A total of 100 faecal samples were collected from healthy as well as diarrhoeic sheep and goats, from farms in and around Ludhiana, Punjab. These samples were subjected to bacterial isolation, followed by identification of isolates, culture sensitivity test and PCR.
On BHI, colonies were spherical, creamy mucoid in nature; on MLA lactose fermenting pink colour colonies were present and on EMB, colonies showed green metallic sheen. Pink colour coccobacilli were seen in Gram’s staining and the
E. coli cultures were confirmed biochemicaly
viz. Catalase test (+ve) Oxidase (-ve) and IMViC test, [Indole (+ve), methyl red (+ve), Voges Proskauer (-ve) and citrate (-ve)]. A total of 40
E. coli isolates isolated from sheep and goats faecal samples were screened for antibiogram against 10 antibiotic agents. Majority of isolates were resistant to penicillins (100%). In goats, resistance to other antimicrobial agents in decreasing order was ampicillin (91.7%), gentamicin (37.5%) followed by amikacin (16.7%), ceftriaxone and tetracycline (12.5%), chloramphenicol, cotrimoxazole and ofloxacin (4.2%) and amoxicillin (0%). In sheep, resistance to antimicrobial agents in decreasing order was ampicillin (93.3%), tetracycline (68.8%), gentamicin (37.5%), amoxycillin, chloramphenicol, clotrimoxazole and ofloxacin (31.3%), ceftriaxone (18.8%) and amikacin (12.5%) (Fig 1). The details of each isolate and resistance percentage is given in the Table 2. We have carried out phenotypic and genotypic detection of antibiotic resistance and virulence genes in
E. coli, isolated from sheep and goat faecal samples. The colony characteristics of the isolated
E. coli in different media resemble the study observation of
Ali et al., (1998). All the
E. coli isolates were found to be positive for catalase, methyl-red positive and indole positive but negative for VP test, which supports the findings of
Beutin et al., (1993). And also the isolated
E. coli organisms fermented dextrose, maltose, lactose, sucrose and mannitol with the production of both acid and gas. Results of MR, Indole test of the
E. coli isolates were positive. In Gram’s staining, the morphology of the isolated bacteria exhibited pink, small rod shape, gram negative bacilli which was supported by several authors
Buxton and Fraser, (1977);
Freeman, (1985).
Antimicrobial agents play a crucial role in human and animal life around the world
Hudson et al., (2017). Moreover, overuse of antimicrobial agents in food-producing animals has always resulted in the development of antimicrobial-resistant bacteria and antibiotic-resistant genes in human and animal pathogens. β-Lactam antibiotics such as ampicillin, amikacin, cephalosporins can be the most effective therapeutic medicines for the treatment of bacterial infections as when combined show protection and high potency against gram-negative bacteria, such as members of enterobacteriaceae family, including
E. coli. Nevertheless, gentamicin, tetracycline, ampicillin, enrofloxacin, chloramphenicol and penicillin are highly prescribed by veterinarians. In our study we found that majority of
E. coli isolates were penicillin resistance. There is one similar study done by
Momtaz et al., (2013), they describe that majority of their
E. coli isolates isolated from meat samples of small and large ruminants were penicillin resistant and some were resistant to other antibiotic like tetracycline, streptomycin and gentamicin.
Molecular confirmation of
E.coli was carried out by PCR using primers as per
Riffon et al., (2001). A 232 bp amplification band was obtained for
E.coli isolates (Fig 2).
Detection of resistance genes and virulence genes
Molecular detection of antibiotic resistance genes was performed in all
E. coli isolates. Virulotyping was also done with
Stx1, Stx2 and
hlyA genes for all
E. coli isolates. Out of 40 isolates, 12 isolates were positive for
bla TEM gene, 19 for
tetA and 10 for
tetB gene (Fig 3, 4, 5). In a study conducted by
Colom et al., (2003), blaTEM was detected in 45 out of 51 amoxycillin-clavulinic acid resistant isolates. In another study,
blaTEM was found in 97% of ampicillin resistant strain of
E. coli (
Medina et al., 2011).
Aslam et al., (2009) also studied same gene in
E. coli isolates, they found that the majority of streptomycin-resistant
E. coli isolates (76%) were positive for the
strA and
strB genes together. The
bla(CMY)
, bla(TEM) and
bla(SHV) genes were found in 12%, 56% and 4%, of ampicillin-resistant
E. coli isolates respectively.
Boerlin et al., (2005) carried out studies on antimicrobial resistant and virulence genes of
E. coli isolates from swine in Ontorio and in that study they found 98% of
E. coli isolates were having
tet A gene.
Aslam et al., (2009) also studied same genes in
E. coli isolates and they foundthat about 50% of tetracycline-resistant
E. coli isolates were positive for
tet(A) (14%),
tet(B) (15%), or
tet(C) (21%) genes or both
tet(B) and
tet(C) genes together (3%). The occurrence of antibiotic resistance genes found in our study was not that much higher as compare to the above studies. This might be due to lower use of antimicrobial agents by the Punjab farmers or the local veterinarians prescribing less antibiotics to them, different geographic zone, their customs and even use of high quality animal nutrition.
In our study we detected
Stx1, Stx2 and
hlyA virulence genes from
E. coli isolates. Among that five isolates were found positive for the presence of
Stx1 gene, none of the isolates carried
Stx2 gene and five isolates were found to be positive for the presence of
hlyA gene (Fig 6,7). These results are in accordance with those of
Khan et al., (2002). They analysed 63 strains of
E. coli and by using PCR they detected virulence gene
Stx1 (36.5%),
Stx2 (19%) and
hlyA (45.5%).
Wani et al., (2004) investigated the presence or absence of shiga toxin producing
Escherichia coli (STEC) in avian species. They collected faecal samples from 500 chicken and 25 free flying pigeon and screened for the presence of
E. coli. Out of 525 samples processed, a total of 426 (chicken 401, pigeons 25)
E. coli strains were isolated. All isolates were subjected to multiplex polymerase chain reaction (mPCR) for the detection of
Stx1,
Stx2,
eaeA,
hlyA and
saa genes. None of the
E. coli strains studied showed the presence of
Stx1,
Stx2 or their variants and
saa genes. The strains of these harbouring
stx2 virulence genes have been implicated in human infections with haemolytic colitis and haemorrhagic uremic syndrome and strain carrying
stx1 may trigger diarrhoea in immunocompromised individuals
(Farrokh et al., 2013). Some of our
E. coli isolates from sheep and goats have two virulence genes, so these are more pathogenic. One of the similar study was done by
Jajarmi et al., (2017) and they also found pathogenic strains of
E. coli that harbour more than two virulence genes like
stx1,
stx2, hlyA and
eaeA. In our study, phenotypic and genotypic characters varies, this might be due to presence of some other genes related to that particular antibiotic, like instead of
blaTEM gene may be
blaSHV could be present or due to cross resitance and coresistance. The potential explanation for absence of virulence gene could be that the isolates might have lost the gene during subculture process
(Karch et al., 1992). Momtaz et al., (2013) also studied resistant genes like
blaSHV, tetA,
tetB etc. and virulence genes like
Stx1, Stx2, ehly etc. and they found that the incidence of
blaSHV was maximum while the incidences of
cmlA and
cat1 antibiotic resistance genes were minimum and virulence genes like
Stx1, Stx2,
eaeA and
ehly were prevalent in the STEC strains isolated from ruminants meat samples. Since some of the isolates were carrying more than two resistance genes and virulence genes, so they are considered as potentially pathogenic and absence of these genes in some isolates in our study should not be underestimated.