Alternaria isolates selection
Isolates of
Alternaria viz.,
Alternaria doliconidium and
Alternaria destruens were isolates and confirmed by sending the samples to NCCS, Pune.
Alternaria doliconidium were found to be 100% similar to Accession no. MG828864.1 and
Alternaria destruens were found to be 99-100% similar to Accession no. NR137143.1. Hence, two different isolates
Alternaria doliconidium and
Alternaria destruens were selected for further pathological investigations.
Evaluation of Lablab purpureus (L.) bean genotypes using Alternaria doliconidium
Under greenhouse evaluation
The seeds of different genotypes were screened under artificial conditions of pathogen and the observations on the disease Intensity and disease incidence were summarised in Table 3. The lowest disease intensity were recorded in VRSEM-757
i.
e. 2.8% while, the highest were recorded in VRSEM-847
i.
e, 12.8%. Furthur resistant evaluation among genotypes showed that, the genotypes VRSEM-702 had disease Intensity of 9.8% followed by 8.4% for VRSEM- 843; 7.4% for VRSEM-746 and 6.2% for VRSEM-799. These were clubbed moderately resistant genotypes. Genotypes found to be resistant had disease intensities of 4.8% for VRSEM-739 followed by 4.2% for VRSEM-730; 3.8% for VRSEM-776 and 2.8% for VRSEM-757 whereas disease intensities for moderately susceptible genotypes were 12.8% for VRSEM-847 and 10.2% for VRSEM-733. It is showing that out of the 10 genotypes evaluated, 40% had disease intensity of moderately resistant and resistant reactions while only 20% showed moderately susceptible reaction. In our study, there were a non- significant effect
i.
e. null hypothesis is accepted at the p>0.05 level for the three conditions F (2, 27) = 0.49; p>0.05 (Table 2).
The disease incidence varied from 10.67% (VRSEM 702) to 34.67% (VRSEM 757). One way ANOVA is used to compare means from two independent groups using the F-distribution. In our study, there were a non-significant effect
i.
e. null hypothesis is accepted at the p>0.05 level for the three conditions F (2, 27) = 2.685; p>0.05.
Under field evaluation
Field evaluation test were conducted for the 10
Lablab purpureus (L.) genotypes to determine their potential resistance/tolerance to leaf spot disease. Five genotypes were found moderately resistant, three were found to be resistant and two were found be moderately susceptible (Table 5). The lowest disease intensity were recorded in VRSEM- 757
i.
e. 3.2% while, the highest were recorded in VRSEM-702
i.
e. 12.6%. Furthur, resistant evaluation among genotypes showed that the genotypes VRSEM-843 had disease intensity of 5.1% followed by 9.4% for VRSEM-739, 6.2% for VRSEM-746, 7.4% for VRSEM-730 and 5.4% for VRSEM-733. These were clubbed moderately resistant genotypes. Genotype found to be resistant had disease Intensity of 4.4% for VRSEM-799, 3.2% for VRSEM-757 and 2.8% for VRSEM-776 whereas disease intensity for moderately susceptible genotypes were 11.80% for VRSEM- 847 and 12.60% for VRSEM-702. In our study, there were a non- significant effect
i.
e. null hypothesis is accepted at the p>0.05 level for the three conditions F (2, 27) = 0.34; p=>0.05 (Table 3).
The mean disease incidence of the ten genotypes were ranged from 8% for VRSEM- 776 to 28% for VRSEM-702. The maximum disease incidence of 28% were found in VRSEM-702 followed by 24% for VRSEM-730 and VRSEM- 847; 20% in VRSEM-746 and VRSEM- 739; 16% in VRSEM- 843 and VRSEM- 733; 12% in VRSEM-799 and VRSEM- 757 and 8% in VRSEM- 776. In our study, there were a significant effect
i.
e, null hypothesis is rejected at the p<0.05 level for the three conditions F (2, 27) = 4.74; p =<0.05.
Evaluation of Lablab purpureus (L.) bean genotypes using Alternaria destruens
Under greenhouse evaluation
The seeds of different genotypes were screened under greenhouse conditions of pathogen for their reaction to pathogen. The lowest disease intensity were recorded in VRSEM-757
i.
e. 3.2% while, the highest were recorded in VRSEM-730
i.
e. 12.8%. Furthur, resistant evaluation among genotypes showed that the genotypes VRSEM-730 had disease intensity of 8.66% followed by 8.00% for VRSEM- 799; 7.60% for VRSEM-847; 7.46% for VRSEM-739; 7.00% for VRSEM- 843; 6.73% for VRSEM- 733; 5.60% for VRSEM- 746 and 5.33% for VRSEM-776. These were clubbed moderately resistant genotypes. Genotypes found to be resistant had disease intensity of 3.86% for VRSEM-702 and 3.20% for VRSEM- 757. Thus, It is showing that out of the 10 genotypes evaluated, 80% had disease intensity of moderately resistant and only 20% found to be resistant. The mean disease incidence varied from 8.00% (VRSEM- 843) to 26.33% (VRSEM- 746) with a mean of 20.40% (Table 4).
In our study of disease incidence and disease intensity, there were a non-significant effect
i.
e. null hypothesis is accepted at the p>0.05 level for the three conditions F (2, 27) = 1.52; p>0.05 and F (2, 27) = 0.51 resp.
Under field evaluation
Field evaluation test were conducted for the 10
Lablab purpureus (L.) genotypes to determine their potential resistance/tolerance to Leaf spot disease through disease intensity and disease incidence. Eight genotypes were found moderately resistant, one were found to be resistant and one were found be moderately susceptible. The mean disease intensity ranged from 10.93% for VRSEM-746 to 3.46% for VRSEM-776. The disease intensity for moderately resistant genotypes were 8.53% for VRSEM-833, 7.33% for VRSEM-739 and VRSEM-757, 6.33% for VRSEM-799, 6.26% for VRSEM-739, 6.06% for VRSEM- 847, 5.53% for VRSEM-702 and 5.33% for VRSEM-730. Genotype found to be resistant had disease intensity of 3.46% for VRSEM- 776 whereas disease intensity for moderately susceptible Genotypes was 10.93% for VRSEM- 746. The Mean disease incidence of the ten genotypes were ranged from 9.33% for VRSEM-776 to 26.67% for VRSEM- 746 followed by 25.33% for VRSEM- 702, 21.33% for VRSEM-847, 20.00% for VRSEM-730, 17.33% for VRSEM-739, 16.00% for VRSEM- 733, 14.67% for VRSEM-843 and VRSEM- 799 and 12.00% for VRSEM-757 (Table 5).
In our study of disease intensity, there were a non-significant effect
i.
e. null hypothesis is accepted at the p>0.05 level for the three conditions F (2, 27) = 4.61; p =>0.05 whereas null hypothesis is rejected
i.
e. significant in case of disease incidence at p<0.05 level for the three conditions F (2, 27) = 0.05; P=<0.05.
No work appears to have been done on the source of resistance to
Lablab purpureus (L.) bean against
Alternaria destruens and
Alternaria doliconidium. However, some work has been done on varietal resistance against
Alternaria alternata in other beans.
Gurha et al., (1981) recorded first time the prevalence of pathogenic attack of
Alternaria alternata on Broad bean (
Vicia faba L.) and searched the sources of resistance against the pathogen.
Maheshwari and Singh (1997) screened 99 genotypes from Uttar Pradesh for their response to the leaf spot caused by
Alternaria. Cultivars found resistant are JDL 77, Arka Vijay, Rajani and Pusa Early Prolific whereas, cultivars found highly susceptible were Kalyanpur Type 2, 7103, Arka Jay, 81, Culture 6802, HA3, HD1 and JDL 85. In our study, the genotypes which were found resistant in both the condition is VRSEM 739 and VRSEM 776 whereas
Shivanna and Shetty (1991) screened eight cluster bean varieties and found HG 182 showing the lowest per cent infection of
A.
cyamopsidis in both pot and field trials.
The genotypes which were found Moderately resistant under greenhouse evaluation and field trial against
Alternaria leaf spot is VRSEM 873 whereas,
Bharodia et al., (1993) found cluster bean variety GAUG 34, the variety with high gum content as moderately resistant to bacterial blight,
Alternaria leaf spot and Powdery mildew while
Kushwaha et al., (1993) reported 12 cultivars of faba bean seedlings being inoculated by
Alternaria alternate pathogen and sustained under plastic covers with high relative humidity, JV-I and Dholi-II found moderately resistant (6-10% infection). The genotypes which were found Moderately susceptible under both condition against
Alternaria leaf spot were VRSEM 847 whereas,
Pangavhane (2001) screened varieties of cluster bean against blight and leaf spot caused by
Alternaria cyamposidis and found Pusa Navbahar variety highly susceptible, Neelam-51 as susceptible and Dipali and Sona-51 found to be moderately susceptible. Varieties have been graded by using scale from 0 to 5 as suggested by
Mathur et al., (1972). On the other hand, Singh and Singh 1998 screened 29
Phaseouls vulgaris varieties against
A.
alternata in field and Kentucky wonder, EC- 26392 and PBL-14-1 were found resistant. EC-57080, Sel-9, MB- Radish spotted, sum-1, p-37, sel-48-2-3 and sel48-1-2 gave moderately resistant reaction. MB light brown, Arka Komal, Mbwhite, Pusa Parvati Contender, D- 48, Pusa Hem Lata, Sel- 2, Sel- 4 and SB black were moderately susceptible.
Aleme (2022) evaluate the performance of 12 accessions of
Lablab across various locations of Ethiopia. In this study, lablab accessions are relatively more tolerant to disease than
Hidosa et al., (2016). According to
Kankwatsa (2018), there were
lablab accessions that displayed higher disease resistance levels in Uganda.