Indian Journal of Animal Research

  • Chief EditorK.M.L. Pathak

  • Print ISSN 0367-6722

  • Online ISSN 0976-0555

  • NAAS Rating 6.50

  • SJR 0.263

  • Impact Factor 0.5 (2023)

Frequency :
Monthly (January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November and December)
Indexing Services :
Science Citation Index Expanded, BIOSIS Preview, ISI Citation Index, Biological Abstracts, Scopus, AGRICOLA, Google Scholar, CrossRef, CAB Abstracting Journals, Chemical Abstracts, Indian Science Abstracts, EBSCO Indexing Services, Index Copernicus
Indian Journal of Animal Research, volume 56 issue 3 (march 2022) : 362-368

Delineation of the Stock Structure of White Sardine Escualosa thoracata (Valenciennes, 1847) Along the Indian Waters based on Biometric Analysis

Prem Singh Prajapat1, B.K. Sharma3, B.B. Nayak1, V. Ramasubramanian2, Tincy Varghese1, Vikas Pathak1, Zeba Jaffer Abidi1,*
1ICAR-Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Mumbai-400 061, Maharashtra, India.
2ICAR-Indian Agricultural Statistical Research Institute, New Delhi-110 012, India.
3College of Fisheries, Maharana Pratap University of Agriculture and Technology, Udaipur-313 001, Rajasthan, India.
Cite article:- Prajapat Singh Prem, Sharma B.K., Nayak B.B., Ramasubramanian V., Varghese Tincy, Pathak Vikas, Abidi Jaffer Zeba (2022). Delineation of the Stock Structure of White Sardine Escualosa thoracata (Valenciennes, 1847) Along the Indian Waters based on Biometric Analysis . Indian Journal of Animal Research. 56(3): 362-368. doi: 10.18805/IJAR.B-4769.
Background: An understanding of the stock structure of commercially exploited species is important for effective fisheries management. The white sardine Escualosa thoracata (Valenciennes, 1847) forms a significant fishery along with both the costs of India. The decline in the resource landings during the last decade along the whole range of its distribution necessitated the recent deliberations to recognize the likely existence of stocks. In the present study, fish stocks are typically identified based on the differences in phenotypic characteristics between fish from discrete units to assess the stock structure of white sardine in the Indian waters using a biometric analysis.

Methods: Different four distinct locations, two each from the west coast (Mumbai and Cochin) and east coast (Kolkata and Chennai) along the Indian peninsula were surveyed based on the geographical situation during 2016. The collected samples of Escualosa thoracata were determined morpho-meristic based deliberationsand subsequently, the data analysis was carried out to recognize the likely existence of stocks.

Result: Biometric analysis used as one of the important complementary contributions to manage and control the management-related problems in the future. The results obtained by the morphometric and the meristic analyses, were correlated and conformed.
Apart from major clupeoid fishes, the lesser sardines, a multispecies group, also happens to be a valuable fishery resource of India’s coasts. The fisheries of Escualosa thoracata are almost neglected in the earlier years due to the availability of oil sardine in abundance (Nair, 1951). It supports economically important fishery along India’s south-west coast, but it also occurs in swarms on the east coast. It assumed importance in recent years due to the demand of this species in domestic consumers. Ontogenic changes in body shape, particularly during a key life-history stages, typically resulted in morphometric characteristics (Dwivedi, 2013). Morphometrics and meristic characters have been most frequently used to delineate stocks of various exploited fish species (Murta, 2000; Silva, 2003). Patterns of morphometric variation in fishes showed distractions in growth rates because body form is a product of ontogeny. The phenotypic plasticity of fish allows them to respond adaptively to the dynamic nature of environmental changes by modifying their physiological and behavioral changes, which leads to changes in their morphology that mitigate the effects of environmental changes (Stearns 1983; Meyer, 1987). Morpho-meristic variation between different fish stocks can provide us a useful information which provides basis for its structure and can be applicable for studying short term, environmentally induced variation (Beg et al., 1999). An analysis of morphological variations between different populations continues to have an important role to play in stock differentiation. Ihseen et al., (1981) found that morphometric and meristic characters in fishes provided useful knowledge for identifying marine fish stocks and spatial distributions.
Thus, the present study is aimed to delineate the stock of geographically distant population of E. thoracata in Indian waters to improve fisheries data outcomes for real-time management decision-making.
Study area
Total 334 specimens of Escualosa thoracata were collected in year 2016 in both the west coast (Cochin in Kerala and Mumbai in Maharashtra) and east coast (Kolkata in West Bengal and Chennai in Tamil Nadu). Collected samples were brought to the laboratory of Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Mumbai and washed thoroughlyand subjected to morphometric and meristic studies. Took 18 morphometric and 7 meristic traits with the help of vernier calliper in laboratory for further analysis.
Morphometric studies
Morphometric characters were measured by using scale and vernier calliper for accuracy to the nearest millimetre. Enumerated about 18 Morphometric traits for the present study. The description of the parameters is provided in Table 1.

Table 1: Morphometric traits.

Meristic studies
A total of 135 specimens of E. thoracata from each west coast and east coast in the year 2016 were brought to the laboratory and following meristic counts were made. The characters were counted by using magnifying lens and needle to separate the rays. The number of dorsal fin rays (NDFR), number of pectoral-fin rays (NPFR), number of pelvic fin rays (NPEFR). The number of anal-fin rays (NAFR), Pre-pelvic scute (PREPES), Post-pelvic scute (POPES).
Data analysis was carried out separately for morphometric and meristic characters because these variables are different statistically; the morphometric are continuous, varied due to environmental changes, while meristic are discrete characters fixed in developmental phases. PROC MEANS procedure (SAS Institute, 2000) was used to estimate the descriptive statistics viz. minimum value maximum value, mean, standard error and coefficient of variance, for the morphometric traits. The data were tested for normality of distribution. The meristic data were subjected to principal component analysis (PCA) using PROC PRINCOMP procedure of SAS.
The total length of Escualosa thoracata for all collected samples ranged from 7.0 to 11.5 cm with a coefficient of variance of 9.31%. The maximum total length 11.5 cm was recorded in male specimens from Mumbai in the west coast. Among the representatives from the East coast, the maximum total length was reported from a specimen from Chennai (10.1 cm) (Table 2). The total length, standard length, body weightand maximum body depth showed a significant difference between the two coasts and the four locations but was not found in the sexes. After regression analysis with standard length, four morphometric traits such as the eye diameter, pre-pelvic length, preanal lengthand caudal depth indicated significant variance between west and east coasts. Between locations within the coasts, the F-test proved substantial difference for four traits such as head snout length, postorbital length, dorsal base length, body depthand caudal depth. For all traits, F-test depicted that there was no significant variation among sexes. The result indicated that a maximum co-efficient of variation is observed in snout length (13.55%) followed by postorbital length (12.59%), body depth (11.81%). The lowest coefficient of variation was recorded in fork length (8.15%). The eye diameter in the east coast ranged from 0.34 to 0.62 mm with a mean of 0.49 mm, whereas the range and mean in west coast from 0.39 to 0.70 and 0.52 mm respectively. The mean caudal depth of fishes from the west coast was 0.78 mm and 0.65 mm for the east coast. The mean head length was lowest for the east coast and highest for the west coast. Comparative variability among locations of total length, caudal depth, snout lengthand eye diameter of Escualosa thoracata is shown in Fig 1, 2, 3 and 4. Descriptive statistics of meristic traits is given in Table 3. Out of six characters, five showed the significant variations between east coast and the west coast. The traits which did not show coast-wise and location-wise variation was the number of pelvic fin rays. Five traits, i.e., NDFR, NPFR, NAFR, PREPES and POPES, show significant variation in the east and west coast. In the PCA analysis of the meristic traits of E. thoracata, 68.45% of total variations were explained by the first three principal components together. 34.68% of total variations contributed by PC 1, 21.45% by PC 2 and 15.33% contributed by PC3. Only one trait showed significant loading on PC1, which was POPES and NAFR loaded significantly to the PC2 and NDFR and NAFR loaded significantly on PC3 (Table 4).

Table 2: Descriptive statistics of various morphometric characters (N=334).


Fig 1: Variability plot of total length of Escualosa thoracata.


Fig 2: Variability plot Caudal depth of Escualosa thoracata.


Fig 3: Variability plot of snout length of Escualosa thoracata.


Fig 4: Variability Plot of eye diameter of Escualosa thoracata.


Table 3: Descriptive statistics of meristic characters.


Table 4: Variable loading in principal component analysis of meristic traits.

The analysis clearly shows that the white sardine stocks from two locations on the east coast, i.e. Kolkata and Chennai, vary from those on the west coast. Apart from that, the stocks from Kolkata and Chennai significantly differed in two traits such as NDFRand NAFR. On the west coast, Kochi and Mumbai stocks also showed significant variation in three features such as NPFR, PREPES and POPES. While NPeFR did not show significant variation coast-wise, location wise and sex-wise also. Morphometric analysis revealed significant heterogeneity among the E. thoracata, which is used to separate stock on the Indian coast. The average length of white sardine samples collected from the west coast was significantly higher than the east coast. Also, there was a significant difference in body weight and maximum body depth of fishesand fishes from the west coast were found to be heavier and deeper. The Arabian Sea is one of the world’s most productive areas of the ocean due to a wide range of geo-climatic phenomenon like upwelling, mixing of waterand lateral advection (Kumar et al., 2009).
In contrast, it is traditionally considered a region of lesser biological productivity in the Bay of Bengaland recent measurements for phytoplankton C^14 uptake also support this fact (Kumar et al., 2002). The productive Arabian Sea provides favourable conditions for the continuous supply of food for fishes such as white sardine. This might be the possible reason for this fish characterized by high growth parameters. The stock characteristics of E. thoracata were studied from the north-west coast of India (Raje, 1994, Prajapat, 2015, Rahangdale et al., 2016), south-west coast of India (Abdusamand et al., (2018) and central west coast of India (Gurjar et al., 2021).
Masuda and Tsokamato (1996) found the development of pigment in the retina and rod formation corresponding to the light intensity and morphological evolution in respect to phototaxis and rheotaxis in the striped jack Pseudocaranx dentex. Higs and Fuiman (1996) found the relationship between light intensity and eye diameter for schooling in several species. They identified that there is a strong correlation between light intensity and eye diameter. Matthews (1988) studied and depicted that the variation in eye diameter can be analysed to the developmental changes in fishes in early stages corresponding to the light intensity in their habitat. It may reflect differences in turbidity of the habitat. Miyazaki et al., (2000) analyzed reduced penetration of solar radiation in the Bay of Bengal due to the large quantities of sediment influx. Hence, variation in light penetration and resultant light intensity in both seas is attributed to variation in eye diameter in fishes from India’s east and west coasts and associated adaptive developmental changes in early stages in the species. Imre et al., (2002) demonstrated that microhabitats differing in water velocity showed morphological variation in the caudal area in brook charr observed deeper caudal peduncle in fishes from turbulent waters. The water turbulence in the Arabian Sea is considerably lower than the Bay of Bengal. the variation in caudal peduncle depth in E. thoracata indicates the possibility of a phenotypic plasticity in response to different hydrological conditions in the Arabian Sea and Bay of Bengal.
Plasticity in overall body shape and natural habitat associated with different morphological divergence is well known in fishes, including intraspecific differences. Hence, it was concluded that physical characteristics of living habitats can determine biological evolutionary and ecological driving changes in the morphological characteristics of habitual fish populations. Polymorphisms involve diversifying behavioral, morphological or life-history traits in populations (Smith and Skulason, 1996). Such polymorphisms are more common in vertebrate populations than initially thought (Robinson and Wilson, 1994; Wimberger,1994; Skulason and Smith,1995). Thompson (1991) analyzed that phenotypic plasticity is the genotype ability to respond to alternative environmental conditions to produce a difference in phenotypes. The study of morphometric parameters of E. thoaracata clearly showed the variation of fishes from Arabian Sea and Bay of Bengal, though in a small magnitude, but surely enough to be considered as subpopulations which suggests the need for different type of strategies to manage the resources. Morphometric analyses have been used as a robust tool for discriminating biological groups (De La Cruz-Agüero et al., 2004). The Principal component analysis (PCA) showed significant variation between the Bay of Bengal and Arabian sea populations. The PCA of meristic traits depicted the separation of Mumbai population. The meristic characteristics were responsible for the differentiation of the Mumbai population. The results obtained by the two methods, morphometric and the meristic analyses, were correlated and conformed.
This biometric analysis of E. thoracata from the Indian coast showed a significant difference between the stock of the west coast and east coast. This studies can be beneficial and could be extended further on delineating the populations from all the geographical locations along the Indian coast.
The authors are grateful to Director, ICAR-CIFE, Mumbai, for providing the necessary facilities during the study period.

  1. Abdussamad, E.M., Mini, K.G.R., Gireesh, R., Prakasan, D., Retheesh, T.B., Pratibha, R., Gopalakrishnan, A. (2018). Systematics, fishery and biology of white sardine Escualosa thoracata (Valenciennes, 1847) exploited off Kerela, south-west coast of India. Indian Journal of Fisheries. 65(1): 26-31.

  2. Beg, G.A., Friendland, K.D. and Pearce, J.B. (1999). Stock identification and its role in stock assessment and fisheries management: an overview. Fisheries Research. 43: 1-8.

  3. De La Cruz-Aguero, J., Garcia-Rodriguez, F.J. (2004). Morphometric stock structure of the Pacific sardine Sardinops sagax (Jenyns, 1842) off Baja California, Mexico. In:  Morphometrics: Application in Biology and Paleontology, [Eleva, A.M. (Ed.)], Springer Verlag, New York, NY, PP. 115-124.

  4. Dwivedi, A.K., Dubey, V.K., (2013). Retracted article: Advancements in morphometric differentiation: a review on stock identification among populations. Review in Fish Biologyy Fisheries. 23: 23-39.

  5. Gurjar, U.R., Takar, S., Milind, S.S., Ravindra, A.P., Vivek, H.N., et al. (2021). Preliminary observation on the sustainability of white sardine, Escualosa thoracata (Valenciennes, 1847) exploited from the central west coast of India. Journal of applied and basic zoology. Pp. 82: 20.

  6. Higgs, D.M. and Fuiman, L.A. (1996). Light intensity and schooling behaviour in larval gulf menhaden. Journal Fisheries Biological. 48: 979-991. 

  7. Ihseen, P.E. Casselman, H.E., McGlade, J.M., Layne, J.M.N.R. and Utter, E.M. (1981). Stock identification materials and methods. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquaculture Science. 8: 1838-1855.

  8. Imre, I., McLaughlin, R.L. and Noakes, D.L.G. (2002). Phenotypic plasticity in brook charr: changes in caudal fin induced by water flow. Journal of Fisheries Biology. 61: 1171.

  9. Kumar, S.P., Maraleedharan, P.M., Prasad, T.G., Gauns, M., Ramaiah, N., De Sousa, S.N., Sardessai, S. and Madhupratap, M. (2002). Why is Bay of Bengal less productive during summer monsoon compared to the Arabian sea? Geophysical. Research. Letters. 29(24): 22-35.

  10. Kumar, S.P. Narvekar, J., Nuncio, M., Gauns, M. and Sardesai, S. (2009). What Drives the Biological Productivity of the Northen Indian Ocean? In: Indian Ocean Biogeochemical Processes and Ecological Variability. [Wiggert, J.D., Hood, R.R., Naqvi, S.W.A., Brink, K.H. and Smith, S.L. (Eds)], American Geophysical Union. pp. 33-56.

  11. Masuda, R. and Tsokamoto, K. (1996). Morphological development in relation to phototaxix and rheotaxix in the striped jack Pseudocaranx dentex, Marine and freshwater Behavioural Physiology. 28(1 and 2): 75-90.

  12. Matthews, W.J. (1988). Morphology, habitat use and life history, In: Patterns in freshwater fish ecology. Chapman and Hall, New York, 756 pp.

  13. Meyer, A. (1987). Phenotypic plasticity and heterochrony in Cichlasoma managuense (Pisces, Cichlidae) and their implication for speciation in chichlid fishes. Evolution. 41: 1357-1369.

  14. Miyazaki, T., Shiozawa, S., Kogane, T., Masuda, R., Maruyama, K. and Tsokamoto, K. (2000). Developmental changes of the light intensity threshold for school formation in the striped jack Pseudocaranx dentex. Marine Ecology Progress Series. 192: 267-275.

  15. Murta, A.G., (2000). Morphological variation of horse mackerel (Trachurus trachurus) in the Iberian and North African Atlantic: implication for stock identification. ICES Journal Marine Science. 57(4): 240-1248.

  16. Nair, R.V. and Chidambaram, K. (1951). A review of Indian oil sardine. Proceedings National Academy of Science. India. 17(1): 71-85.

  17. Prajapat, P.S. (2015). A study on biology of white sardine, Escualosa thoracata (Valenciennes, 1847) along Goa coast of India, M.F.Sc. dissertation, ICAR- C.I.F.E. (Deemed University). pp. 85.

  18. Rahangdale, S., Chakraborty, S.K., Jaiswar, A.K., Shenoy, L., Raje, S.G. (2016). Preliminary study on growth and mortality of Escualosa thoracata (Valenciennes, 1847) from Mumbai waters. Indian Journal of Marine Sciences. 45(2): 290-295.

  19. Raje, S.G. Deshmukh, V.D. and Thakurdas (1994). Fishery and biology of white sardine, Escualosa thoracata (Valenciennes, 1847) at Versova, Bombay. Journal of the Indian Fisheries Association. 24: 51-62.

  20. Robinson, B.W. and Wilson, D.S. (1994). Character release and displacement in fishes: A neglected literature. American Naturalists. 144: 596-627.

  21. Skulason, S. and Smith, T.B. (1995). Resource polymorphism in vertebrates. Trends in Ecology and Evolution. 10: 366-370.

  22. Smith, T.B. and Skulason, S. (1996). Evolutionary significance of resource polymorphisms in fishes, amphibians and birds. Annual Review of Ecology Evolution and systematics. 27: 111-133.

  23. SAS Institute. (2000) SAS/STAT. User’s Guide, Version 9.1, 4th edn., Vol. 1. SAS Institute, Cary, NC, 943 pp.

  24. Silva, A. (2003). Morphometric variation among sardine (Sardina pilchardus) populations from the north eastern Atlanttic and the western Mediterranean. ICES Journal Marine Science. 60(6): 1352-1360.

  25. Stearns, S.C. (1983). A natural experiment in life- history evolution: field data on the introduction of mosquitofish (Gambusia affinis) to Hawaii. Evolution. 37: 601-617.

  26. Thompson, J.D. (1991). Phenotypic plasticity as a component of evolutionary change. Trends in Ecology Evolution. 6: 246-249. 

  27. Wimberger, P.H. (1994). Trophic Polymorphisms, Plasticity and Speciation in Vertebrates. In: Theory and application in fish feeding ecology. [Stouder, D.J. Fresh, K.L. and Feller, R.J. (Eds.)] University of South Carolina Press, Columbia, pp 19-43.

Editorial Board

View all (0)