Leaf area index
The leaf area index (LAI) of maize plants, a crucial indicator of canopy development, varied significantly among treatments due to the application of different coated urea fertilizers. The LAI values increased steadily until the vege-tative (0.97) and tasselling (3.34) stages, indicating vigorous plant growth during these phases. However, a decline in LAI was observed at the harvest stage (2.38). Among the fertilized treatments, the highest mean LAI was recorded in the POCU (2.71) treatment, closely followed by the HACU (2.70) treatment. In contrast, the UCU (2.04) treatment exhibited the lowest mean LAI, indicating less vigorous growth compared to the other treatments (Table 2).
Specifically, at the vegetative stage, the UCU treatment showed the maximum LAI (1.12), which was comparable to the POCU (1.04) and HACU (1.08) treatments. Conversely, the ZCU treatment exhibited the minimum LAI (0.94) at this stage. At the tasselling stage, the HACU treatment displayed the highest LAI (4.35) which was at par with POCU treatment (4.16), indicating robust canopy development in these treatments. By the harvest stage, the POCU treatment showed the maximum LAI (2.91), which was on par with PSCU treatment (2.75). These results indicate that the POCU treatment promoted greater canopy development throughout the growth stages. In contrast, the UCU treatment exhibited the lowest LAI at both the tasselling (2.91) and harvest (2.10) stages, indicating less effective growth promotion compared to the other treatments (Fig 1).
Chlorophyll ‘a’ and ‘b’ and total chlorophyll content
The research revealed notable differences in chlorophyll content among maize plants treated with various coated urea fertilizers throughout different growth stages. Average total chlorophyll content increased steadily until the vegetative (1.57 mg mL
-1) and tasselling (1.81 mg mL
-1) stages, but decreased at the harvest stage (1.65 mg mL
-1) (Table 3). At vegetative stage, among the fertilized treatments, the PSCU treatment showed the highest chlorophyll ‘a’ content (1.41 mg mL
-1), was on par with HACU (1.37 mg mL
-1), POCU (1.34 mg mL-1), NOCU (1.33 mg mL
-1) and SCU (1.33 mg mL
-1) treatments, while the lowest was recorded in the UCU treatment (1.23 mg mL
-1). PSCU 14.6% and HACU 11.4% increased chlorophyll ‘a’ over uncoated urea. For chlorophyll ‘b’ content, the highest was found in the HACU treatment [0.38 mg mL
-1 (11.8% higher chlorophyll than UCU)], which was at par with PSCU treatment (0.36 mg mL
-1)], while the lowest was in the SCU treatment (0.29 mg mL
-1). The maximum total chlorophyll content was recorded in the PSCU treatment (1.77 mg mL
-1) which is 12.7% higher over UCU. This PSCU treatment was on par with POCU (1.67 mg mL
-1), HACU (1.75 mg mL
-1) and NOCU (1.65 mg mL
-1) treatments, while the minimum was in the UCU treatment (1.57 mg mL
-1).
At the tasselling stage, the highest chlorophyll ‘a’ content was in the POCU treatment (1.58 mg mL
-1), was on par with PSCU (1.49 mg mL
-1), HACU (1.52 mg mL
-1) and NOCU (1.48 mg mL
-1) treatments, with the lowest in the ZCU treatment (1.36 mg mL
-1). The maximum chlorophyll ‘b’ content was in the HACU treatment (0.51 mg mL
-1), which was on par with PSCU (0.47 mg mL
-1) and POCU (0.49 mg mL
-1) treatments, while the minimum was in the UCU treatment (0.36 mg mL
-1). The maximum total chlorophyll content was recorded in the POCU treatment (2.07 mg mL
-1), which was on par with HACU (2.03 mg mL
-1), PSCU (1.96 mg mL
-1) and NOCU (1.94 mg mL
-1) treatments, with the minimum in the UCU treatment (1.75 mg mL
-1).
At the harvest stage, the highest chlorophyll ‘a’ content was in the POCU treatment (1.48 mg mL
-1), which was on par with HACU (1.42 mg mL
-1) and NOCU (1.37 mg mL
-1) treatments, with the lowest in the UCU treatment (1.17 mg mL
-1). The maximum chlorophyll ‘b’ content was in the POCU treatment (0.50 mg mL
-1), was on par with HACU (0.47 mg mL-1) treatment, while the minimum was in the UCU treatment (0.31 mg mL
-1). The maximum total chlorophyll content was recorded in the POCU treatment (1.98 mg mL
-1), which was on par with HACU (1.89 mg mL
-1) treatment, with the minimum in the UCU treatment (1.48 mg mL
-1). Based on the results, the coated urea fertilizers had varying effects on chlorophyll content in maize plants across different growth stages. The POCU treatment consistently performed well, showing high chlorophyll ‘a’ and ‘b’ content as well as total chlorophyll content at various stages. The HACU treatment also showed promising results, especially in terms of chlorophyll ‘b’ content. The PSCU, NOCU and SCU treatments also performed relatively well in maintaining chlorophyll levels. Finally, POCU and HACU treatments appear to be the most effective coated urea fertilizers for enhancing chlorophyll content in maize plants, followed by PSCU, NOCU and SCU treatments (Fig 2).
Uncoated urea registered the highest Leaf Area Index (LAI) up to the vegetative stage due to its early dissolution. However, this early availability of urea might not have been sustained in subsequent stages of maize growth, leading to a reduction in LAI as the growth progressed. This reduction indicates a potential decline in photosynthetic activity. In contrast, coated urea fertilizers exhibited a lower LAI during the vegetative stage because their slow-release properties might have inhibited vegetative growth. This resulted in smaller leaves, shorter internodes and
ulti et al., 2012). However, the LAI steadily increased until the tasselling stage and then gradually decreased towards maturity.
Among the treatments, pine oleoresin coated urea (POCU) and humic acid-coated urea (HACU) were more effective in providing a steady supply of nitrogen during the post-silking stage. Their specific nutrient release patterns sustained a balanced nutrient supply, promoted higher LAI and supported better canopy development. This pattern can be attributed to the slow release of nitrogen, which supported maize growth even after the tasselling stage. According to
Ma et al., (2021), slow-release fertilizers not only enhanced leaf vitality and photosynthetic capacity but also delayed leaf senescence and increased nitrogen uptake after silking. As the crop absorbed sufficient nitrogen, this nutrient might have been redirected towards canopy expansion and grain filling.
The LAI and chlorophyll content in maize are closely related as they both reflected the physiological status and growth of plants. A higher LAI indicates a larger leaf canopy, which contributed to higher photosynthetic rates and chlorophyll production. Our study found that the POCU treatment had 15.4% higher chlorophyll content than the UCU treatment, commanded to higher nitrogen uptake and utilized the nitrogen properly for the chlorophyll synthesis. This result was in line with
Singh and Sharma (2020). Our study further demonstrated, compared to UCU, the addition of nitrogen through POCU significantly increased 6.4, 18.3 and 33.8% of chlorophyll ‘a’ and ‘b’ and total chlorophyll at the vegetative, tasselling and harvest stages, respectively (Fig 3). Consistent release of nitrogen from POCU were readily available at the photosynthesis site, promoting chlorophyll content ultimately led to yield development. This might be because of enhanced functional leaf area and delayed leaf senescence, facilitated by phytohormones promoting cell division and elongation due to continuous uptake of nitrogen from slow release fertilizers. Overall, the slow release N fertilizers produced significant leaf greenness level than UCU fertilizers. This finding was consistent with
Gil-Ortiz et al.et al., (2020) and
Ashraf et al., (2019).
Outperformed treatments such as POCU and HACU treatments in terms of LAI and chlorophyll enrichment due to a great compatibility between coating material and urea. POCU provided a barrier for rapid release and the sustained release of nitrogen synchronized with crop growth stages. Additionally, pine oleoresin containing urease inhibitor facilitating the slow transformation of nitrogen oxidation process of NH
4+-N to NO
3--N. Hence, prolonged nitrogen availability could be achieved in the soil by restricting different losses. A concomitant result was observed from
Balaganesh et al., (2021). Similarly, HACU started lower, consistently increased LAI and chlorophyll content, surpassing uncoated urea possibly due to gradual nutrient release and humic acid’s growth-promoting effects. In addition, humic acid functional groups such as phenolic and carboxylic groups inhibit urease activity to reduce the rate of urea hydrolysis. This keeps the soil NH
4+-N content at a low level, which reduces the risk of NH3 volatilization and potential nitrification, leading to lower N losses. This result was aligned with the finding of
Kong et al., (2022).
Moreover, next to POCU and HACU, other coated urea fertilizers such as NOCU and SCU were also found to improve maize growth characteristics compared to UCU treatment. This improvement could be attributed to the inhibitor present in NOCU and the slow-release nature of SCU, which released nitrogen slowly and enhanced the plant growth characteristics by synchronizing with plant requirements. Overall, slow-release fertilizers have a positive and enhanced effect on the growth and yield of crops
(Ghafoor et al., 2022) by assimilation of chlorophyll transmitting captured light energy to PSII This process is influenced by electron transfer and photochemical activity
(Guo et al., 2022).
The correlation between LAI and chlorophyll content could be attributed to the fact that a larger leaf area allows for more photosynthetic activity, which in turn leads to higher chlorophyll production. The positive correlation between LAI and total chlorophyll content (r=0.66) indicated higher LAI conceded higher chlorophyll content (Fig 4). Therefore, treatments that promote higher LAI, such as the POCU and HACU treatments, are likely to also resulted in higher chlorophyll content. This result was in agreement with the findings of
Singh and Sharma (2020);
Bijay and Singh (2017);
Zhang et al., (2019).