Effect of vitamin E and Se supplementation on plasma level of heavy metals and micro minerals in buffalo
Blood samples were collected from two different buffalo farms, analyzed for heavy metals using inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometer. Buffaloes being kept in non exposed area were found to have lower heavy metal levels. The concentration of Cr, Cd, Ni, Pb, As was found to be 0.0204±0.001, 0.028±0.0009, 0.0076±0.0007, 0.11±0.0091, 0.04±0.0063 ppm respectively (Fig 1a). However, samples collected from highly exposed Buddha Nallha region were found to have elevated heavy metals. The concentration of Cr, Cd, Ni, Pb, As was found to be 0.7575±0.19, 0.0555±0.031, 0.22±0.04, 0.593±0.31, 0.5865±0.02 ppm respectively (Fig 1a). Animals were divided into control (non-exposed) and exposed groups. The latter group was supplemented with Vitamin E and Se @20ml/day for 30 days. Blood was collected on 0
th, 15
th and 30
th day post supplementation from exposed group (n=10) and control group (n=10) on 0
th day, result were compared by independent t-test using SPSS (Fig 1a, 1b).
After supplementation of Vitamin E and Se, heavy metals such as lead (2.817±0.756 ppm), chromium (1.1865±0.4536 ppm) and cadmium (0.075± 0.015 ppm) were found to be gradually increasing even after 30
th day of supplementation (Fig 1a). Among the heavy metals studied post treatment, few of them showed considerable variation. Nickel (ppm) was found to be decreased significantly as compared to its initial level prior to treatment at 0
th day (0.219±0.044) which decreased significantly (p<0.05) after 30
th day supplementation (0.111±0.018). There wae non significant difference was observed in arsenic level after 30
th day of supplementation (Fig 1a), however, the levles of arsenic showed increasing trend. Prior to the treatment, the levels of micro minerals (Zn, Cu, Co, Fe) in control group were observed significantly lower as compared to exposed group. Exposed group also found with sub normal levels (ppm) of micro minerals
viz. Zn (3.8415±0.9759), Cu (1.1355±0.1374), Co (0.033±0.0037) which were found lowered than permissible limit (Fig 1a) but Fe (81.1005±9.4165) was reported to be in normal range (Fig 1b). It was found that, the levels of micro minerals (Zn, Cu and Co) remained sub normal (except iron), lowered than the permissible limit in blood even after 30 day of supplementation of Vitamin E and Se @ 20 ml/day.
Previous studies have reported that heavy metal concentrations were very high in agricultural soil, fodder and water in Punjab, as a result of that these heavy metals
via the food chain were recorded in blood of buffalo and other ruminants.
(Dhaliwal et al., 2016; Dash et al., 2016; Yeotikar et al., 2018). Several other studies in animals revealed that decrease in micro-minerals could ensue due to increase in heavy metal concentrations. One of the study conducted on pigs reported that dietary arsenic fed to the crossbred pigs resulted in decreased (p<0.05) serum Fe concentration but plasma Cu levels remained unaffected
(Wang et al., 2006). Roy et al., (2009) reported non-significant decrease in blood Cu level in Arsenic (As) exposed goats (2 mg sodium arsenite/kg BW
i.e. equivalent to 38 ppm). Dietary As caused a marked accumulation of Cu in the kidney of rats (
Shiguang and Beynen 2000) and a reduction of Cu concentrations in the liver (
Uthus 2001), plasma and blood cells
(Elsenhans et al., 1987; Hunder et al., 1999). Thompson et al., (1991) reported that excess As might be attributed to direct toxic effect and secondary deficiency of other trace elements like Zn, Cu, Mn to precipitate indirect toxicity. Contrary to the present study,
Roy et al., (2009) reported non-significant increase of plasma Zn level in As exposed goats. Their report suggested that the essential elements might have contributed to the protection of animals from the effects of heavy metal exposure, while their deficiency may aggravate toxicity.
Effect of vitamin E and Se supplementation on oxidative stress markers
A non-significant difference was observed in MDA level in exposed group (0
th day) when compared to that of control group and significant decrease (p<0.05) in lipid peroxidation (nmol/mg Hb) was observed in exposed group after 15 days (2.139±0.1701) of supplementation and increased non-significantly after 30 days (2.5722±0.4844) of supplementation yet lower than the unsupplemented control group (Fig 2a). Decrease in MDA level significantly (p<0.05) on 15
th day of supplementation might be protective effect of Vitamin E and Se from heavy metal stress. Non-significant increase of MDA on 30
th day might be due to persistence of heavy metals in the system, which led to the production of free radicals and consequently lipid peroxidation. Study conducted on rats revealed that, feeding of mercuric chloride lead to increase in lung MDA but when supplemented with vitamin E plus mercuric chloride significant decrease in MDA was reported
(Celikoglu et al., 2015).
Activity of antioxidant enzymes in unexposed control and heavy metal exposed buffaloes was noted before beginning of the supplementation trial. SOD, CAT, GPx on 0 day in control group was found to be 2.2792±0.1755, 0.0136±0.0012, 4.0662±0.122 U/mg and in exposed group was 2.763±0.5014, 0.1857±0.046 and 1.610597±0.205 U/mg (Fig 2b-2c) respectively. It was observed that SOD was elevated as compared to control but non-significant on 0
th, 15
th and 30
th day of supplementation with Vitamin E and Se in contrary GPx and CAT were significantly high as compared to control (Fig 2b-2c).
Reduced glutathione level on 0
th day in control and heavy metal exposed group was 2.6±0.017 and 4.431±1.0687 µg/ml respectively. It was found that after Vitamin E and Se supplementation the blood glutathione level increased significantly (p<0.05) after 30
th day (9.7338±0.5486 µg/ml) (Fig 2d).
Non-enzymatic antioxidant vitamins E and C were estimated to monitored post treatment effects. Vitamin E level (Fig 3) was 9.7±0.0046 mg/dl on 30
th day in exposed group post supplementation which was found to be significantly (p<0.05) higher as compared with control (3.7±0.0002 mg/dl). Plasma levels of Vitamin C was found significantly higher (p<0.05) prior to supplementation on 0
th day in exposed group but non-significant increase was observed on 30
th day after oral supplementation of Vitamin E and Se (Fig 2e).
Antioxidant enzymes has been considered to be the first line of cellular defense against oxidative damage.
Nandi et al., (2005) reported the non-significant changes (P>0.05) in blood SOD and CAT activity in rats fed with as (10ppm) which was comparable with our studies. Some authors have been reported non-significant (P>0.05) decrease of SOD and CAT activity in goat kids fed with arsenic and arsenic with vitamin E for 90 days
(Patel et al., 2009; Vaswani et al., 2010). Flora (1999) and
Ramanathan et al., (2002) recorded significant increase (p<0.05) in SOD and CAT activity in brain tissue in As with a-tocopherol treated group when compared to exclusively As exposed rats which was found to be in agreement with the present study.
Nandi et al., (2008) reported that the supplementation of ascorbic acid (an antioxidant) for 8 weeks restored blood SOD and CAT activities towards normalcy in As exposed rats, which is in accordance with our findings. Studies conducted on mice has revealed that there was significantly decrease in CAT, GSH-Px activities and GSH in nickel treatment. So when supplemented with vitamin E with or without vitamin c showed significant decrease in toxic effect and increase in antioxidant status
(Dahdouh et al., 2016).
Our findings indicated that, gradual increase in heavy metals in exposed buffaloes even though they were supplemented with Vitamin E and Se @ 20ml/day for 30 days. Drastic alterations in the antioxidant enzyme activity status was not noticed. These enzymes remained in uniform range that could be due to the effect of supplementation. In contrast to our finding,
Karaboduk et al., 2015 reported that mercuric chloride exposure in mice led to decreased SOD, catalase, GPx activity as compared to control. But the reversal in the activity had been noticed after treatment with Vitamin E and Se. A significant rise in GPx, catalase, SOD and decreased in MDA were reported post treatment with Vitamin E and Se.
Layachi and Kechrid (2012) have found that cadmium induced rats showed reduction in antioxidant activity which was increased by ameliorative effect of vitamin E and C.
Similar study done by
Al-Attar (2010) on mice revealed that when treated with vitamin E increased activity of GSH and SOD was observed, which was comparable to our present findings. Balanced activity in SOD, CAT, GPx and increase in GSH level after vitamin E supplementation might be due to its role in scavenging free radicals
i.e. superoxide, hydroxyl radicals, peroxyl and alkoxyl radicals resulted from damage caused by heavy metals, before they attack membrane lipids leading to removal of cell damaging free radicals.
Effect of vitamin E and Se supplementation on biochemical profile
The plasma glucose, cholesterol, triglycerides, total protein, albumin, urea and creatinine in control animals were found to be 50.878±0.3813, 96.422±0.0961, 11.47±0.0494, 7.314±0.1715, 2.904±0.0676, 13.432±0.036 and 0.76±0.051 mg/dl respectively (Fig 3a-c). The activity of non-antioxidant enzymes, AST (81.442±0.4547 U/L), ALT (23.372±0.1589 U/L), ALP (88.578±0.1605 U/L), LDH (755.2±38.9479 U/L) and CK (6.64±0.0707 U/L) was found to be in normal range (Fig 3d-e).
Biochemical parameters in the heavy metal exposed group were found to be elevated before supplementation of vitamin E and Se. On day 0 level of glucose, total cholesterol, triglycerides was 63.239±1.9748, 109.59±4.0203 and 21.384± 2.6023 mg/dl respectively (Fig 3a). After supplementation with Vitamin E and Se @20ml/day to heavy metal exposed group initial analysis of biochemical profile revealed significantly higher level of plasma blood glucose, total cholesterol, triglycerides. Total protein (9.356±0.2708 g/dl) and albumin (3.766±0.1767 g/dl) was also found to be significantly high on day 0 (Fig 3b). Activity of liver enzyme like AST (185.543±11.972 U/L), ALT (78.647±7.45 U/L) and ALP (111.505±4.1775 U/L) was found to be increased when compared with control or non-exposed group (Fig 3e). Our findings have indicated that heavy metals exposed group supplemented with Vitamin E and Se @20ml/day resulted in significant decrease in Glucose, total cholesterol and triglycerides as compared to the initial day 0th status. Supplementation of Vitamin E and Se also affected (p<0.05) the activity of ALT, AST, LDH, albumin, urea, and creatinine. Total protein concentration was found to be decreased (p<0.05) after 30
th day of supplementation (Fig 3b). Studies conducted on mice has revealed that serum glucose, total protein, ALT, AST and ALP was significantly increased in nickel treated mice
(Dahdouh et al., 2016) which was in agreement with our present findings.
Layachi and Kechrid (2012) have reported oxidative liver injury in rats exposed to cadmium characterized by increased serum glucose, ALT and ALP activities. Similar studies have been conducted by
Das et al., (2012), goat supplemented with arsenic (As) reported significant increased (p<0.05) AST and ALT activities, vitamin E supplementation at higher doses showed a protective effect (p<0.05). Plasma total protein was found to be decreased (p<0.05) but creatinine increased periodically in all As supplemented groups.
Effect of vitamin E and Se supplementation on expression study of metallothionein (MT-2)
Previous studies have been indicated the role of metal binding protein, metallothionein (MT) in heavy metal metabolism. The alternations in expression pattern of MTs could be a marker in determining heavy metal exposure in animals. Keeping this in view the abundance in animals, MT-2 expression was analyzed in blood cells. MT-2 expression was studied in control and heavy metal exposed buffaloes. Exposed buffaloes, which were supplemented with vitamin E and Se, corresponding expression of MT-2, was monitored during supplementation and after completion of the trial. The fold change expression of MT-2 after supplementation was 5.507±0.047 on 0th and 7.8349±1.12 on 30th day which was found to be significantly (p<0.05) high as compared to control (Fig 4). The concentration of few of the heavy metals fluctuated during the supplementation period. It was observed that some of the heavy metals decreased on 15
th day after supplementation that resulted in non-significant decrease in MT-2 fold expression but at the end of trial after 30th day of supplementation level of heavy metals were also increased. As vitamin E and Se was supplemented level of heavy metal remained unabated and despite supplementation up-regulation of MT-2 gene expression was reported.
Studies conducted on mice revealed that arsenic exposure resulted in up-regulation of MT-2 gene expression which could be due to decrease in micro-minerals and increase in heavy metal concentration
(Kreppel et al., 1993). No studies are available in buffaloes that could correlate metallothionein expression pattern with heavy metals. We observed proportionate elevation in MT-2 expression despite of feeding Vitamin E and Se supplementation, which could imply that feeding vitamin E and Se might not be affecting the cellular accumulation of heavy metals. Studies conducted on Grass Carp (fish) observed that administration with Cadmium (Cd) resulted in liver toxicity, which was expressed as increase in malondialdehyde (MDA) percentage of hepatocyte apoptosis and apoptosis-related gene mRNA transcript expression. Treatment with vitamin E and MT lead to protection against Cd-induced hepatotoxicity by decreasing Cd contents, lipid peroxidation, and histological damage and reducing the percentage of hepatocyte apoptosis by regulating related mRNA transcript expression. Therefore, it was found that Vitamin E and MT treatments could moderate/lessen Cd-induced hepatotoxicity through their antioxidative and antiapoptotic effects. MT had more powerful effect than vitamin E.
(Duan et al., 2018).