Disease history and symptoms
The clinical signs and disease history were indicative of possible tick-born infection, however, these observed signs were mild, varied and overlapping with TBDs. It is attributed to the low severity of parasitemia and milder pathogenicity (Zwart, 1985). The major clinical signs or management practices associated with different pathogens of TBDs are enlisted in Table 2. The case fatality rate was highest (20.0%) in buffaloes with infection of only
Theileria spp. compared to co-infected (7.69%) buffaloes. No deaths were recorded in buffaloes infected with
Anaplasma marginale,
Babesia spp. and negative buffaloes. Co-infection of pathogens resulted in a higher proportion of animals showing key symptoms of TBDs recorded under the study. Provision for wallowing had lesser haemo-parasitic infected buffaloes but no proportional effect on the type of pathogens in TBDs infected buffaloes. Red urine due to hemoglobinuria was only observed in buffaloes found infected with
Babesia spp. Redwater (hemoglobinuria) and associated symptoms of high fever, anorexia, anemia, decreased milk production and physiological state were highly suggestive of babesiosis which is in concurrence with published reports
(Singla et al., 2002; Rani et al., 2010). However, without hemoglobinuria babesiosis is difficult to differentiate from other TBDs infection based on clinical symptoms and epidemiology. Peripheral lymph node enlargement was associated with
Theileria infection (40.00%) or co-infected (7.69%). Corneal opacity and conjunctivitis were also observed in few buffaloes found infected with
Theileria spp., or co-infected with
A. marginale. Anaplasmosis and theileriosis are also difficult to differentiate clinically in adult buffaloes, though superficial lymph node is suggestive of the early stage of
Theileria spp. infection. TBDs are economically important diseases of buffaloes, though the occurrence reported is comparatively lesser than crossbred cattle. Ticks collected from buffaloes were grossly identified based on key features belonged to different species of the
Ixodidae family namely
Hyalomma spp., responsible for the transmission of
Theileria spp. and
Rhipicephalus spp. responsible for the transmission of
Babesia spp.,
Theileria spp. and
A marginale in the region (Jithendran, 1997). Disease history and clinical findings and association of tick’s vectors in the surrounding as well as suspected buffaloes were indicative of tick-borne diseases but are often overlapping and diverse (Ghosh and Nagar, 2014). The use of acaricidal by farmers also did not have a proportional effect on TBDs positive or negative animals. Acaricidal use by farmers is sometimes rendered ineffective due to the availability of infected vectors in the surroundings and premises shared with other animals. Response to empirical treatment with oxytetracycline had a beneficial symptomatic effect in both
Anaplasma and
Theileria infections and their co-infection. The oxytetracycline LA is reported useful against
Anaplasma and
Theileria infection (Bansal and Sharma, 1986; Cranwell, 1990;
Yousef et al., 2020). Significant (P<0.05) positive coefficients was observed for increased body temperature and lacrimation in TBDs buffaloes using probit regression (Table 3). These symptoms may help in the screening and selection of animals for such conditions.
Prevalence and spectrum of TBDs by Giemsa stained microscopy
The buffaloes had a high prevalence (47.66%) of parasites causing TBDs including
Theileria spp.,
A. margin,e and
Babesia spp. (Fig 1). The high prevalence of TBDs positive buffaloes in the region is attributed to the selection of suspected buffaloes and the availability of vector in the environment. However, the majority of these infected buffaloes (86.28%) had low severity of infection. Amongst the buffaloes found positive for infection of hemo-parasites, most of them (56.52%) had co-infection of parasites or mixed infection (Table 4). It may be associated with multiple genus of tick infestation associated with one or more different parasite. Earlier reports of mixed infection in buffaloes of Egypt associated with
Anaplasma,
Babesia and
Theileria infection supports our findings
(Nagwa et al., 2016; Amira et al., 2020). The most prevalent hemo-parasite infection in buffaloes was
A. marginale followed by
Theileria spp. and
Babesia spp. (Table 4). The present findings of the prevalence of only
Theileria spp., infection (4.67%) is less, while associated with other TBDs (26.17%) is high than the earlier reports of the prevalence of theileriosis 9.33% from suspected buffaloes of Patna (Kala and Deo, 2018). This difference may be due to the geographical restriction of sampling and considering only one pathogen of TBDs. In mixed infection of buffaloes, the most prevalent concurrent pathogens identified were
A. marginale and
Theileria spp. (43.14%) infection. We did not observe any buffalo infected
Theileria spp. infection. TBDs are economically important diseases of buffaloes, though the occurrence reported is comparatively lesser than crossbred cattle. Ticks collected from buffaloes were grossly identified based on key features belonged to different species of the
Ixodidae family namely
Hyalomma spp., responsible for the transmission of
Theileria spp. and
Rhipicephalus spp. responsible for the transmission of
Babesia spp.,
Theileria spp. and
A marginale in the region (Jithendran, 1997). Disease history and clinical findings and association of tick’s vectors in the surrounding as well as suspected buffaloes were indicative of tick-borne diseases but are often overlapping and diverse (Ghosh and Nagar, 2014). The use of acaricidal by farmers also did not have a proportional effect on TBDs positive or negative animals. Acaricidal use by farmers is sometimes rendered ineffective due to the availability of infected vectors in the surroundings and premises shared with other animals. Response to empirical treatment with oxytetracycline had a beneficial symptomatic effect in both
Anaplasma and
Theileria infections and their co-infection. The oxytetracycline LA is reported useful against
Anaplasma and
Theileria infection (Bansal and Sharma, 1986; Cranwell, 1990;
Yousef et al., 2020). Significant (P<0.05) positive coefficients was observed for increased body temperature and lacrimation in TBDs buffaloes using probit regression (Table 3). These symptoms may help in the screening and selection of animals for such conditions.
Prevalence and spectrum of TBDs by Giemsa stained microscopy
The buffaloes had a high prevalence (47.66%) of parasites causing TBDs including
Theileria spp.,
A. marginale and
Babesia spp. (Fig 1). The high prevalence of TBDs positive buffaloes in the region is attributed to the selection of suspected buffaloes and the availability of vector in the environment. However, the majority of these infected buffaloes (86.28%) had low severity of infection. Amongst the buffaloes found positive for infection of hemo-parasites, most of them (56.52%) had co-infection of parasites or mixed infection (Table 4). It may be associated with multiple genus of tick infestation associated with one or more different parasite. Earlier reports of mixed infection in buffaloes of Egypt associated with
Anaplasma,
Babesia and
Theileria infection supports our findings
(Nagwa et al., 2016; Amira et al., 2020). The most prevalent hemo-parasite infection in buffaloes was
A. marginale followed by
Theileria spp. and
Babesia spp. (Table 4). The present findings of the prevalence of only
Theileria spp., infection (4.67%) is less, while associated with other TBDs (26.17%) is high than the earlier reports of the prevalence of theileriosis 9.33% from suspected buffaloes of Patna (Kala and Deo, 2018). This difference may be due to the geographical restriction of sampling and considering only one pathogen of TBDs. In mixed infection of buffaloes, the most prevalent concurrent pathogens identified were
A. marginale and
Theileria spp. (43.14%) infection. We did not observe any buffalo infected reported worldwide which is in concurrence with our observations
(AL-Hosary, et al., 2015; Esmaeilnejad et al., 2020). Similarly, in buffaloes, oxidative stress and parasitic burden-dependent oxidative damages to erythrocytes by
T. annulata infection in buffaloes have been reported
(Molayi-Jabdaragi et al., 2020). Logistic regression between oxidant MDA and antioxidant CAT in TBDs infected buffaloes showed significant positive (0.004±0.002) and negative (-2.449± 1.150) coefficients, respectively (Table 6). This indicates that an increase in MDA and a decrease in CAT level can be a useful indicator for screening TBDs infected buffaloes.
The biochemical response during the infection was measured in terms of ALT, AST, total protein and cortisol concentration in buffaloes (Table 5). The concentration of ALT increased significantly in group I buffaloes and only non-significantly higher in group II buffaloes compared to group III buffaloes. The concentration of AST was also significantly higher in group I and II compared to group III buffaloes. The total serum protein was significantly reduced in both group I and II buffaloes compared to group III buffaloes. The biochemical response in TBDs infected buffaloes was indicative of damage to the tissues by the parasitic invasion particularly of liver, muscle, RBCs. This damage brought hypoxic changes in organs. It was reflected by an increase concentration of liver and tissue enzymes (ALT, AST) and a decrease in total serum protein
(Singh et al., 2001; Hasanpour et al., 2008). A similar observation in cattle infected with
A marginale (Ganguly et al., 2018), with
T. annulata (Omer et al., 2003) and with
B. bigemina (Ganguly et al., 2017) has been reported. The level of Hb was lower in all the groups of buffaloes. However, in group I buffaloes, the concentration of Hb were significantly lower compared to other groups. Anemia due to low haemoglobin level in most of the buffaloes sampled might be due to endemic infections of TBDs and sample selection criteria. The cortisol level was significantly lower in group I buffaloes compared to both group II and III buffaloes which may be indicative of hormonal dysfunction of adrenal gland favouring the dissemination of parasite
(Forsyth et al., 1999). This finding corroborates with previous reports of decreased cortisol level in
T. annulata infected cattle
(Sangwan et al., 2002). A significant logistic regression coefficient was observed only for cortisol (0.148±0.062) and total serum protein (-1.368 ±0.066) and TBDs infected buffaloes and may be useful as prognostic and diagnostic markers (Table 6).
Acute-phase response and cytokines
Acute-phase response is a complex systemic early defence system activated by infection and inflammation mediated by pro-inflammatory cytokines with the release of acute-phase protein
(Glass et al., 2003). These proteins are involved in controlling inflammation against a wide range of pathogens and often the severity of infection is quantified based on their level. Acute-phase response was measured in terms of the serum SAA in haemo-parasite negative and positive buffaloes and especially in
Theileria spp. infected buffaloes. The concentration (mg/L) of SAA was non-significantly different between group II buffaloes (18.21±2.72) and group III buffaloes (12.71±1.83). However, SAA was significantly (P<0.01) higher in group I buffaloes infected with
Theileria spp. (47.07±5.66) versus other buffaloes in group II and III (Fig 2A). Our observations are in agreement with the earlier findings of increase acute phase response proteins in
T. annulata infected water buffaloes (El-Deeb and Iacob, 2012). Several inflammatory cytokines, including TNF-alpha, play important role in disease progression. TNF family along with IL-1 and IL-6 are considered important inducers of acute phase response in the liver (Baumann and Gauldie, 1994). The TNF-alpha was highest (18.73±1.43 ng/L) in
Theileria spp. infected buffaloes of group I followed by group II (13.08±0.87 ng/L) and least in group III buffaloes (4.86±0.76 ng/L) and these values varied significantly (P£0.01) with each other (Fig 2B). In our study, a higher concentration of TNF alpha in TBDs positive and more in
T. annulata infected buffaloes also suggest a possible mechanism for acute phase response and subsequent elevation in the serum SAA level in the circulation. However, logistic regression analysis showed a non-significant coefficient between SAA, TNF alpha and TBDs infected buffaloes.
Therapeutic management
The animal welfare ethic is to provide treatment for ailing animals apart from research. The overall response of oxytetracycline long-acting along with antipyretic was positive in 38.31 per cent buffaloes sampled, on day two of treatment. There was an improvement in appetite and rectal temperature. The response of initial treatment with oxytetracycline long-acting and antipyretic is attributed to its known efficacy against
A. marginale (Swift and Thomas, 1983;
Sarli et al., 2020) and the response rate was less as they were infected with other non-responsive pathogens. The overall case-fatality rate was 5.88% in TBDs infected buffaloes with the highest (20.00%) recorded in buffaloes infected with
Theileria spp. The deaths recorded were within 48 hours of blood sampling. The majority (80.0%) of the
Theileria spp. positive buffaloes responded within 7 days of treatment administered module-I and IV of therapeutic management. The majority of buffaloes (95.50%) co-infected with
Theileria spp. and
A. marginale given a combination of module-I, II and IV responded favourably after 10 days of treatment and the case fatality rate was 4.50% observed within 7 days of treatment. Similar to our findings, observation of mortality in adult cattle and calf infected with TBDs even after specific treatment has been reported by
Kohli et al., (2014). The possible reasons for mortality are anemia, respiratory distress, persistent inappetence, anoxia, disseminated intravenous coagulopathy and toxemia
(Nazifi et al., 2008; Godara et al., 2010; Underwood et al., 2015; Boes and Durham, 2017). All other TBDs infected buffaloes responded favourably with respective module combination within 7 days of treatment. Imidocarb is highly effective against
A. maginale infection has been previously reported
(Ashuma et al., 2013). Similar to our regimen, McHardy and Simpson (1974) have reported the efficacy of Imidocarb dipropionate @ 3 mg/kg capable of rapidly curing
A. marginale by single subcutaneous injction. Supportive therapy by multivitamins, hematinic and anti-oxidants though cannot decrease the level of parasitemia yet influence recovery by improving hematocrit values
(Nayak et al., 2018). However,
Altug et al., (2014) reported that vitamin B is the most efficient supportive therapy for the treatment of
T. annulata infection in cattle. Positive response after 7 days of treatment has been reported similar to our findings
(Ganga et al., 2010; Altug et al., 2014). However, milk yield could not be restored in these buffaloes even after 15 days post-treatment. This may be attributed to slow response in optimizing the compromised haemato-biochemical profile after specific treatment controlling parasitemia. Slow response in the improvement of milk production in
T. annulata infected cattle treated with buvarvaqunone has been reported
(Ayadi et al., 2016). Tick control was achieved in all the buffaloes after 3 consecutive application of module-V at weekly intervals. This indicates ticks were sensitive to common acaricidal drugs used by the farmers and application of the same simultaneously to the environment and shared animals.