Reverse transcriptase PCR (RT-PCR) of Fusion protein gene
Confirmation of the virus was made by detection of NDV genome-specific primers designed for F gene, which yielded a product size of 326 bp from all processed samples as visualized on agarose gel (Fig 1). The positive samples were also cross validated using reported primers.
Cytopathic effect of CEF cells following NDV infection
Processed inoculum of fowl isolate (Genotype VII, NDV/F2/22/RSP-2) and pigeon isolate (Genotype II, NDV/P1/22/RSP-2) were inoculated on CEF cell monolayer after 5th passage of culture. CPE evident for both fowl and pigeon isolate were fairly similar (Table 1). In the first passage post-infection (ppi), infectivity with NDV was inapparent. Cytopathic effects were noticeable after 2
nd passage of infection, characterized by disruption of monolayer, cell rounding, vacuolization and detachment (Fig 2). Changes were accelerated in the 3rd passage after virus inoculation.
Gene sequence analysis and comparison between NDV strains
Three representative isolates each from fowls and pigeons belonging to the distinctive geo-spatial areas were selected for nucleotide sequencing and sequences were submitted in the open access, annotated public library- GenBank to allocate accession number for nucleotide and amino acid sequences (Table 2). Comparison of the partial
F gene nucleotide sequences of pigeon and fowl isolates with reference strains, as shown in the (Fig 3) revealed nucleotide homology of 100% between NDV/P1/22/RSP-2 and NDV/P2/22/RSP-2 and 99.6% with NDV/P3/22/RSP-2. One of the fowl isolates NDV/F3/22/RSP-2 was 100% homologous to NDV/P1/22/RSP-2 and NDV/P2/22/RSP-2 and 99.6% homologous to NDV/P3/22/RSP-2. The previously isolated NDV from pigeon in Jammu (MH577764) region was 96.5% homologous to NDV/P1/22/RSP-2 and NDV/P2/22/RSP-2 and 99.8% homologous to NDV/P3/22/RSP-2. NDV/F1/22/RSP-2 shared 99.6% homology whereas NDV/F2/22/RSP-2 shared 69.6% homology with all the three pigeon isolates respectively.
Meanwhile, all the pigeon isolates along with the two fowl isolates clustered within genotype II, forming a separate clade. However, one of the fowl isolate NDV/F2/22/RSP-2 clustered in genotype VII that is a Group of highly velogenic NDV (Fig 4).
Molecular pathotyping
Based on deduced amino acid sequences between positions 110 to 118 for the Fusion gene cleavage site (at position 117, the N-terminus of F1), the fowl and pigeon isolates were pathotyped accordingly (Fig 5). Both the fowl and pigeon isolates had a motif 110G-G-R-R-Q-K-R*F-I118 which revealed that these isolates from fowls and pigeons were of velogenic pathotype.
Comparison of the F gene sequences of the NDV-F2-17-RSP-1 with the reference strains revealed nucleotide homology varying between 88.2%-94.1% (Fig 6). NDV-F2-17-RSP-1(ON918571) sequence had the highest homology of 94.1% with NDV isolated from Iran (KX268351) and lowest homology with MF622047, the isolate from Southern Africa (88.2%). Phylogenetically, the fowl isolate NDV-F2-17-RSP-1 clustered under sub-genotype VII-l which has been also designated under clade VII.1.1 (Fig 7). Upon alignment with other genotype VII isolates, it was found to be unique at various nucleotide positions (Fig 8).
Jammu region is endemic for Newcastle disease and has been documented so far in backyard chicken and pigeons. In spite of the regular outbreaks, the actual prevalence of the disease in backyard fowl and pigeons is difficult to ascertain. The earlier pigeon outbreaks reported by
Chowdhary et al., (2020a) were characterized as a lentogenic genotype-II PPMV-1, whereas the present findings in pigeons revealed genotype-II velogenic PPMV-1 strains.
The primers successfully detected NDV in the clinical samples from both fowl and pigeons and have been cross validated with standard vaccine virus and previously established primers
(Yang et al., 1999). The present primer set could therefore be used for detection of both APMV-1 and PPMV-1.
Strains with low virulence do not have the ability to replicate in the absence of trypsin in the cell culture. However, both isolates were able to easily replicate in absence of trypsin, explaining their virulent pathotypes.
Sequencing and phylogeny revealed that one fowl isolate belonged to genotype VII which is a group of highly virulent NDV circulating across the globe and predominantly reported from the Asian countries
(Shabbir et al., 2012). Genotype VII is one of the most variable genotypes of NDV which is continuously evolving thus forming the novel sub-genotypes. In addition, the isolate further clustered with the chicken isolate in a sub-genotype VII-l, proposed recently under clade 1.1 (VII.1.1) by
Dimitrov et al., (2019). Previous studies have demonstrated the presence of virulent genotype XIII from chickens
(Chowdhary et al., 2020b) in Jammu and genotype VII from chickens in Kashmir which were having close identity to Pakistan isolates, followed by China and Sweden strains (
Maqbool, 2016). The emergence of novel virulent genotype VII.1.1 in the present study indicates that virus is continuously evolving in the field and leading to heavy mortalities among the poultry flocks. In India, prevalence of both genotype VII and XIII in chickens is well documented
(Tirumurugaan et al., 2011; Jakhesara et al., 2014). Its noteworthy that genotype VII in general and sub-genotype VII.1.1 of NDV in particular is one of the emerging genotypes, with increasing isolation rates in poultry flocks in recent years
(Xue et al., 2017). Thus, the present study highlights that genotyping of field isolates need to be carried out to undermine the epidemiological dynamics of evolving or newly emerging NDV strains, especially in context of virulent genotypes such as belonging to VII. The present VII.1.1 isolate was also found to have unique nucleotide residues at various positions when compared to other reference strains, thus revealing mutations of the wild type virus. These mutations underline possible evolution of newer variants with altered virulence and genotypic lineages.
In addition, identification of genotype II from the other two fowl and all three pigeon isolates indicate that it is the predominant genotype in circulation. It is noteworthy to mention that previous pigeon isolate was a lentogenic pathotype sharing 99.4% homology with LaSota vaccine virus and speculated as a spill-over of the vaccine strains into the environment
(Chowdhary et al., 2020a). Surprisingly, the present genotype II isolates were all found to be velogenic with considerable homology to each other, while forming a separate clade from the previously isolate and LaSota. Genotype II is the only group which have both lentogenic and mesogenic pathotypes, apart from velogenic ones (
Czegledi et al., 2002). Seemingly, a shift in pathotypes of genotype II in Jammu region since 2017 (NDV/P/17/RSP-1) corresponding proteolytic polybasic cleavage site (R-R-Q-K-R*F) have occurred. Such shifts have also been documented elsewhere
(Yu et al., 2001). Additionally, outbreaks with genotype II virus have recently been documented from other parts of the country as well
(Bordoloi et al., 2021, Kochiganti et al., 2024).
Moreover, the phylogenetic closeness of two fowl and three pigeon NDV isolates (genotype II) under study hint towards an interspecies transmission potential of the virus.
In the light of the above speculations, it is a cause of great concern, if pigeons become potential reservoirs of NDV, they may disseminate avirulent viruses over time, which mutates to velogenic pathotypes evolving to recombinant strains.
Studies on NDV in Jammu and Kashmir indicated the concurrent prevalence of multiple genotypes with variable pathogenicity within the same state,
i.
e., velogenic and lentogenic genotype II in pigeons and virulent genotypes XIII and VII in fowls. This makes control strategies quiet challenging. Moreover, it has been reported that the strains which are of low virulence for pigeons or other avian species prove to be virulent for chickens as they have the property of selecting highly pathogenic derivatives from non-pathogenic precursors
(Shengqing et al., 2002). In such an event of evolving recombinant strains, the efficacy of vaccine strains would remain questionable, unless trials are conducted to prove otherwise. Moreover, the concept of vaccinating the backyard fowls in the region is seldom practiced; while on the other hand, there has been an indiscriminate use of commercially available LaSota vaccines in pigeons, as admonished earlier
(Chowdhary et al., 2020a).