Chief EditorK.M.L. Pathak
Print ISSN 0367-6722
Online ISSN 0976-0555
NAAS Rating 6.43
Impact Factor 0.5 (2023)
Full Research Article
Efficacy of Silver Coated Foley’s Catheter in Comparison with Latex Foley’s Catheter for Prevention of Antimicrobial Resistance and Catheter Associated Urinary Tract Infections in Obstructive Urolithiasis of Male Buffalo Calves
- Email email@example.com
First Online 14-11-2022|
Methods: The present study was aimed to address the antimicrobial activity and biofilm inhibition effect of silver Foley’s catheter in male buffalo calves suffering from obstructive urolithiasis. The study was conducted on twelve male buffalo calves suffering from obstructive urolithiasis, randomly divided into two groups irrespective of their age viz., group I (latex Foley’s catheter treatment) and group II (silver hydrogel coated Foley’s catheter treatment). Cultural examination and antibiotic sensitivity of cultured bacteria from the urine passed through fixed urinary catheter was performed at 0th, 7th, 14th and 28th postoperative days in both the groups.
Result: There was significant reduction in growth of bacteria like Streptococcus, Staphylococcus and E. coli bacterial colony formation on blood agar and MacConkey lactose agar, respectively in silver catheter group as compare to latex catheter group from day 0 to day 28th. The zone of inhibition was more pronounced for both antibiotics viz., Cefotaxime and Ceftriaxone (upto 24 mm) in urine samples collected from silver hydrogel coated Foley’s catheter as compared to latex Foley’s catheter indicating its biofilm inhibition effect on bacteria. Silver-hydrogel Foley’s Catheter are more cost-effective as compare to latex Foley’s catheter.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In all the cases no complication during surgery was observed and tube cystotomy was performed found safe, reliable technique for retention of urine in buffalo calves. Tube cystotomy include simple procedure, preservation of the reproductive function of the animal and less tendency of recurrences of retention of urine (May et al., 1998). The silver hydrogel Foley’s catheter and latex coated Foley’s catheter was fixed inside the bladder by putting 30 ml of normal saline to inflate the balloon and prevent backward movement of catheter in group I and group II respectively. The underlying muscles, subcutaneous fascia and skin were closed in routine manner after passing the catheter through a subcutaneous tunnel. Post-operatively, the animals were kept under close observations given antibiotics and NSAIDS intramuscularly in non-uniform climatic conditions for 28 days for recording any kind of complications like urethral leakage, blockade, dislodgement of catheter, re-obstruction, suture dehiscence and pus discharge, if any. The urinary catheter was kept closed with needle cap to prevent any external environment infection as much possible to certain extent and open only at the time of urination and sample collection.
Microbiological examination of urine
Urine samples were collected aseptically through tube cystostomy Foley’s catheter postoperatively after removing the needle cap in 5 ml sterile syringes on 0th, 7th, 14th and 28th day in both the groups (Group I and II). Total 48 samples were collected from both groups. From each animal, 2-3 ml urine was collected aseptically in sterile test tube from respective catheter for microbiological examination. The urine sample was cultured for their growth on 90 mm plates of MacConkey lactose agar for E. coli and Klebsiella sp. and blood agar for Streptococcus sp. and Staphylococcus sp. of bacteria respectively. Bacteria are differentiated on the basis of morphological characteristics with the help of gram staining as well as cultural characteristics on the plate seen on simple microscope under 100X and further under contrast microscope. Isolated bacteria were residing in the nutrient broth and then incubate for 4-5 hrs till turbidity appears inside it. After incubation, bacterial broth was streaked on the blood agar, antibiotic discs of cefotaxime and ceftriaxone were placed on the streaked broth of bacteria. After 24 hrs incubation, the zone of inhibition and sensitivity of bacteria was observed against the respective antibiotics.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Microbiological findings were represented in the form of pie diagrams and on agar plates depicting results from group I and II subjected to antibiotic sensitivity testing after bacterial culture over blood agar and MacConkey agar. In group I, twenty-one (88%) samples showed growth while three samples (12%) showed no growth of bacteria after incubation over respective agar media at various day interval from day 0 to day 28th (Fig 1 and Table 1). In group II, from day 0 to day 28th thirteen samples (42%) showed growth while eleven samples (58%) showed no growth after incubation over respective agar media (Fig 1 and Table 2). These findings correlated with Schumm and Lam (2008) where they concluded that silver alloy urinary catheters appear more effective than standard catheters at reducing bacteriuria in patients who require short-term catheterisation. Similarly, five types of bacteria were isolated after culture on MacConkey lactose agar and blood agar in group I, while three types of bacteria were isolated in group II on respective agar. On collection of 24 samples at day 0, 7th, 14th and 28th from each calf of group I, Staphylococcus was most common in 11 (45%) samples, followed by Streptococcus in 6 (22%), E. coli in 4 (19%), Klebsiella in 2 (8%) and Bacillus in 1(6%). Out of 24 samples collected from day 0 to day 28th in group II, Staphylococcus 13(54%) and Streptococcus 10 (41%) were most commonly found followed by E. coli in 4 (16.6%) samples. No Klebsiella and Bacillus spp. were found in group II. In both groups Staphylococcus was most commonly found bacteria followed by Streptococcus, E. coli and Klebsiella which correlated with study conducted by Rupp et al., (2004) which stated that there is 57% symptomatic UTI and 43% asymptomatic UTI caused by coagulase negative Staphylococcus, E. coli and Klebsiella bacteria. Modak et al., (1973) delineated that Pseudomonas and Gonococci are more susceptible to silver ions than Staphylococci. This is due to the thin murein wall of gram-negative bacteria (2-3 nm) in comparison to the greater thickness of murein in gram-positive bacteria (10 nm) as silver ion bound to the murein by adsorption processes induces bacteriostatic effects, whereas at higher silver ion concentrations, bactericidal effects are achieved by silver-DNA-chelate complexes, which corroborates our findings of reducted Klebsiella infection in group II than in group I. Hachem et al., (2009) reported that silver-hydrogel urinary catheter has limited activity on inhibiting the growth of E. coli bacteria which supported our findings in our both groups as silver catheter is ineffective in controlling the infections caused by E. coli.
The zone of beta-haemolysis was observed on blood agar having golden yellow colonies of Staphylococcus and whitish mucoid colonies of Streptococcus in both the groups (Fig 2a). On MacConkey lactose agar, circular smooth colonies of E. coli were observed (Fig 2b) with appearance of flat and dark pink due to lactose fermentation and pale pink mucoid colonies of Klebsiella (Fig 3). In group I, colonies of Bacillus (Fig 4) were found in one sample having characteristics like non-haemolytic, flat, slightly convex with irregular edges on blood agar. Cultured bacteria were observed microscopically at 100X found elongated rod-shape Bacillus (Fig 5a), gram negative, non-motile and rod-shaped E. coli (Fig 5b) along with Klebsiella (Fig 5c). Contrast microscopy of cultured bacteria showed twisted bunch of round berries of Streptococcus (Fig 6a) and round and forms grape like clusters of Staphylococcus (Fig 6b) along with rod-shape non-motile E. coli (Fig 7) were observed. In group I, five samples were found to be sensitive (Zone of inhibition was above 15 mm) to both Cefotaxime and Ceftriaxone (Fig 8), however resistance or no growth (Zone of inhibition was observed below 15mm) was reported in 16 samples. In group II, 9 samples were found to be sensitive to both Cefotaxime and Ceftriaxone, however 15 samples were showed either no growth or resistance to antibiotics (Fig 9). This is in correlation with Schierholz et al., (1998) where they showed in their study that silver coated central venous catheter reduced the infection rate by 50% although there was no reduction of catheter colonization or catheter associated sepsis.
In group I, seventeen (70%) samples collected at different scheduled day of study showed gram positive cocci and seven (29%) showed gram negative rods of which five were sensitive and other sixteen were resistant to both antibiotics. The trend showed zone of inhibition decreased from day 0th to day 28th postoperatively in four cases and nearly constant in two cases (Table 1). In group II, thirteen samples (54%) showed gram positive cocci and four (16%) showed gram negative rods of which six were found sensitive and other four samples were resistant to both cefotaxime and ceftriaxone. The zone of inhibition was increases or absent and going upto 22 to 25 mm as we move from day 0th to day 28th in five cases decreases slightly in one case (Table 2). So, overall sensitivity to both antibiotics against bacteria was more in group having silver coated latex Foley’s catheter. Maki et al., (2001) recorded that use of catheters coated with antimicrobial agents or antiseptics using technologies which help in releasing of ionic silver into the aqueous environment may assist in prevention of CAUTIs caused by intraluminal organisms. The findings of this study are in correlation with the Rupp et al., (2004) where they reported that there is 56% decrease in CAUTI’S (Catheter associated urinary tract infection) in silver alloys catheters. Ogilvie et al., (2018) confirmed in his study of using silver catheter in preventing catheter associated urinary tract infections in short term (<48 hrs) was quite significant as compare to non-silver catheters. Karchmer et al., (2000) also reported reduction in the rate of catheter-associated UTI has ranged from 27% to 73% in his randomized trials involving the silver alloy/hydrogel-coated urinary catheter. The total cost of silver hydrogel coated Foley’s catheter is around 6000 INR for six animals in group II as compare to the cost 1000 INR for latex foley’s catheter in group II is totally defensible as the post-operative cost for antibiotics is reduced due to the ability of silver in preventing bacteria for making biofilm, hence reduced the reoccurrence of antimicrobial resistance from day 7th to day 28th in group II (Table 2) as compare to group I (Table 1). The results of our study is supported by the findings of Rupp et al., (2004) which stated direct cost savings achieved through the use of the coated urinary catheter as compare to uncoated catheters.
Conflict of interest
- Arnoldo, L., Migliavasca, R., Regastin, L., Raglio, A., Pagani, L., Nucleo, E., Spalla, M., Vailati, F., Agodi, A., Mosea, A., Zoth, C., Tardivo, S., Bianco, I., Rulli, A., Gualdi, P., Panetta, P., Pasini, C., Pedroni, M. and Brusaferro, S. (2013). Prevalence of urinary colonization by extended spectrum- beta-lactamase Enterobacteriaceae among catheterized inpatients in Italian long term care facilities. BMC Infectious Diseases. 13: 124.
- Cornia, P.B., Amory, J.K., Fraser, S., Saint, S. and Lipsky, B.A. (2003). Computer-based order entry decreases duration of indwelling urinary catheterization in hospitalized patients. The American Journal of Medicine. 114(5): 404-407.
- Getliffe, K.A. and Mulhall, A.B. (1991). The encrustation of indwelling catheters. British Journal of Urology. 67: 337-341.
- Hachem, R., Reitzel, R., Borne, A., Jiang, Y., Tinkey, P., Uthamanthil, R., Chandra, J., Ghannoum, M. and Raad, I. (2009). Novel antiseptic urinary catheters for prevention of urinary tract infections: Correlation of in vivo and in vitro test results. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy. 53(12): 5145-5149.
- Hooton, T.M., Bradley, S.F., Cardenas, D.D., Colgan, R., Geerlings, S.E., Rice, J.C., Saint, S., Schaeffer, A.J., Tambyah, P.A., Tenke, P. and Nicolle, L.E. (2010). Diagnosis, prevention and treatment of catheter-associated urinary tract infection in adults. International Clinical Practice Guidelines from the Infectious Diseases Society of America. Clinical Infectious Diseases. 50: 625-663.
- Karchmer, T.B., Giannetta, E.T., Muto, C.A., Strain, B.A., Farr, B.M. (2000). A randomized crossover study of silver-coated urinary catheters in hospitalized patients. Arch Intern. Med. 160: 3294-8.
- Magill, S.S., Edwards, J.R., Bamberg, W., Beldaus, Z.G., Dumyati, G., Kainer, M.A., Lynfield, R., Maloney, M., McAllister- Hollod, L., Nadle, J., Ray, S.M., Thompson, D., Wilson, L.E. and Fridkin, S.K. (2014). Multistate point-prevalence survey of health care-associated infections. The New England Journal of Medicine. 370: 1198-1208.
- Majeed, A., Sagar, F., Latif, A., Hassan, H., Iftikhar, A., Darouiche, R.O. and Mohajer, M.A. (2019). Does antimicrobial coating and impregnation of urinary catheters prevent catheter- associated urinary tract infection? A review of clinical and preclinical studies. Expert Review of Medical Devices. 16(9): 809-820.
- Maki, D.G. and Tambyah, P.A. (2001). Engineering out the risk for infection with urinary catheters. Emerging Infectious Diseases. 7(2): 342-347.
- May, K.A., Moll, H.D., Wallace, L.M., Pleasant, R.S., Howard, R.D. (1998). Urinary bladder marsupialization for treatment of obstructive urolithiasis in male goats. Veterinary Surgery. 27: 583-588.
- Modak, S.M. and Fox Jr., C.L. (1973). Binding of silver sulfadiazine in the cellular components of Pseudomonas aeyuginosa. Biochemical Pharmacology. 22(19): 2392-2404.
- Nicolle, L.E. (2012). Urinary catheter associated infections. Infectious Disease Clinics of North America. 26: 13-28.
- Nicolle, L.E. (2014). Catheter associated urinary tract infections. Antimicrobial Resistance and Infection Control. 3(23): 1-8.
- Ogilvie, A.T., Brisson, B.A., Gow, W.R., Wainberg, S., Singh, A. and Weese, J.S. (2018). Effects of the use of silver-coated urinary catheters on the incidence of catheter-associated bacteriuria and urinary tract infection in dogs. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association. 253(10): 1289-1293.
- Rupp, M.E., Fitzgerald, T., Marion, N., Helget, V., Puumala, S. anderson, J.R. and Fey, P.D. (2004). Effect of Silver-coated Urinary Catheters Efficacy, Cost-effectiveness and Antimicrobial Resistance. Department of Internal Medicine, University of Nebraska Medical Centre: 272. doi: 10.1016/j.ajic.2004. 05.002.
- Saint, S., Lipsky, B.A. and Goold, S. (2002). Indwelling urinary catheters: A onepoint restraint? Annals of Internal Medicine. 137(2): 125-127.
- Schumm, K. and Lam, T. (2008). Types of urethral catheters for management of short-term voiding problems in hospitalised adults. Cochrane Database Systematic Reviews. 2. doi: 10.1002/14651858.
- Siddiq, D.M. and Darouiche, R.O. (2012). New strategies to prevent catheter associated urinary tract infections. Nature Reviews Urology. 9(6): 305-314.
- Stickler, D.J. (2008). Bacterial biofilms in patients with indwelling urinary catheters. Nature Clinical Practice Urology. 5(11): 598-608.
- Zarb, P., Coignard, B., Griskeviciene, J., Muller, A., Vankerckhoven, V., Weist, K. and Suetens, C. (2012). The European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) pilot point prevalence survey of healthcare-associated infections and antimicrobial use. Eurosurveillance. 17(46): 20316.
- Schierholz, J.M., Lucas, L.J., Rump, A. and Pulverer, G. (1998). Efficacy of silver-coated medical devices. Journal of Hospital Infection. 40(4): 257-262.
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.