017). Our results showed that dietary protein levels significantly influenced the digestive enzyme activities in climbing perch. Specifically, amylase activity in both the intestine and liver were inversely correlated with dietary protein content, while protease activity was enhanced with increasing protein levels. The amylase activity was decreased with increased levels of dietary protein, mainly due to the lower digestible carbohydrate (NFE) in the groups fed with higher protein diets
(Mohanta et al., 2008; Talukdar et al., 2020, 2021). In contrast to the present results, amylase activity was increased in rainbow trout (
Oncorhynchus mykiss) fed with higher protein diets (
Kawai and Ikeda, 1973). On the other side, the protease activity was positively correlated with increased levels of dietary protein. These results consistent with the findings of
Talukdar et al. (2020) in
Mugil cephalus. Interestingly, lipase activity remained unaffected by varying levels of dietary protein, which could be attributed to the equivalent lipid content of the diets. Similar findings also reported by
Lundstedt et al. (2004) in
Pseudoplatystoma corruscans and
Talukdar et al. (2021) in
Anabas testudineus.
Whole body composition
Whole body compositions of climbing perch fed with varying levels of dietary crude protein are presented in Table 3. Significant difference (P<0.05) was observed in whole body composition of fish fed with different diets. The highest moisture content was recorded in CP 25 (77.99±0.07%) dietary group. The highest crude protein (14.48±0.04%), crude lipid (3.52±0.03%) and crude fibre (1.87±0.05%) was observed in the CP 38 dietary group. In contrast, the ash content reduced with increasing levels of dietary protein, with the highest value was observed in CP 25 (1.94±0.03%) while the lowest was observed in CP 38 (1.61±0.03%). However, the study found increase in the crude protein, crude lipid and crude fiber contents at the end of the experiment.
Body composition of fish is influenced by various factors including dietary protein, digestible energy to protein ratio, size of the fish and environmental factors
(Li et al., 2006). In the present study, fish moisture content was linearly decreased with increasing levels of dietary crude protein in the diet. The minimum moisture content was recorded in the CP 38 group, while the highest protein content was noted in CP 38 group. These results indicated that whole body protein content of climbing perch increased with elevated levels of dietary protein. However, there were no significant differences in whole body composition between the fish fed the 38% (CP 38) and those fed with 35% (CP 35) crude protein diet. Similar results were also reported in
Paralichthys olivaceus (Kim et al., 2002), Bidyanus bidyanus (
Yang et al. 2002),
Oncorhynchus mykiss (
Ahmed and Ahmad, 2020)
. Kim and Lee (2009) found that whole body protein content increased in a dose dependent manner in response to dietary protein levels and exhibited higher crude protein content on the dietary protein level where maximum growth rate was achieved. Crude lipid content increased with elevated dietary protein levels, which is in consistent with the findings of
Khan et al. (1993) in
Mystus nemurus and
Siddiqui and Khan (2009) in
Heteropneustes fossilis. Crude fibre also increased with elevated levels of dietary protein. In contrast, ash content showed a negative correlation with the dietary protein levels.