Length-weight relationship
A total of 891 fish (n = 476 (F) and 415 (M)) were examined for the Length-Weight Relationship (LWR). For females, the length ranged from 19.5 cm to 75.1 cm and weight ranged from 103.5 g to 4276.0 g. Similarly, the length of males ranged from 19.7 cm to 76.5 cm and weight from 130.1 g to 4346.1 g. Linearizing the two variables (Length and Weight) by taking their logarithmic values and then regressing them gave the linear expressions of LWR for males and females (Table 1). LWR parameters of
P.
filamentosus resulted in the intercept ‘a’ value for female, male and pooled sexes as 0.051, 0.057 and 0.053, respectively. The slope ‘b’ value is slightly higher in females (2.651) than males (2.638). The logarithmic relationship of length and weight for females, males and pooled sexes is represented in scatterplots (Fig 2 a, b and c). R
2 values of female, male and pooled sexes were observed as 0.966, 0.976 and 0.970, respectively. The regression coefficient ‘b’ is less than 3, indicating a negative allometric growth for males, females and pooled sexes of
P.
filamentosus. The allometric growth of
P.
filamentosus was statistically proved by a statistical test of hypothesis, with a null hypothesis H0: b= 3 against the alternate hypothesis H1: b≠3. The results showed that there was a significant de
viation from the cubic relationship of length and weight in both males and females (females, t
(476) = (-15.25), p<0.05 and males, t
(415) = (-17.90), p<0.05). Given that the p-value was less than the significance level, we reject the null hypothesis of the isometric relationship and accept the allometric growth of
P.
filamentosus.
LWR shows isometric, negative allometric or positive allometric growth pattern in fishes
(Kop et al., 2019). LWR is a major parameter that provides valuable information regarding the conditions of fish stock in a region
(Rao et al., 2024). The coefficient of correlation (R
2) determines the strength and reliability of the length-weight relationship (LWR). A high R
2 value (close to 1) indicates a strong relationship between length and weight, suggesting accurate predictions, whereas a low R
2 value suggests variability due to environmental or biological factors
(Froese, 2006).
Kamikawa et al., (2015) reported the ‘a’ value for six
Pristipomoides sp. ranged from 0.018 to 0.135, the ‘b’ values ranged from 2.91 to 3.11 and the coefficient of determination ‘R
2’ ranged from 0.96 to 0.99, which aligns with the findings of the present study. Similarly,
Wilson et al., (2019) recorded ‘b’ values for
P.
filamentosus males (2.783), females (3.0134) and the pooled sexes (2.903), indicating an isometric growth pattern for females and a negative allometric growth pattern for males and the pooled sexes.
Velamala et al., (2020), reported a negative allometric growth pattern in
P.
typus (2.993) and
P.
multidens (2.644). In a recent investigation by
Nair et al., (2021), the ‘b’ values for
P.
filamentosus indicated isometric growth patterns (b=3) for all three categories (male, female and pooled sexes). LWR was not consistent throughout the year and can vary significantly due to different factors such as health, sex and food availability
(Bagenal and Tesch, 1978;
Froese, 2006).
Relative condition factor
The month-wise and length class-wise mean relative condition factors for females (n= 476) and males (n=415) of
P.
filamentosus were calculated. The Kn value for females varied during the study period from 0.96 to 1.20, with a mean value of 1.05. The peak value was observed in November (1.20±0.02), followed by October (1.13±0.01) and December (1.03±0.02), indicating healthy fish. Kn value was <1 in females during January (0.96±0.02), February (0.98±0.01) and March (0.97±0.02. The Kn value for males varied across the different months studied, ranging from 0.92 to 1.17, with an average of 1.02. The peak values were observed in October (1.17±0.02), followed by November (1.14±0.02) and December (1.04±0.01), indicating the healthy condition of the males during these months. The lowest Kn value for males was observed in February (0.92±0.01) (Fig 3a).
Fakoya et al., (2019) reported that the Kn value of the Gorean snapper,
Lutjanus goreensis, in the coastal zones of Lagos, southwest Nigeria, ranged from 0.80 to 1.07, with a mean value of 1.01 for males and from 0.96 to 1.11, with a mean value of 1.02 for females. In the current study, the Kn value for females ranged from 0.90 to 1.30, with a mean value of 1.03, while for males, it ranged from 0.85 to 1.21, with a mean value of 1.01. The length class-wise variation in Kn value for both females and males showed two peaks (0.90±0.02 and 0.85±0.04) within the length range of 74.5-79.5 cm, FL. The highest Kn value was observed in both sexes: 1.31±0.04 in 49.5–54.5 cm, FL for females and 1.21±0.05 in 54.5–59.5 cm, FL for males (Fig 3 b).
Masood and Farooq (2010) reported a Kn value close to one for four species of Lutjanids-
Lutjanus johnii,
L.
lutjanus,
L.
malabaricus and
L.
fulvus-collected from the Karachi fishing harbour, Pakistan. Similarly,
Rahman et al., (2023) observed a Kn value equal to or close to one for the length-wise relative condition factors of three coral-associated Lutjanids, including
L.
johnii,
L.
quinquelineatus and
L.
xanthopinnis, collected from the Terengganu waters of the South China Sea, Malaysia.
Rodriguez et al., (2023) also reported a length class-wise mean Kn value of one for
L.
synagris from the Colombian Caribbean Sea. The results of the present study suggest that favorable conditions exist in the southern coast of Kerala, India, for
filamentosus. In this study, relatively higher Kn values for both sexes from October to December indicate gonadal maturation during this period. Condition factors can be influenced by various biotic and abiotic factors, including food availability, water quality, age, size, sex and gonad development
(Somy, 2014;
Narasimhaiah et al., 2021).
Sexual dimorphism
A total of 301 immature fish (Females- n = 167, Males- n = 134) and 293 mature fish (Females- n = 172, Males- n = 121) were selected for the analysis of sexual dimorphism and confirmation based on gonadal observation. Fish with a fork length (FL) ) ≥ 32.4 cm for females and FL ) ≥ 32.1 cm for males were classified as mature.
P.
filamentosus exhibited sexual dimorphic characteristics, including distinct changes in body colouration and variations in pigmentation on the pelvic, anal and pectoral fins and modifications of urogenital regions (Table 2). According to
Smith et al., (2014) simplified methodologies for recognizing sexual dimorphism lacking in many marine fishes including deep-water snappers. In the present study, juveniles and subadults of
P.
filamentosus do not exhibit any sexual dimorphic characteristics. However, sexual dimorphic characteristics become evident in larger () ≥ 30.0 cm, FL) and mature fish. Both sexes of juvenile
P.
filamentosus were pale lavender, which gradually became silvery towards the ventral side.
Kami (1973) agreed with our observation that juveniles and subadults of
P.
filamentosus do not exhibit colour variations; these variations become evident only in large adults.
Kami (1973) also confirmed the reliability of colour variations among males and females in sex determination in
P.
filamentosus and
P.
auricilla but did not report the details of these variations.
Both the genital septum and genital papillae were more pronounced at maturity. Gross visual observation of the urogenital region has been proposed as an accurate method to determine the sex of
P.
filamentosus (Luers et al., 2017). The female
Etelis carbunculus has an enlarged, crescent-shaped genital pore and the septum tissue, which divides the two pore openings, resembles papillae. In contrast, the male fish lack a distinct papilla
(Nichols et al., 2022). The variations observed in body and fin colouration and characteristics of urogenital regions of both sexes were confirmed by dissecting the male and female gonads Fig 5 (e) and Fig 5 (f) and correlating the observed features.
Kami (1973) reported traces of yellow colour in the ventral lobe of caudal fin in females and a distinct yellow blotch in the ventral lobe of the caudal fin of large males (>27.0 cm, FL) of
P.
auricilla from Guam. Sexual dimorphism is evident in urogenital modifications in deep water snappers (
P.
zonatus,
P.
seboldii,
Aphareus rutilans and
E.
coruscans) from Hawaii
(Nichols, 2019), similar to that reported in the present study in
P.
filamentosus. Sexual size dimorphism has reported in deep water red snapper (
E.
carbunculus), in which female is 20% longer than males
(Williams et al., 2017). Similarly, males are larger than females of same age group in humpback red snapper (
L.
gibbus)
(Nanami, 2010;
Taylor et al., 2018; Moore, 2019) and Maori snapper (
L.
rivulatus) from north-eastern Australia
(Wakefield et al., 2020).
Along with characteristics such as body pigmentation, fin shape and genital papillae, sexual dimorphism constitutes a significant component of external morphological variation between the sexes
(Andersson, 1994).
Hedrick and Temeles (1989) identified three major adaptive mechanisms that encourage sexual dimorphism in fish: sexual selection, dimorphic niche and food competition. In a food fish breeding program, sexual dimorphic features of fish play a significant role in selecting good specimens of brood fish, which will yield good numbers of healthy eggs.