Grafting is the horticultural technique that involves joining the two plant parts together so that they will readily unite to continue their growth together. The lower part of the combined plant is called rootstock while the upper part is called the scion in which cambial layers perfectly match and the tissues completely unite to form the whole plant (
Poincelot, 1990). It is a natural or deliberate fusion of plant parts, as a result, a vascular continuity bridge is established between them (
Pina and Errea, 2005) and the resulting genetically composite organism functions as a single plant. This technique is the most commonly used asexual propagation of commercially grown agricultural crops especially horticultural plants wherein the lower portion forms root
i.e. rootstock and the upper portion form shoots
i.e. scion which is selected from the stem, leaves, flowers, fruits,
etc. (
Hottes, 1925). The rootstock is raised from seeds in most cases (
Sadhu, 1986). In this plant union, scion becomes the new shoot for the plant union and the rootstock supports the root system and conducts nutrient
s across the graft union into the shoot. According to
Ziegler and Wolfe (1981), the following factors must be considered during grafting; it must be true to type, with a record of satisfactory production for at least 5 years, free from systemic diseases and must have attained maturity.
From a genetic perspective, grafting involves the creation and development of a composite genetic system by uniting two or more distinct plant parts of genotypes, each of them maintains their own and distinct genetic identity throughout the life period. A degree of compatibility is another important genetic consideration while performing grafting.
Mudge et al., (2009) broadly define and categorize the limit of compatibility. Generally, interclonal/intraspecific grafts (rootstock and scion belonging to same botanical species) are nearly always compatible, interspecific/intrageneric grafts (rootstock and scion belonging to different species of the same genus) are usually compatible, intrageneric/intrafamilial grafts are rarely compatible and interfamilial grafts are essentially always incompatible.
Andrews and Marquez (1993) recognizefour potential factors that may contribute to incompatibility: (I) cellular recognition, (II) wounding response, (III) growth regulators and (IV) incompatibility toxins. In addition to graft incompatibility, graft failure also can be caused by anatomical mismatching due to poor craftsmanship, seasonal variability, environmental conditions and different diseases
(Hartmann et al., 2002).
Grafting is a well-developed and commonly used practice that has many physiological, biological and horticultural uses. Grafting may be used to enhance nutrient uptake
(Colla et al., 2010a), induce tolerance against low and high temperature
(Rivero et al., 2003 and
Venema et al., 2008), improve water use efficiency
(Rouphael et al., 2008a), increase the synthesis of endogenous hormones
(Dong et al., 2008), improve alkalinity tolerance
(Colla et al., 2010b), improve salt and flooding tolerance
(Yetisir et al., 2006 and
He et al., 2009), limit the negative effect of boron, copper, cadmium and manganese toxicity
(Edelstein et al., 2005; Rouphael et al., 2008b; Arao et al., 2008 and
Savvas et al., 2009) and also reduce uptake of persistent organic pollutants from agricultural soils (
Otani and Seike, 2006, 2007). Moreover, graft combination may alter sex expression and flowering of grafted plants by altering the amounts of hormone produced (
Satoh, 1996). The higher yield of grafted plants is may be due to large size quality fruits as grafted plants are resistant to soil borne diseases
, has a strong root system and greater photosynthetic activity
(Xu et al., 2005 and
Qi et al., 2006).
The success and subsequent growth of grafted saplings depend on many factors including environmental conditions, variety, method of grafting and selection of scion and rootstock materials
(Hartmann et al., 2002). The prevailing environmental conditions are primarily governed by the grafting seasons and propagation structures under which grafting is performed. The climatic factors like light, temperature, rainfall and humidity have a significant influence on the percentage of survival and establishment of grafts (
Singh and Singh, 2006). This paper aims to review the recent research findings on the success, survival and growth of grafted saplings to varying seasonal and propagation environments in tropical and subtropical fruit crops.
Factors affecting grafting
Effect of grafting season on various growth parameters
The success/failure of grafting is highly correlated with the environmental conditions under which it is performed. One of the most important conditions for successful grafting is the selection of the appropriate season of grafting which is conducive to rapid graft healing and subsequently the formation of the graft union. A study conducted by
Singh and Srivastava (1979) in meteorological data about the success of grafting revealed that high atmospheric humidity due to high rainfall and low maximum temperature coupled with high minimum temperature was very congenial to the union of the rootstock and scion. Similarly, high atmospheric humidity due to high rainfall and moderate temperatures was also found very congenial for the union of rootstock and scion (
Singh and Srivastava, 1982).
Swamy et al., (1993) reported that the success of grafting was highly correlated with higher monthly mean minimum temperature, afternoon relative humidity and the number of rainy days per month. However, grafting can be performed at any time of the year when suitable scion is available and protection from field hazards such as extreme climatic conditions, diseases and insects (
Shah, 1992).
Days taken for sprouting
It is the time taken between grafting to the sprouting of the first bud. Various research reported that the bud sprouting process highly depends upon the climatic factors of a growing environment where grafting has been performed. The congenial weather conditions such as optimum temperature and high relative humidity help in early sprouting. Favorable climatic conditions and better water availability play an important role in photosynthetic activity and early buds sprouting.
Joshi et al., (2000) reported that the minimum days were taken by March grafted custard apple (
Annona squamosa L.) plants for sprouting.
Tewari et al., (2004) recorded the minimum number of days (19.2 days) to sprouting in February while performing bench grafting in anola (
Emblica officinalis L.). An experiment conducted by
Prashant et al., (2007) on softwood grafting of mango (
Mangifera indica L.) at fortnight intervals from August to December showed that the earliest sprouting (24.50 days) in the first fortnight of September. A study conducted by
Giri and Lenka (2008) reported that the days taken for sprouting in the graft of wood apple (
Feronia limonia Swingle) was minimum (8 days) in May. A study carried out by
Patel et al., (2010) on softwood grafting in Khasi mandarin (
Citrus reticulata Blanco) reported that the grafting from June 30
th to August 15
th gave the minimum days for sprouting. Similarly,
Mulla et al., (2011) reported the number of days taken for sprouting was minimum (26.67 days) in June for softwood grafting in jamun (
Syzygium cumini Skeel). In another study conducted by
Salik et al., (2015) in sweet orange (
Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck) reported that the first sprouting was observed in 26 days after grafting when grafting was carried out in 2
nd week of February. A study conducted by
Khan et al., (2018) observed that the earliest sprouting (29 days) was recorded in lemon (
Citrus limon L.) when grafting was carried out on 29
th June.
Number of sprouts and sprouts length
The optimum temperature and relative humidity have a vital role that determines the sprouting and number of sprouts by avoiding desiccation of buds through active sap flow in grafts.
Patel et al., (2010) recorded the maximum number of sprouts (3.11) when softwood grafting was performed in Khasi mandarin during July. Research conducted to study the epicotyls grafting in mango showed that the maximum sprout length (20.05 cm) was observed when grafting was performed on 6
th August (
Islam and Rahim, 2010). The maximum number of sprouts (2.33) was recorded when grafting was performed during September and February in jamun
(Ghojage et al., 2011). Another study conducted by
Mulla et al., (2011) recorded the highest sprout length (5.34 cm) from the grafts performed during May in jamun.
Number of leaves and leaf area
The variation in the number of leaves during different months and seasons is due to exposure to different temperatures and humidity. These fluctuating weather parameters ultimately affect the success and survival of grafts because they have a direct effect on cell activity and the growth of stock and scion. The favorable environmental conditions primarily accelerate the early bud breaking and secondarily influence the maximum leaf flushing as well as the maximum number of leaves due to early healing and graft union formation. The early formation of callus bridge between scion and rootstock ultimately enhance the transport and movement of water and mineral nutrients through xylem and photosynthate through the phloem.
Islam et al., (2004) reported the highest number of leaves (22.16) in mango grafts prepared during June.
Adhikari (2006) reported maximum leaves per sapling (47) on 31
st January grafted sapling in acid lime (
Citrus aurantiifolia Swingle) at Rampur, Chitwan.
Kudmulwar et al., (2008) reported the highest number of leaves (21.93) in plants grafted during February in custard apple (
Annona squamosa L.) by using Balanagar scion. A study carried out by
Patil et al., (2010) reported the highest number of leaves (15.08) on the graft prepared during July in sapota [
Manilkara achras (Mill) Foseberg] with a new seedling of Khirni [
Manilkara hexandra (Roxb.) Dubard] rootstock.
Mulla et al., (2011) reported the highest number of leaves (12.48) in the graft prepared during June while the highest leaf area (34.8 cm
2) was observed during May in jamun. In another study conducted by
Ghojage et al., (2011) on softwood grafting in jamun reported the highest number of leaves (9.33) when grafting was performed during February. A study carried out by
Singh et al., (2012) showed that the veneer grafting performed on 30
th June, 15
th July and 30
th July produced the maximum number of leaves (24) in mango.
Angadi and Karadi (2012) observed that the graft performed during June gave the maximum number of leaves (12.64) and the highest leaf area (36.22 cm
2) in softwood grafting in jamun.
Chalise et al., (2013a) reported the highest number of leaves (48.47) on 14
th November grafted saplings whereas lowest (21.93) on 13
th January grafted saplings in mandarin at Dhankuta, Nepal. A study carried out by
Khan et al., (2018) observed the maximum number of leaves (11.9) on the grafts prepared on 6
th July in lemon.
Nahar et al., (2018) reported a leaf area of 18.87 cm
2 when lime (cv. BAU lime-1) was grafted onto lemon rootstock in Bangladesh.
Graft height
Graft height is one of the important parameters that determine the marketable age and price of saplings. Graft height is highly influenced by different growth parameters such as the number of leaves, leaf area and numbers of primary and secondary branches. Early healing of graft and higher cell activity during the optimum season of grafting determine sprouting and growth of grafts. The greater the leaf area higher will be the photosynthetic activity and ultimately better the growth and development of grafts. The variation of graft height in different seasons might be attributed to prevailing environmental conditions along with the availability of dormant and swollen buds of scion in a bulging condition which promotes earlier sprouting and better growth.
An experiment was conducted to investigate the effect of rootstock age and grafting time on the success of custard apple in which maximum graft height (37.08 cm) was recorded when grafting was conducted during February
(Pawar et al., 2003). Patil et al., (2010) obtained the highest graft height (16.06 cm) when grafting was done during July in sapota. In a similar study on sapota, the highest graft height was observed when grafting was carried out on 15
th May (
Ratna, 2012).
Alka et al., (2010) reported that softwood grafting performed in jamun under Akola conditions showed that 15
th September and 15
th March grafted saplings were superior with respect to graft height. In another study carried out by
Salik et al., (2015) in sweet orange observed that the maximum graft height (19.5 cm) was observed when grafting was carried on the 2
nd week of February. A study carried out by
Khan et al., (2018) observed that the highest graft height (9.9 cm) was recorded on graft prepared on 6
th July in lemon.
Graft union success and survival
There is variation in graft success and survivability because of the variation of temperature and relative humidity during different months and seasons. The maximum graft success is directly related to prevailing optimum temperature and higher relative humidity. These congenial weather conditions facilitate early contact of the cambium layer of rootstock and scion resulting in early callus formation and initiation of subsequent growth.
Poon (1998) reported veneer grafting in the 2
nd week of December had the highest grafting success (97.91%) as compared to other dates in mandarin.
Nayak and Sen (2000) noticed that the percentage of veneer graft success was greater in July-August (78.80%) followed by January-March (75%) in mango. A study conducted by Chaitanya (2000) reported the highest grafting success in sapota cv. Kalipatti when grafting was carried out during May and July (90 and 85%) respectively.
Gautam et al., (2001) suggested grafting from 16
th to 31
st January was the best time of grafting for mandarin at Lumle, Kaski. They observed the maximum grafting success (87.50%) on 31
st January whereas minimum success (37.50%) on 20
th November. A study conducted by
Islam et al., (2003) in epicotyl grafting in jackfruit (
Artocarpus heterophyllus L.) in which the highest success (49.55%) and highest survival (45.47%) was recorded by the grafts prepared during June whereas success was lower (10.08%) in the grafts prepared during April.
Adhikari (2006) elucidated that the highest graft success (79.73%) was observed in acid lime grafted onto trifoliate orange (
Poncirus trifoliata L.) rootstock on 16
th January by shoot tip method in Chitwan. In another study,
Simkhada (2007) suggested that April was the ideal time for veneer grafting in persimmon (
Diospyros kaki Thunb.). The highest success percentage (82.50%) was recorded in the first fortnight of September in softwood grafting in mango
(Prasanth et al., 2007). Patil et al., (2010) reported the highest graft take (63.33%) during July in sapota. Research conducted by
Ghosh et al., (2010) in softwood grafting in sapota observed the highest graft success (72%) on 1
st July under Paschim Midnapur conditions of West Bengal. An investigation carried out by
Chandra et al., (2011) reported the maximum graft success (85%) in pomegranate (
Punica granatum L.) cv. Bhagwa after 90 days of grafting with wedge grafting performed on 30
th January.
Mulla et al., (2011) on softwood grating in jamun noticed the highest graft success (100%) in November and May and highest graft survival (93.33%).
Uchoi et al., (2012) reported the highest graft survival (90.50%) during January in jamun.
Singh et al., (2012) reported the veneer grafting performed on 15
th July recorded the highest graft-take success (96.66%) and survival (90%) in mango. Research conducted by
Chalise et al., (2013a) at Paripatle, Dhankuta reported the highest graft success (96.11%) on 13
th January in mandarin. A study conducted by
Kalabandi et al., (2014) in sapota var. Kalipatti noticed the highest graft survival (64.21%) when grafting was performed during August under Marathwada conditions. Grafting carried out on the 1
st week of February had the maximum graft survival (89.30%) in sweet orange
(Salik et al., 2015). Bhandari (2018) reported the highest graft success and survivability on 25
th January as compared to early dates in different citrus species at Kavre, Nepal.
Effect of propagation environment on growth parameters
Propagation environment and structures such as greenhouse, glasshouse, polyhouse, nethouse and mist chamber have a direct influence on the success and survivability of grafts. A fine water spray (intermittent mist) at frequent intervals reduces transpiration rate and leaf temperature by increasing relative humidity inside the propagating structures thereby creating a favorable environment for graft success and subsequent growth of saplings. The high temperature and high atmospheric humidity were very congenial for the formation of graft union between scion and rootstock
(Hartmann et al., 2002). Production of quality planting materials throughout the year is possible through modification of the growth environment to a certain extent (
Khan, 1994). The propagation environment influences various growth parameters significantly by altering temperature, humidity, light and other climatic factors. Shade also plays an important role in grafting and provision of shade during and after grafting was found to have a positive effect on the success of grafting. Light is essential for photosynthetic activity and better nourishment of grafts. The rate of photosynthetic activity varies with the level of shade
(Swamy et al., 1993). The variation of graft success and subsequent growth of saplings under different coloured shade structures might be due to minor interference on the plant micro-climate which can modify both the quantity and the quality of transmitted sunlight.
Days taken for sprouting
Days taken for sprouting is greatly reduced under the protected condition compared to the open condition due to suitable environmental condition
s for the formation of the graft union. The prevailing suitable temperature and relative humidity under the protected structures facilitate early contact of cambium layers of rootstock and scion, early callus formation and initiation of subsequent growth. A study conducted to determine the effect of colour of polyhouse (white, red and blue) and open condition on the sprouting of mango showed that the earliest graft was sprouted under red polyhouse which was significantly superior to open conditions (
Hema Nair et al., 2002).
Selvi et al., (2008) studied the effect of grafting environment (mist, 50% agro shade and tree shade) on the success of softwood grafting in jackfruit and observed that the lowest number of days (20.89 days) were taken under 50 per cent shade net for sprouting. A study conducted by
Patel et al., (2010) reported the minimum days required for sprouting under polyhouse (34.67 days) followed by open condition and nethouse in Khasi mandarin. According to
Visen et al., (2010), the time taken for sprouting was significantly reduced (12-13 days) under greenhouse conditions compared to open field while performing wedge grafting in guava (
Psidium guajava L.) cv. Allahabad Safeda, Lucknow 49 and Lalit under North Indian plains. A softwood grafting performed in jamun under nethouse as well as open field conditions showed that the grafting operation carried out in open field conditions took significantly lesser days (22.9 days) for sprouting
(Shinde et al., 2010). A wedge grafting was performed in anola under polyhouse conditions took minimum days (6.5 days) for first sprouting compared to open field conditions (11.3 days) during November (
Gurjar and Singh, 2012). A study revealed that the minimum mean number of days taken for sprouting of mango grafts under naturally ventilated polyhouse was 12.11 days while the highest mean number of days (13.46 days) taken for sprouting was recorded in partial shade under coconut trees
(Sivudu et al., 2014a). Similarly, another study carried out by
Sivudu et al., (2014b) reported that the lowest number of days taken for sprouting was observed under a naturally ventilated polyhouse (10.60 days).
Number of sprouts and sprout length
Various researchers reported that the number of sprouts and sprout length is higher under the protected condition due to favorable growing environmental conditions.
Patel et al., (2010) reported that the maximum numbers of sprouts (3.07) were recorded in polyhouse compared to open conditions (2.33) in softwood grafting in Khasi mandarin.
Mulla et al., (2011) reported that the maximum sprout length was obtained under controlled conditions during February in jamun. A study revealed that the maximum sprout length was observed in naturally ventilated polyhouse (6.06 cm) followed by a partial shade under coconut (5.93 cm) while the lowest sprout length was recorded by grafting under open conditions (5.21 cm) in mango
(Sivudu et al., 2014a). Similarly, another study conducted by
Sivudu et al., (2014b) recorded the highest sprout length (6.06 cm) under the partial shade of coconut followed by a naturally ventilated polyhouse (5.93 cm).
Anushma et al., (2014) observed that the graft kept under a red coloured shade net recorded a significantly higher number of sprouts (2.31) whereas a lower number of sprouts (1.58) was recorded in grafts kept under a black shade net.
Number of leaves and leaf area
Grafting performed under protected condition has a greater number of leaves and leaf area. The favorable condition prevailing inside the structure induces rapid callusing and early contact of cambial layers which enables the graft to heal quickly for the strongest graft union formation that ultimately results in faster and better growth and development of grafts. An investigation carried out by Hema
Nair et al., (2002) observed the highest number of leaves per graft under red polyhouse which was significantly superior to open conditions.
Shinde et al., (2010) reported that grafting operation performed in open conditions produced significantly the highest number of leaves (4.9) in jamun.
Harshavardhan (2011) recorded the highest numbers of leaves (8.67) per graft under polyhouse condition during October in jackfruit.
Sivudu et al., (2014a) reported a significantly higher number of leaves (17.34) in a natural ventilated polyhouse in mango. Similarly, another study carried out by
Sivudu et al., (2014b) reported the highest number of leaves (24.60) per graft under open conditions and highest leaf area (478.96 cm
2) per graft under naturally ventilated polyhouse. A study reported that the maximum number of leaves (12) was recorded on grafts kept under red shade net and the minimum number of leaves on grafts kept under blue shade net (8.22) in jamun
(Anushma et al., 2014).
Graft height
The various growth parameters such as the number of sprouts, number of leaves, leaf area,
etc. determine the rate of photosynthesis and photosynthate accumulation that is ultimately required for the growth of graft. Various researchers reported that the graft height was generally observed higher in protected and controlled conditions
. A study reported that the maximum graft height was observed under red polyhouse which was significantly superior to open conditions in jamun (Hema
Nair et al., 2002). Patel et al., (2010) studied softwood grafting in different growing conditions
viz. polyhouse, nethouse and open conditions in which the highest graft height was observed in polyhouse (32.05 cm) followed by nethouse (27.35 cm) and lowest in open condition (21.99 cm). A study conducted by
Sivudu et al., (2014a) reported the highest graft height (17.92 cm) under naturally ventilated polyhouse followed by a partial shade under coconut (17.62 cm) and shade net 50 per cent (17.59 cm) while the lowest graft height (17.03 cm) was recorded by grafting under the open condition in mango.
Graft union success and survival
Various researchers revealed that higher success of grafting under protected structures was due to congenial conditions that prevent the desiccation of scion and stock which results in better graft union formation and ultimately higher graft success and faster growth. In general, callus formation is better in protected structures due to suitable climatic conditions. The difference in graft success under different color structures might be attributed to variation in the light quality, photosynthesis, temperature and relative humidity
(Hasanein et al., 2011). Low-cost poly-cum-net tunnel (with polythene sheet covering a shade net) resulted in the highest recovery of grafts (90.87%) and graftable rootstocks (95.02%) in cashew (
Anacardium occidentale L.)
(Lingaiah et al., 2000). Baghel et al., (2002) reported the best success and survival of mango grafts under polyhouse conditions compared to open conditions.
A study conducted by
Sundari and Reddy (2003) reported the highest graft success (50.10 to 59.81%) in cashew under fifty per cent partial shade condition compared to complete shade or open condition.
Sagvekar et al., (2005) observed significantly higher grafting success under polyhouse as compared to open conditions in cashew cv. Vengurla-4.
Visen et al., (2010) reported that the maximum graft success was observed in the greenhouse (81.71%) and minimum in open field conditions while performing an experiment in guava cv. Allahabad Safeda, Lucknow 49 and Lalit. A softwood grafting performed in jamun reported that the grafting performed in open condition gave significantly the highest survival (75.35%) of grafts
(Shinde et al., 2010). Patel et al., (2010) found that graft success was better under polyhouse as compared to other conditions in softwood grafting in Khasi mandarin.
Harshavardhan (2011) noticed the highest per cent of graft success under polyhouse conditions during October in coastal Andhra conditions in jackfruit. A study conducted by
Gurjar and Singh (2012) reported the maximum graft survival in polyhouse (98.30%) as compared to open field conditions (76%) while performing wedge grafting in anola during March. A study conducted by
Sivudu et al., (2014a) observed the highest graft success under naturally ventilated polyhouse (71.27%) and lowest in open condition (62.06%) in veneer grafting in mango. In another study, the highest percentage of survival of mango grafts was recorded under naturally ventilated polyhouse (67.18%) and lowest under open condition (57.41%)
(Sivudu et al., 2014b). Anushma et al., (2014) studied the effect of colored shade nets (white, red, black, green and blue) on the success of softwood grafting in jamun and reported that the grafts kept under red coloured shade net resulted in significantly higher graft success (72.50%) and graft survival (96.87%) whereas significantly least graft success (47.50%) and graft survival (92.71%) was recorded in the grafts kept under blue shade net and white shade net respectively
(Anushama et al., 2014).