Data on hip morphology on the breed would provide an opportunity for more sensitive treatment planning and better outcome in CHD. Complete hip joint metrics in GSD breed dogs are discussed in the present study.
GSD breed dogs below 6 months of age (Group I)
Mean ± S.E values of hip joint metrics and
p-values showing only significant difference (p<0.05) are presented in Table 1. HAL is the distance along the femoral neck axis from the base of the greater trochanter to the inner pelvic brim. Higher HAL value was associated with increased femoral neck width and HAL is related to femoral strength.
HAL values differed non significantly between healthy hip joint and CHD. Within the group of dogs with healthy hip joint, non significant difference in HAL values were observed between male and female dogs and right and left hip joints. HAL was significantly higher in male Sivas Kangal dogs with healthy hip joints
(Sarierler et al., 2017). On the contrary, in the present study, in CHD, HAL values were higher in male dogs. HAL values were similar in unilateral or bilateral CHD.
Non significant difference in FNALa and FNALb values were observed between healthy hip joint and CHD and between right and left limbs irrespective of CHD. FNALa values were significantly higher in female dogs with healthy hip. FNALb values were significantly higher in unilateral CHD.
AW values were significantly higher in dogs with CHD. AW values were similar in male and female dogs, in right and left limbs of all dogs. AW values were significantly higher in bilateral CHD and on higher side in female dogs with unilateral CHD and in male having bilateral CHD.
FSC values were similar in dogs with healthy hip joint or with CHD. Within the group of dogs with healthy hip joints there was non significant difference among male and females, in right and left limbs. FSC was higher in female dogs in CHD and higher in bilateral CHD. FSC was thicker in male dogs with a healthy hip joint in Sivas Kangal breed
(Sarierler et al., 2017).
HD was significantly different between healthy hip and CHD. Dogs with CHD had higher HD values. Within the group of dogs with healthy hip joint, there was non significant difference between male and female dogs, in right and left limbs. In CHD, female dogs had significantly higher HD values. HD values were similar in unilateral and bilateral CHD.
ND values were significantly higher in dogs with healthy hip joint. Within the group of dogs with healthy hip joints female dogs had significantly higher ND values. TW values were similar in all dogs irrespective of CHD. TW values were significantly higher in female dogs with CHD. TW values were similar in unilateral or bilateral CHD.
FSD values were similar in all dogs irrespective of CHD. Within the group of dogs with CHD, FSD values were higher in female dogs. FSD values were similar in unilateral and bilateral CHD. FSD values were higher in female dogs in unilateral CHD.
FIA is biomechanically important in the transfer of forces from the femur to the acetabulum and increased FIA was reported in CHD (
Madsen and Svalastoga, 1994). An association between hip status and inclination angle was recorded (
Hauptman et al., 1985 and
Sarierler, 2004). There was significant difference in FIA values between dogs with healthy hip joint and CHD. FIA values were similar in male and female dogs, in right and left limbs when the hip joint was healthy, where as in CHD, FIA values were significantly higher in male dogs.
There was no variation HNI values between dogs with healthy hip joint and CHD. Among dogs with healthy hip joint, HNI values were significantly higher in male dogs. HNI values were higher in unilateral CHD.
The acetabular angle (AA/ACM) derived by Idelberger and Frank is a measure of the acetabular depth. AA values were significantly higher in CHD (
Tonnis, 1987) in the present study. AA values were similar between male and female dogs, right or left limbs irrespective of CHD.
EAA values were significantly higher in CHD. Higher EAA values were observed in cases of acetabular dysplasia
(Delaunay et al., 1997). EAA values were similar in male and female dogs, right and left limbs irrespective of CHD. EAA values were significantly higher in unilateral CHD and male dogs had higher EAA values in unilateral CHD.
Normal AHI values ranged between 70% and 90%, with an average of 90% (
Tonnis, 1987). In the present study, AHI values were significantly higher in dogs with healthy hip joint. AHI values were similar in male and female dogs, right and left limbs whether the hip joint was healthy or dysplastic. AHI values were significantly higher in unilateral CHD and male dogs had higher AHI values in unilateral CHD.
Subluxation is reported to be minimal when 50 per cent of the diameter of the femoral head is within the acetabulum
(Farese et al., 1998 and
Tomlinson and Johnson, 2000). Norberg angle (
Tomlinson and Johnson, 2000) different distraction indices (
Heyman et al., 1993) and the percentage coverage of the femoral head (
Tomlinson and Johnson 2000) have been used to assess the degree of lateral displacement of the femoral head from the acetabulum. In the present study, PC values were significantly higher in dogs with healthy hip joint (
Lopes et al., 2018) and male dogs had higher PC values within the healthy dogs. PC values were higher in unilateral CHD.
NA is a quantitative method of assessing the hip joint for dysplasia and is commonly considered a measure of laxity
(Adams et al., 2000). A normal hip was reportedly considered to have an NA greater than 105
o and it is more likely that the dog will develop osteoarthritis as the subluxation progresses
(Lust et al., 2001). Dogs with healthy hip joint had significantly higher NA values. NA values did not differ significantly between male and female dogs, right and left limb in all the dogs. Significantly higher NA values were observed in dogs with unilateral CHD and female dogs had higher NA values in bilateral CHD.
Measurement of the DI involves measuring relative displacement of the femoral head from the acetabulum on a stress radiographic view of the pelvis. A DI value of 0.3 was established as a susceptibility threshold value for DJD
(Kapatkin et al., 2002). In the present study significantly higher DI and SI values were observed in dogs with CHD. SI values were significantly higher in bilateral CHD. DI and SI values did not differ significantly between male and female dogs, right and left limbs within the group of dogs with healthy or dysplastic hip joint.
GSD breed dogs between 6 to 12 months of age (Group II)
Mean ± S.E values of hip joint metrics and
p-values showing only significant difference (
p<0.05) are presented in Table 1. HAL values were non significantly different between healthy hip joint and CHD. HAL values were similar in male and female dogs and in right and left limbs in healthy hip joint. HAL was significantly higher in male Sivas Kangal dogs with healthy hip joints. HAL values were significantly different between male and female dogs in CHD where in male dogs had higher HAL values. HAL values were similar in unilateral or bilateral C HD.
FNALa and FNALb values were significantly higher in CHD. In dogs with healthy hip joint, male dogs had significantly higher FNALa and FNALb values. Similar observation was recorded in Sivas Kangal dog breed
(Sarierler et al., 2017). FNALa and FNALb values were higher in female dogs in CHD.
AW values were non significantly different between dogs with healthy hip joint and dogs with CHD. Female dogs had higher AW values irrespective of whether the hip joint was healthy or dysplastic or whether the CHD was unilateral or bilateral. On the contrary, higher AW values were recorded in male Sivas Kangal breed dogs with healthy hip joint.
There was non significant difference in FSC values between dogs with healthy hip joint and dogs with CHD. Within the group of healthy hip joints FSC values were similar in male and females and in right and left limbs. On the contrary, FSC was thicker in male dogs of Sivas Kangal breed
(Sarierler et al., 2017). In the present study, FSC values were significantly higher in male dogs in CHD. The FSC values were similar in unilateral and bilateral CHD.
HD values were similar in dogs with healthy hip joints and in CHD. Non significant difference was observed in between male and female dogs, between right limb and left limb either in healthy hip joint or in CHD, however, male dogs with CHD had higher HD values than male dogs with healthy hip joint.
ND values were significantly higher in dogs with healthy hip joint with no difference in ND values between male and female dogs, right and left limbs. Within the dogs with CHD, ND values were higher in male dogs. The ND values were similar in unilateral and bilateral CHD.
TW values were non significantly different between dogs with healthy hip joint and dogs with CHD where as male dogs with healthy hip joint had significantly higher TW values than female dogs of the same group. On the contrary, in CHD, TW values were higher in female dogs. Male dogs with a healthy hip joint had significantly higher ND values than the male dogs with CHD whereas female dogs with a healthy hip joint had significantly lower ND values compared to female dogs with CHD. TW values were similar in unilateral and bilateral CHD.
FSD values were significantly higher in dogs with healthy hip joint. FSD values were similar in male and female dogs, in right limb and left limb when the hip was healthy where as in CHD, FSD values were significantly higher in male dogs. FSD values were similar in unilateral and bilateral CHD.
FIA values were significantly higher in dogs with healthy hip joint. No such difference was recorded in FIA values by some researchers
(Hauptman et al., 1985) whereas higher FIA values were recorded in CHD (
Madsen and Svalastoga, 1994) by other researchers. In the present study, FIA values were similar in male and female dogs, in right limb and left limbs irrespective of CHD. Age and sex did not affect the FIA values
(Hauptman et al., 1985). FIA values were similar in unilateral and bilateral CHD and male dogs had higher FIA values when the CHD was unilateral.
HNI values were similar in all dogs irrespective of CHD, sex and limb laterality. HNI values were significantly different higher in unilateral CHD. AA values were significantly higher in dogs with CHD (
Tonnis, 1987) Within the group of dogs with healthy hip joint or with CHD, AA values between male and female dogs, right or left limbs did not differ significantly.
EAA values were significantly higher in dogs with CHD. Higher EAA values were observed in acetabular dysplasia
(Delaunay et al., 1997). Within the group of dogs with healthy hip joint, EAA values were significantly higher in male dogs. EAA values were similar in unilateral and bilateral CHD. Male dogs had significantly higher EAA values in unilateral CHD.
AHI values were significantly higher in dogs with healthy hip joint and male dogs had significantly higher AHI values within the group. AHI values were significantly higher in unilateral CHD. PC values were significantly higher in dogs with healthy hip joint. PC values were similar in male and female dogs, right and left limbs irrespective of CHD. PC values were significantly higher in dogs with unilateral CHD.
Dogs with healthy hip joint had significantly higher NA values. NA values did not differ significantly between male and female dogs, right and left limbs irrespective of CHD. NA values were significantly higher in dogs with unilateral CHD.
DI and SI values were significantly higher in CHD. Within the group of dogs with healthy hip joint and with CHD, both DI and SI values did not differ significantly between male and female dogs, right and left limbs. Significantly higher DI and SI values were observed in bilateral CHD.