The transition period of dairy cows, defined as the interval from three weeks before calving to three weeks after parturition, is one of the most metabolically demanding phases in the production cycle of high-yielding dairy cattle
(Bakshi et al., 2017). During early lactation, the energy requirement for milk synthesis increases rapidly, often exceeding the amount of energy consumed through feed intake. This metabolic condition results in negative energy balance (NEB), where energy output surpasses energy intake (
Mekuriaw, 2023).
Negative energy balance is a major metabolic challenge during the transition period of dairy cows and can negatively affect health, production and reproductive performance
(Chandra et al., 2019).
High-producing dairy cows, particularly crossbred animals developed for improved milk yield, are highly susceptible to NEB due to their elevated metabolic demands
(Ramadan et al., 2025). In response to energy deficiency, cows mobilize body reserves, primarily adipose tissue, leading to increased concentrations of circulating metabolites such as non-esterified fatty acids (NEFA) and beta-hydroxybutyrate (BHBA) (
Nathasya, 2024). While this metabolic adaptation supports milk production during early lactation, prolonged or excessive NEB may lead to metabolic disorders, reduced reproductive efficiency and compromised immune function
(Sonea et al., 2023).
Recent advances in dairy production systems have introduced various monitoring tools and mitigation strategies aimed at detecting and managing NEB (
Gheorghe-Irimia et al., 2023). Monitoring approaches include body condition scoring, blood metabolic biomarkers, milk composition indicators and precision livestock technologies
(Gonzalez et al., 2018). Similarly, nutritional and management interventions such as energy-dense diets, rumen-protected nutrients and feed additives have been proposed to mitigate NEB and enhance metabolic stability
(Vithalrao et al., 2025).
Although numerous studies have evaluated these strategies, results remain inconsistent across production environments and management systems (
Erdaw and Beyene, 2022). Therefore, synthesizing the available evidence through meta-analysis provides a robust approach to quantify the overall effectiveness of NEB monitoring and mitigation tools on dairy cow productivity and health
(Beaumont et al., 2022).
Problem statement
One of the most serious metabolic challenges facing high-yielding dairy cows during early lactation is negative energy balance
(Berset et al., 2021). In small-scale or semi-intensive dairy farming systems, inadequate feeding management, feed quality and transition management are likely to increase the negative energy balance
(Ramadan et al., 2025).
Several tools for monitoring negative energy balance, as well as mitigation strategies, have been put forward (
Fentener van Vlissingen et al., 2015). However, dairy farmers are still facing challenges in finding the most efficient strategy for maintaining an optimum energy balance to enhance dairy cow productivity (
Gheorghe-Irimia et al., 2023). Most research has been based on single interventions, leading to inconsistent results based on breed, diet and management practices (
Cuadrado-Roura et al., 2025).
It is therefore essential to critically review all available research to ascertain the general efficacy of negative energy balance monitoring and mitigation strategies on dairy cow productivity.
Objectives
General objective
The general objective of the study was to assess the effectiveness of the negative energy balance monitoring and mitigation tools on the milk production, reproductive performance and metabolic health of high-yielding crossbred dairy cows through a meta-analysis study.
Specific objectives
1. Evaluate the effectiveness of the NEB monitoring tools for the early detection of metabolic imbalances.
2. Determine the effect of the mitigation strategies on the milk yield and composition.
3. Evaluate the influence of the NEB management strategies on the reproductive performance.
4. Evaluate the impact of the mitigation interventions on the metabolic health.
Study design
A systematic review and meta-analysis was conducted at Dambi Dollo University, College of Agriculture and Natural Resources, Kellem Wollega, Oromia, Ethiopia, to comprehensively evaluate the effectiveness of monitoring tools and mitigation techniques for negative energy balance in dairy cows. The review synthesized evidence from peer-reviewed studies published between 2015 and 2025, focusing on dairy cattle nutrition, metabolic health and transition cow management.
Relevant literature was systematically identified, screened and analyzed according to predefined eligibility criteria. The systematic review enabled a critical assessment of available management and nutritional strategies for reducing or monitoring negative energy balance in dairy cows. The meta-analysis combined quantitative findings from independent studies conducted under different experimental conditions, production systems and dairy cattle breeds to provide an overall estimate of the effectiveness of the evaluated interventions.
The review particularly focused on indicators and management strategies related to negative energy balance, including feed and nutrient management, body condition, metabolic health indicators, milk production and transition-cow management. The synthesis of evidence from multiple studies was used to identify consistent effects, sources of variation and the applicability of these strategies to high-yielding and crossbred dairy cattle production systems.
Literature search strategy
For a comprehensive and systematic collection of relevant literature, scientific studies published between 2015 and 2025 were carefully retrieved from widely and well-recognized academic databases such as Scopus, Web of Science, ScienceDirect, PubMed and Google Scholar
(Tibebu et al., 2024). A systematic approach was used to conduct a comprehensive and thorough search of the relevant literature using carefully selected and specific keywords and their combinations related to the specific objectives of the research
(Chaiban et al., 2020). The major keywords used in the systematic review were negative energy balance, transition dairy cows, metabolic biomarkers, milk production, reproductive performance, feed additives and rumen-protected nutrients
(Memon et al., 2025). The keywords were used individually and in combination using boolean operators to cover a wide range of relevant literature on the monitoring and mitigation of negative energy balance in high-yielding dairy cows (
Mekuriaw, 2023). This systematic approach to the review ensured that a wide range of diverse and high-quality scientific studies on the nutritional, metabolic and productive responses of dairy cows during the transition period were incorporated into the review
(Vithalrao et al., 2025).
Inclusion criteria (PICOS framework)
The inclusion criteria for this study were clearly defined using the PICOS criteria to ensure a clear and high-standard synthesis of available information. The study population of focus was high-yielding dairy cows, including crossbred cows, particularly during the critical period
(Leistikow et al., 2022). The interventions of focus covered various tools used to monitor negative energy balance and various strategies to address it (
Maris, 2017). These interventions were then compared to a control that did not receive any treatment, allowing a clear evaluation of their effectiveness. The outcome of focus covered various parameters that determine the productivity and health of high-yielding dairy cows, particularly in relation to their reproductive and metabolic health
(Zargaran et al., 2026). These parameters included milk production and composition, reproductive performance and metabolic indicators such as NEFA and BHBA. The study was restricted to peer-reviewed experimental and observational studies to ensure a clear and scientifically valid synthesis of available information (
Patra, 2016). This ensures a clear and robust basis to assess the overall impact of various strategies to address negative energy balance on the productivity and health of high-yielding dairy cows (
Bekuma, 2019).
Data extraction
From every study included, a thorough set of data was meticulously collected to facilitate a thorough and systematic analysis
(Sherif et al., 2025). This included data on the author and year of publication, which provided a context based on time, allowing for an understanding of research trends over a period of a decade (
Lin, 2025). Additionally, data on countries and production systems were collected to allow for a more thorough understanding of regional and management-related variations (
Patra, 2016). The breed of dairy cows was also included to allow for an understanding of variations based on genetics. Data on types of monitoring or mitigation strategies employed was also collected to facilitate a thorough categorization of data
(Garavito et al., 2024). Outcome measures such as milk yield, milk composition, reproductive performance and metabolic measures such as NEFA and BHBA levels were also collected to allow for an understanding of the effectiveness of NEB management strategies based on various aspects of dairy cow productivity (
Mekuriaw, 2023).
Statistical analysis
The meta-analysis was carried out using a random-effects model to obtain a comprehensive estimate of the pooled effect sizes, accounting for the variability between studies
(Srettiwat et al., 2023). This enabled the synthesis of findings from varied experimental conditions, breeds and production systems to develop a comprehensive understanding of NEB monitoring and mitigation strategies (
Kumar and Srivastava, 2025). The statistical analysis was carried out using the calculation of standardized mean difference (SMD) to estimate the effect size of the interventions and heterogeneity analysis was also performed using the I² statistic to assess the heterogeneity between the studies (
Lin, 2025). To assess publication bias in the meta-analysis, the use of a funnel plot was made to ensure the validity of the findings
(Alders et al., 2018). Subgroup analyses were also carried out on the basis of the intervention types to assess the differences and identify the interventions that were more effective in increasing milk production, reproductive efficiency and metabolic health in high-yielding dairy cows
(Kang et al., 2025).
Study selection
The systematic search yielded a total of 1,240 articles, which were then narrowed down to 145 articles based on a thorough screening of titles and abstracts. Finally, based on the inclusion criteria set for the study, a total of 38 high-quality articles published between 2015 and 2025 were included in the final meta-analysis. The articles included in the meta-analysis were diverse, including various geographical areas such as North America, Europe, Asia, Africa, among others. The articles also included various breeds of high-yielding dairy cows, such as Holstein-Friesian and crossbreed cows. This is an indication that the results obtained from the meta-analysis are relevant to a wide range of areas around the world.
Fig 1 presents the summary of study selection process, characteristics of included trials, PRISMA flow diagram, geographic distribution, journal trends from 2015 to 2025 and breed distribution.
Effects on milk production
The meta-analysis revealed that the implementation of NEB mitigation strategies had a significant positive effect on milk production in high-yielding dairy cows. Overall, it was revealed that these strategies, which included energy-rich diets, rumen-protected nutrients and specific feed additives, would result in an 8 to 15% increase in milk production. Among these strategies, supplementation with rumen-protected choline and fats was noted to be particularly beneficial. This is because these compounds play a critical role in maintaining liver function and improving energy metabolism in dairy cows. Liver function is critical in ensuring that cows are able to efficiently utilize nutrients, particularly during the early lactation period when metabolic demands are high. Various strategies for mitigating negative energy balance (NEB), including nutritional management and dietary supplementation, can help support milk production in high-yielding dairy cows during early lactation (Fig 2).
Effects on reproductive performance
The implementation of NEB mitigation strategies has also been associated with significant improvements in reproductive performance among high-yielding dairy cows. The pooled data analysis indicated that NEB mitigation strategies reduced days open by 10 to 18 days, increased conception rates by 12 to 20% and increased ovarian activity during early lactation. The improvements are mainly attributed to the energy status of the cows, which reduces metabolic stress and allows normal reproductive activity to resume. This is a clear indication of how closely reproductive performance is linked to metabolic management, with NEB mitigation strategies improving both milk and reproductive performance among high-yielding dairy cows. Efficient reduction of negative energy balance (NEB) by means of proper nutrition and dietary supplementation will help to enhance the reproductive success of high-yielding dairy cattle by promoting the restoration of normal ovulation, increased chances of conception and decreasing the time for the first service post-calving (Fig 3).
Effects on metabolic health indicators
The effectiveness of the NEB mitigation strategies on the metabolic health of high-yielding dairy cows was considerable. The results of the pooled analysis showed a reduction of 15 to 30 percent in the plasma NEFA concentration, BHBA levels indicating a reduced risk of ketosis and an improvement in the glucose and insulin status, indicating an improvement in the energy metabolism of the cows. The results of the present study clearly show the importance of the effective management of negative energy balance, which is beneficial to the productivity of dairy cows as well as to the metabolic stability of the cows during the critical transition period. Appropriate strategies to control metabolic energy balance including providing a balanced diet, optimizing feeding and supplementing with nutrition can improve metabolic homeostasis in high yielding cows during early lactation. This may improve the cow’s energy status by reducing excessive mobilization of body stores and decrease risk of metabolic diseases like ketosis and fatty liver (Fig 4).
Heterogeneity among studies
The results of the meta-analysis indicated the existence of moderate heterogeneity between the results of the included studies, with I² values ranging between 55% and 72%. The results of the sensitivity analysis indicated the reliability of the results obtained, since it was found that the overall effects of NEB monitoring and mitigation on aspects such as milk production, reproductive performance and metabolic health were consistent despite the existence of heterogeneity.
The findings of this meta-analysis provide compelling evidence that effective monitoring and mitigation strategies for negative energy balance (NEB) substantially enhance both productivity and metabolic health in high-yielding dairy cows, particularly during the critical transition period
(Cooke et al., 2025). The significant improvements in milk production observed across the analyzed studies are consistent with previous research highlighting the importance of optimizing dietary energy supply and maintaining metabolic balance to support milk synthesis in high-yielding dairy cows
(Kaniamuthan et al., 2025). Early lactation represents a phase when feed intake often lags behind the rapidly increasing energy demands for milk production
(Gupta et al., 2023). Without targeted nutritional interventions, negative energy balance (NEB) may lead to reduced milk yield, excessive mobilization of body reserves and an increased risk of metabolic disorders in high-yielding dairy cows
(Bounoua et al., 2025). Among the most effective strategies, rumen-protected nutrients such as choline and methionine emerged as critical components for optimizing metabolic efficiency (
Kiplagat, 2025). These nutrients support hepatic function, facilitate proper fat metabolism and reduce the risk of fatty liver syndrome, which is a common complication of NEB in high-producing dairy cows
(Karim et al., 2026). By improving the cow’s ability to metabolize energy efficiently, these interventions directly enhance milk synthesis and overall metabolic health, demonstrating a clear mechanistic link between nutritional support and production outcomes (
Linde, 2022). Additionally, energy-dense diets and targeted feed additives contributed to higher milk yield by supplying additional metabolizable energy to meet the high demands of early lactation
(Vithalrao et al., 2025).
Beyond milk production, reproductive performance was significantly improved by NEB mitigation strategies. Severe negative energy balance is known to suppress ovarian activity, delay the resumption of estrous cycles and extend days open (
Mekuriaw, 2023). The meta-analysis revealed that targeted interventions reduced days open by 10-18 days, increased conception rates by 12-20% and enhanced ovarian activity during early lactation (
Mekuriaw, 2023). These improvements are largely attributable to enhanced energy status and reduced metabolic stress, which promote hormonal balance and timely recovery of reproductive function
(Azizov et al., 2024). This highlights the critical interrelationship between nutrition, metabolism and fertility in transition cows, underscoring that effective NEB management is essential not only for milk productivity but also for maintaining herd fertility and long-term reproductive efficiency (
Mekuriaw, 2023).
Metabolic health indicators further support the effectiveness of these interventions. The pooled results indicated a 15-30% reduction in plasma NEFA concentrations, decreased BHBA levels and improved glucose and insulin balance
(Honan et al., 2021).
Blood biochemical parameters can be used as useful indicators for evaluating energy balance and metabolic status in dairy cows
(Reddy et al., 2025).
Lower NEFA and BHBA concentrations reflect reduced mobilization of body fat and decreased risk of ketosis, while stable glucose and insulin profiles indicate improved energy partitioning for both production and maintenance (
Assessment of Smallholder Chicken Production, 2021). Maintaining metabolic stability during early lactation is critical, as this period is highly susceptible to metabolic stress, which can compromise both productivity and health (
Gross and Bruckmaier, 2019). Effective mitigation strategies thus play a vital role in reducing the incidence of metabolic disorders, decreasing veterinary interventions and promoting the overall well-being and longevity of high-yielding dairy cows
(Vithalrao et al., 2025).
Despite these positive outcomes, the meta-analysis revealed moderate heterogeneity among studies (I² values ranging from 55% to 72%), reflecting differences in breed, diet composition, feeding strategies and production systems (
Lamb, 2008). Crossbred cows, for instance, may respond differently to energy-dense diets compared with purebred Holsteins due to variations in metabolic efficiency and body condition dynamics (
Mekuriaw, 2023). Similarly, management practices such as feeding frequency, access to high-quality forage and the formulation of transition diets can influence the magnitude of response to NEB mitigation strategies
(Cohen et al., 2025). These factors highlight the importance of customizing interventions to the specific needs of individual herds and production environments rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all approach (
Okiomeri, 2020).
The practical implications of these findings are significant for dairy management. By integrating precision monitoring tools such as metabolic biomarker analysis, body condition scoring and milk composition evaluation, early detection of NEB becomes possible, allowing timely nutritional and management interventions
(Gonzalez et al., 2018). This proactive approach not only optimizes milk production and reproductive efficiency but also reduces the risk of metabolic diseases, supporting sustainable and profitable dairy operations (
Gheorghe-Irimia et al., 2023).
Finally, this meta-analysis contributes to the broader understanding of ruminant nutrition and transition cow management by providing a quantitative synthesis of the effectiveness of NEB interventions across diverse systems, breeds and environmental conditions
(Bateki et al., 2020). The evidence confirms that coordinated strategies, combining monitoring and targeted nutritional interventions, can deliver measurable improvements in milk yield, fertility and metabolic health
(Kang et al., 2025). Future research should focus on refining these strategies further by examining the interactions between specific feed additives, genetic potential and environmental factors to optimize transition cow performance globally (
Nkrumah, 2025).
In summary, strategic NEB management during the transition period is essential for enhancing milk production, reproductive efficiency and metabolic stability
(Memon et al., 2025). The robust evidence synthesized in this meta-analysis reinforces the value of tailored, evidence-based nutritional and management practices that support both productivity and health in high-yielding dairy cows, offering a strong foundation for sustainable and profitable dairy production systems worldwide (
Abdisa and Tagesu, 2017).
Appropriate nutritional management during the transition period is essential for maintaining dry matter intake, supporting metabolic adaptation and reducing the severity of negative energy balance and associated metabolic disorders in high-yielding dairy cows
(Shafi et al., 2019). Dietary factors, particularly the balance between neutral detergent fiber and non-fibrous carbohydrates, can influence dry matter intake and feeding behavior during the transition period
(Huang et al., 2019). Similar evidence from crossbred cows indicates that nutritional supplementation during the transition period can influence nutrient intake, milk production and production efficiency (
Sidhu, 2023).
Hematological and biochemical parameters are valuable indicators for assessing the metabolic and physiological status of dairy animals during the transition period and for identifying metabolic disturbances associated with negative energy balance and postpartum health challenges
(Kour et al., 2024). Parameters such as haemoglobin, packed cell volume, albumin, total protein, triglycerides, calcium, sodium and potassium can be used to characterize metabolic changes associated with the transition period
(Paul et al., 2024).